THE MORTALITY EXPERIENCE OF AMERICAN MISSIONARIES BY NATHAN WILLEY. BEING A COMPLETE RECORD OF THE MORTALITY EXPERIENCE OF THE FOREIGN MISSIONARIES OF THE A. B. C. F. M., FROM ITS ORGANIZATION TO JULY 1, 1873, AS COMPARED WITH THE AMERICAN EXPERIENCE” TABLE OF MORTALITY. PRICE, 50 CENTS. UNPUBLISHED FROM THE INSURANCE MONITOR, NOVEMBER, 1873, 176 Broadway. Entered according to act of Congress, in the year 1873, by C. C. Hine, in the Office of the Libra- rian of Congress at Washington, I). C. the ]£ diktat J'rHtermtg. Tf this pamphlet is noticed or criti- cized by yon, please send a copy of yonr paper to this office. C. C. Httstr. 1711 BROADWAY, V. Y. MORTALITY EXPERIENCE OF AMERICAN MISSIONARIES. NATHAN WILLEY. The following tables comprise a record of the mortality expe- rience of over 1,000 missionaries of the A. B. C. F. M., including more than 13,000 years’ service, mostly in foreign lands. The original data from which these tables were compiled were pre- pared by Bev. John A. Vinton, of Winchester, Massachusetts. Mr. Vinton has spent several years in preparing statistical infor- mation of this kind for the Board, and but few men ever lived more competent to execute such a task. These tables embrace all the missions established by the Board since its organization. In some cases, missions have been trans- ferred to other Boards, as the Presbyterian and Beformed Dutch, and from that time the A. B. C. F. M. lias had no further control over them. Missions have also been discontinued, as in the Sand- wich Islands and Borneo. In these cases the data furnished do not generally extend beyond the period of transfer or discontin- uance. In preparing these tables, the compiler was furnished with cards containing the name, place and date of birth, date of em- barkation, of death, release, or return to this country, and the field of labor of each missionary. In a very few instances the date of birth was not given, but the number of years of exposure was al- ways ascertained. In such cases the average expected mortality of the known ages exposed in each locality was found, and the ad- ditional mortality from the unknown ages, found by a simple pro- portion, was added to it. It will be noticed that there is a great difference in the mortal- ity in different parts of the globe. In Western Africa, Southern India, Southern China, and the Indian Archipelago, the mortality has been from three to nearly seven times as great as the Ameri- can Experience Tables indicate, while in the Sandwich Islands and in Southern Africa the aggregate mortality has been less. In the Sandwich Islands, though lying within the tropics, the mountain- ous nature of the country enables foreigners to select places of res- idence where the air is as mild as in the mountains of Tennessee; and in South Africa, the mission stations are on an elevated pla- teau, where the climate is as healthy and salubrious as in West Virginia. But in all that belt of country commencing with Turkey, and extending eastward and southward through Syria, Persia, India, and Southern China, and especially in the Indian ocean, the mor- tality of American missionaries has been excessive, as a glance at the Recapitulation Table will show. In these countries, fevers and the cholera have caused a large ratio of the deaths, while only a very small number have died by violence. One important and instructive feature in these tables is the comparative mortality of males and females. In all the unhealthy countries, with the singular exception of Persia, the mortality among women is much greater than among men. This may be partly accounted for by the younger age of embarkation and the less previous exposure to hardship. Among the missionaries to Turkey, the mortality among females who embarked under the age of twenty-five has been about two-aml-a-half times as great as among those who were older at the time of leaving home. Among the female lives in the Sandwich Islands, we find eleven deaths between the ages of twenty-five and thirty-nine inclusive, while the tabular mortality calls tor a fraction over six. We find also a good illustration of the influence of climatic dif- ferences upon northern men and women living in the Southern States. In the missions among the Cherokee and Choctaw Indians, in the States of Georgia, Mississippi, Arkansas, and the Indian Ter- ritory, the mortality of males is about 44 per cent., and of females 4G per cent, greater than the tabular rate. Another circumstance which will make these tables of great practical value to our life insurance companies, is the fact that nearly all these lives are from the Northern States, not more than one or two per cent, being from the south or foreign countries. We cannot assert that these tables give the total mortality of the American missionaries arising from their foreign residence. In many cases, finding that health and usefulness were ruined, the missionary bade farewell to his chosen field and returned to die in his native land. If his recovery was deemed impossible, he sev- ered his connection from the Board, and his subsequent record does not appear in this table. Neither have we any account of those whose health, though permanently injured, was just sufficient to enable them to linger for a few years till prematurely cut off by death, after they had left the Board and engaged in other pursuits. To obtain the total mortality which has resulted, directly and indi- rectly, from missionary life, would require more elaborate data. 5 H Total yrs. Add ages unknown. 82833:J3SS3;i33§S3S82382SSS3gSSSS2Sfe!fc:3£g}fc&SftSg8gaS8S882S2883#KSSSB8S3 AGE. e » So 1 '• 1 ’•••••’• " MMUMM-MUMM^WWa«COM«^^4kCiOi5iCir.S^5.r< • • • • V 1 Ye*n‘- 3 ft to - - ••••••••**;• X ••• • ; * CO- • • O O X * CCwiMMOiTCOC:- • X; • • • Months. ' 11 H P3 — 8 Of . i •••••••••*•••••••• • S • • • • • • ’ • i t i ! • jo ’ • • • to • • • * CO • • • ’ t$ • • • • • • • • • : 2: : Expected Mor- tality. £ M o>- CD to a ••••••►■*•••• • • • • • • • • • • Actual Mortal- ity. it 1 130 ss s : • ’ : ' • : : : • ’ : : : : : : ’ ■ Years. 3 * r. a CO CO * * • • ; • • • • • • • • • • citoor* • co • • • • -3 x • • ct-3tox-3>-*tocDj o j • • -o 2 Months. o 0 K R i 1 immmmm Expected Mor- tality. r H Cd CD CO or j j j : r : Actual Mortal- ity- o c Si 1 1 :::::: : i i : : »««>*«> mot c-.=: a a>co:c;cti- . . . • Tc„.. «g| CO CO • I C; ;;; O- ; j ! . . CO CO X • • CO; £ j S • COOtOt* • • • X; • • X © • M-ioiCtMCMClW- • • • • Months, | | o K *U iu -1 *0 1 \wM\mm\% U1 in U ih h |H ; iM!! aM M i;! M1; M n M M Expected Mor- tality. s § " CT i M i; i M ;;; M j ~j Actual Mortal- ity. * § § Years. s rq" 3 M » i i i::: j j ij ' i j - : : : ! * *® * **' : : ■ *-*■: » -*■ • • CO X •—1; • • *-*■' I © -3 £ j CO © ’ Of X • • • Months, j | o n K o > CO O w 3 -j CO I n n n n u • •! n u in: §i n in h in n in i 8: i M l; 1M iM i i i; M a- M H Expected Mor- tality. ► t* PJ a CO CO Actual Mortal- ity. 6 Total.. | Total yra.| Add ages! unknown AGE. j 1351 » 1 • : : : : : ■ MISK(0 1SKIOKIO»»iUt^^ 1u»: : : '• Years. Years of Expos- ure. 13 ; ; • • • • c • • • * • • • • hac* • • os • • ax *o ha ! ax• • • o• ax• ccotc* go -3 cc co ha . Months. g 15.6214 5 1 WlWmimm • • M. • • • • H* • • • • ha • ’• • • l-1 • • • • i3 • • • • 02 • • • • |-a • * • • | • • • Expected Mor- tality. rt OQ ro X- M Jg : : : i i : ! j : : j i i ! i ! ! • M- 1 ! ! ha I • ! • • ! ha • 13 *3 • HA j • *3 j • • HA • COHl3HHi j • • • • • • • Actual Moital- ity. d S3 | d 2 g : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : • l-‘l-‘»ONl»S»OC0 6545.*.*.OiO«OlO>C:-aOlCw®S»SgSS““ofegSS£-S3oS£Sfe»Sg^CTi-‘: Years. 0 SCD 3 M » H ha GO Oil CO j j Oa | ! CiCHA* ! CO GO © C* • HA j COHCHQwj O © © Xa Xx XX 05 ■ CO -3 CO 13 © i3 Months. • *0 3 2 0 »=d H § © mmmmnmmf n in H in n in h in n 1 m i;!!! in n i: i n Expected Mor- tality. ► r* rt oi * g ha* ! | j ’ j j ! | ! j ha! | j | | ha! ! ! t-i! ha! j3haha! ha! ha! ! ! Actual Mortal- ity. 1 368 « 1 HMJ3l3i3}3M^.ltAGiGlC;C:C5-3-3XJC0OOt3(Xj;a-33CO7:OO7:»ir.C«CG»C0)3H Years. h; S d2 3 * 5 O 05 t-> • ■ • *. fe j *S ; tcj • l-ij • 50 13 • • -1 • • 0D :C -q • d CT -3 lb. -3 • S>-CifcOi-jr. ; ; Months. • *0 cc O c g 3.7327 CO 1 ax : : : i i i § H *;: H in N iM n sN M IN H i! N1 s: M ill! M Expected Mor- tality. w CO -3 -3 i M M M M M M H H M M M M M: H N M M M M M H i M ~M M M M M H Actual Mortal- ity- CO , Hj ! a g S 1 *t ::: : — 1_ _u_n-i~t-ii-n-ii-5i-ii-ii-i»BO:eoi<5.*.o»ae~l-j-q-3!oSS*i5i6G83s“S«si5S««G«C)»»B*s. • Years. 2 H g > GO GO ! ! ! ! ! ! ! . ! *-a ha ! 05! ha! co! ! ! go* 01 ’• aiowoooMrfAHAMowo-iMOi; ; Months. 2 0^ R K CO CO 1 s mnmmmmnhi ::s::::S:!:ij5:::ii::::i&::::2::::3!::i2::::: : : zj- : : : d: : : : g: : : : g: : :£:::: rj: : Expected Mor- tality. ► f M po CO CO ::: j j :::::::::: : *! -*• j ■ Actual Mortal- ity. 7 Total.. Total yrs. Add ages unknown 233233S538SS2S8SS3SS2S3S8S£££&££&ftS3S3g&S£88g28gS!$S8£88!S8SS AGE. 1 s I : : : : : : • : ' : MMMM^MMMMwB5.o.wB.o>o.oiaotaa = sa?5»aS!b»K003COtBts«^M: Years. isf CO *-*■ JO • * '* I • * : • 1 S • • ’ • • • • • • • • • • ; • • • • • CO j CC; CO :© • GO O • GoSoSjOJOCOOrfk.00; • • •* Months. 11 K to 1 (O 3 \\\i\m\mmmmmi\\mmm\ Expected Mor- tality. ft B • ••*••••• •••.•••••• *©• :::::::: • • * • *©• • ••••• • Actual Mortal- ity. TJ M 5 S 1 ;;; i i; H • : • : : ' • • • • * : • : : • • • ! • • ’ ! • : • Years. SB’S P - - O; • • O®; • -J; ; mm! j .fcSOtOOHWl-'OMi-*; OS • *S j • • Months. j? * i 2 s ?: m i m m m m m m n gw: 11: m in! i in m iNi sm m Expected Mor- tality. 1 CT : : : i •;:: : : i i i i = : ; : : i-I —: i ;:: Actual Mortal- ity- >— 1 — 05 8 S ; H-‘*a*SCOCOCOMMCOOiasOSOS-aaO-sS E2> — ft a 1 Years. s = P- JO 00 05 • • • • • • • • | j • • SC—; • *-• • ' O CT CO *• JO 2 SC -3 I-1 i >C -s ft .U SO • >OCS'-‘COSCClCcBBB-}COOC>i-‘i-‘a>OoftftooCsBcO Months. I! J giP 0> o» :::::: a: :::::: s: i an: i i; n; i: i i im n i si; i i i; : i i ai m am i im: *n i i in=i Expected Mor- tality. 1 £g s 5 & j : j j i m! : T Actual Mortal- ity- 8 Total..! Total yrs. Add ages unknown. GO X or GO -q -1 -1 -1 -1 -1 -1 -1 -1 05 05 05 05 05 05 05 05 05 05 CT OT OT OT CT CT or CT CT CT -u cc CO CO CO CO CO CO CO CO CC M) JO iO tc to ro tc C0t0»-iO«00«4l05 0i^C0tC( 0f4lC0i0H-.O^G0 AGE. CO o GO | 3 £ j • \* ►—1Ltotststotstc|tststctoco ' Years. K S teg m g £* e-* 1 Of t-1 1 j ; ; i i : : : i : i i i i 1 i i j j j i i ; : i cc! • 4- Oi -QK -3 CO • CO • • t» GO • O Of 00- • • 05 ->3 45*. 4-*. GO • • • M1 45. CO • Months. ; •*' X? QD 1 I® CO Ot g iC 1 CO tO tu 1 or i j i ::: 8 • * §3 * * * * * : : : |! : j g| i j j g! 1 I : i! i : j Expected Mor- tality. ► r1 rt QD XU O CO 1 | 1 “1 :::::::::: : • : |-t: j i -I j: j i j -j i -i ; mm • ! ; i i j '• i i ; i Actual Mortal- ity. a s § Of • ’• • . t£*-£‘-4^£*.£‘-£k-05-QGCO^l-fctStSi-‘';0-3-3Ce05£»-t5»-ii-». • • Years. K< S rara 3 Mg o tq l-H 00 j j j | oo J : j : • -3 CO -3 5C • COtsj • O5C0O5*-k‘ GO 50 ©t • • • • Months. |o M Si > 05 50 to ►u. 05 • *•••-• .... ; j ; ; ! ; ; I g; . • • CO • • • • • • lO • • • • CO • • • i O • • S • • • • • Expected Mor- tality. ► t-* rt cc GO ►-1 -1 j j j : | m! j ; i • • to ; ts • »- *; ; j j j -j i ; j j • : j j ; Actual Mortal- ity. 05 05 j • • • • • • ; • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • j • Years. Years of Expos- ure. CO -1 : : : : CT: :::: : • • M O O • 05 05 O ►—1 • -*3 5© CO —3 05 Months. 05 05 *05 f 05 1 :.::::: 1 : : |:. : : '. • : i : |: i 11 gi! j i |M ; i sj: i: h i; j Expected Mor- tality. | Si o CO CO | = 1 ! E = = = = = = !! = : f = = : = = ::«! *: 1 : ! 1 M 1 i : : M i : -j : j -j : i ; : i : j i : i | Actual Mortal- ity. w H K C5 £l • • | • • • • • • • • •• • • • • • • • • • Years. H1 g o 50 | CO i h = M i i : ! ! i i : : i : i : i • i i i i : i j j j S£: ! *-‘-3* Ot • 05 • O CO CO j GO GO • • j | Months. • T3 cc O 05 O tel « w ro 5 > 05 II b» to i;::: i::: i: i i i i i; M ; |M M |M M I- : : : g: : : : S: • • : a • • Expected Mor- tality. - 1 i: | i M: U M! M M: 1H H • M N N M h jMu 1 jMHM j | Actual Mortal- ity. 9 82 83 Total yrs. Add ages unknown Total..! 2S333a3£3d23£S33SSS3283S3£SZSS2S£&5£&*S&££33g3S£3£S3£ggtt!S£8£8B!2SSS > S3 M 1 * im : M»»»ai^^^eSSSS:ssSSSSxS»S8SaaeaSSSSSSSSSSSa£aSSSSSS88d6SSaSS£e>Wi : Years. m ?s. CO o» • : o: : ;' -a *-‘ • £ o* • ®~• eo • ®0»• £ c« .&. co -j co j or .u co 1 eo ►- © j -q j cci-*j Months. 2 CO $ o gM 13 c S i III; • • • *-»■.' . • • is • . • to • • • jo • • • • to • • • • 65 • • • • >-*■ • • • * h* i l • . I ‘ l . #o • • • • H-i! 1 l I ! i i ! mmmmm mmmmmmm^in Expected Mor- tality. ► ! GO s| I j -j = i i -I ii i i; M i i i : — ; • i —i i i - J■ -j :: -j j j ; ;; j j Actual Mortal- ity. £ all! _i_ii-ijOMCoi£>..fe.CTO"CiOT;n-q;c©>-!u©©©ocxooaox3*Soi©lqiqi3,£oc©(Scoac:c?©oc©ii©2g:22SSS©2joiq©©.&.*i>»«! Years. o co -a : : 3? ’ ’. | j j •' j • ’• j • • ►-* -3 • -3 *-*; • C7T • ’• * • C5 35 -3 CC • • Cl' • • Months. n IS i JS : : : § H; 1 n 11H i in NII n in H in H in n in H in HII n in n in U in i i Expectec tality. Mor- ; 1 0 5 i;;; 1 i; i:! i; i11 i • i i i; i;1 i i1! i;;; Actual Mortal- ity. 1 i ■~ • • Years. tU -3 • • ' ‘ ’ ’ • '. • | | • • • • »t*. JO CT • —3; • • • • *• O j tO • Or • ’ Months. :n o la. 6954 (C • • i m n! im i i in n in n in n an M im i im; in n sm i; im i in i im n Expected Mor- tality. J 1 gra to> t-i'. ! : i ;■ i i i i i°* i i : i i ’ ‘ : i : Actual Mortal- ity. 1 2 1|;[: : 1 : ; : MW^MMMMMhiHUBoicioiSTa-jooc3!CcSooH“j45!sMM»»M2!fc5xS£®-;co^(4(o»«c»woca;is; Y ears. i*i ?°o a 00 011 : : : I . * '. CO* • • • • • • • * • CCOO- • • iO *X> • • • ; • • to* 50* • • • «oj C:-3* • Months. -n ? 00 g o> -J I : ; ; 1 Mi H n H H in H sH!! gu:! in M iH N si! H sM!! in H ill N iH!! in 11 Expected Mor- tality. 1 t> 3 si; n ;;;1; M M ;; i I i: —; i 1 i 1 i i i i 11 i‘~;; i;:;;; i ; ~S: II —-1;:;;:;; Actual Mortal- ity. 10 Males. Females. Number oflives. Years of exposure. Expected mortality. Actual mortality. Ratio of actual to expected mortality. Number of lives. Years of exposure. Expected mortality. Actual mortality. Ratio of actual to expected mortality. Western Africa, River Gaboon, and Cape Palmas 19 151.2 1.5747 8 5.0803 20 136.6 1.1897 8 6.7244 South Africa 21 303.3 4.4272 5 1.1294 21 357. 3.6267 3 .8272 Turkey and Greece 104 1351.2 15.6112 24 1.5344 126 1201.7 11.2359 28 2.4920 Syria 27 308.10 3.7327 7 1.8753 40 351.4 3.2994 9 2.7278 Persia 23 255.3 2.6772 11 4.1088 24 247.1 2.2268 5 2.2454 India, Ceylon, Madura, Madras, Siam, and Indian Archipelago 127 1636.11 19.6963 42 2.1324 147 1478.2 16.7741 55 3.2789 South China 22 308.4 3 5027 8 2.2840 17 191.8 1.6932 8 4.7248 North China 14 161.9 1.6346 3 1.8353 13 141.9 1.6156 1 .6190 Sandwich Islands and Micronesia 78 1537.3 22.9690 18 .7837 76 1491.10 21.6992 17 .7871 Cherokee and Choctaw Indians 01 823.4 9 6954 14 1.4133 39 663.1 8.2018 12 1.4631 Total 496 6957.3 85.5510 140 1.6365 | 523 6260. 71.4624 146 2.0488 RECAPITULATION. MORTALITY STATISTICS—MISSIONARIES A. B. C. F. M. 11 In preparing the foregoing tables, it has occurred to the writer that it might lie of great importance to the cause of Foreign Mis- sions, as well as for the information of the public at large, that careful and accurate statistics of the health, exposure, and mortal- ity of the foreign missionaries should be prepared. When we take into consideration the years of constant study and the initial ex- pense of fitting one for this field of labor; the difficulty in finding the right class of men, who are willing to peril their lives and health in this cause, at a time when wealthy congregations are willing to pay liberally for their services at home; and especially the fact that the majority of them return with impaired health after a few years’ exposure—the value of a single life rises to an impor- tance which it is impossible for us to estimate in money, and the subject of knowing their sanitary and mortality experience, and of discovering such methods as will enable them to prolong their lives and usefulness, becomes a matter which ought to concern all who take an interest in the cause. These tables also suggest the question whether some investiga- tions should not be made, or statistical information obtained, to lessen the great excess of mortality among the female lives, lu nearly all the mission fields the female mortality is from thirty to fifty per cent, greater than among males, which is far greater than the corresponding mortality among the sexes in the United States. It seems as if it would be but an act of justice towards that sex which makes the greatest sacrifices, who lead silent and uncom- plaining lives among so much that is repugnant and disgusting to their finer sensibilities, that the causes which have produced this excess of mortality should be thoroughly investigated, and, if pos- sible, measures taken to avoid it in the future.