MEASURING NURSING RESOURCES FEDERAL SECURITY AGENCY PUBLIC HEALTH SERVICE DIVISION OF MEDICAL 0 HOSPITAL RESOURCES DIVISION OF NURSING RESOURCES MEASURING NURSING RESOURCES 1/ CONTENTS Page Introduction 1 Section I# Estimating the Number of Nursing Personnel Currently Employed . 7 Introduction 7 Public Health • • . 8 Industry • • . • 9 Offices and Private Practice . .... 10 Hospitals 17 Summary: Section I 23 Section II. Estimating the Number of Nursing Personnel Required to Meet Current and Future Needs 2£ Introduction. 2£ Public Health . 26 Industry ••••..••. 29 Offices and Private Practice .33 Hospitals 35 Introductory Statement 35 General and Allied Special Hospitals ... 37 Tuberculosis Hospitals 61 Mental Hospitals 6h Chronic Hospitals .68 Total number of nursing personnel needed in hospitals 70 Summary 72 Summary: Section II* . . 73 l/,Prepared by Lois E. Gordner, Nurse Officer (R), Public Health Service, ~ Federal Security Agency, Washington, D.C. Page Section III. Planning to Meet the Needs for Nursing Personnel. ... 80 Introduction . 80 Educational Qualifications of Nursing Personnel Currently Snployed. ....81 Basic Professional Programs (Diploma and/or Degree Programs for Undergraduate Student Nurses). ...... 90 Advanced Professional Programs (Programs for Graduate Nurses Leading to a Degree). . 97 Approved Training Programs for Non-Professional Nursing Personnel 99 Financial Support for Preparing Nursing Personnel • . .101 Computing the Annual Number of Students who must be Enrolled in Basic Schools of Nursing and Training Programs for Non-Professional Nursing Personnel to meet Estimated Needs 102 Computing the Average Percent of High School Graduates who must be Enrolled in Nursing Programs to Produce the Number of Nursing Personnel Needed • • .108 Summary: Section III 110 ii - FEDERAL SECURITY AGENCY PUBLIC HEALTH SERVICE l/yashington 2£, D, C, August 4, 1949 Col. J. J. McNinch Director Army & Medical Library 7th and Independence Ave. Ifliashington 25, D. C. Dear Col. McNinch: Enclosed is a copy of “Measuring Nursing Resources'*, prepared by Miss Lois E, Gordner, hospital nursing consultant, of our staff. This is intended as a guide to a method for nurses and others who contemplate studies to determine nursing needs and resources on an area basis. It represents to date the method that has evolved as a result of assistance given by the Public Health Service to several States in measuring their nursing resources. Copies are available upon request. Sincerely yours, Lucile Retry Chief Nurse Officer Public Health Service J. R, McGibony, Medical Director Chief, Division of Medical and Hospital Resources Enclosure - Page Example of a covering letter to accompany a mailed questionnaire Example of a covering letter to accompany a mailed questionnaire to employers of nursing personnel in offices • • • . • 12 Questionnaires !• Self-addressed, stamped post card to be mailed to individual employers of nursing personnel in offices • 13 2, Self-addressed, stamped post card to be mailed to the registrar of individual licensed nurses’ registries 3* Mailed questionnaire to individual hospitals to obtain a record of the number of nursing personnel currently employed 21 h* Mailed questionnaire to individual hospitals selected to participate In a sample study of general hospitals to obtain: Record of the number of administrative nursing personnel on duty . i|2 Record of nursing personnel giving direct patient care during 2i+ hours. k3 5. Mailed questionnaire to individual hospitals to obtain: Record of the educational qualifications of graduate professional nurses currently emploved 65 Record of the educational qualifications of non-professional nursing personnel currently employed 86 Worksheets Worksheets to be used in conjunction with Questionnaire its Worksheet 1 - Summary of data relative to the ratios of administrative nursing personnel to daily average patient census (including newborn) in (Hospital A), on (Date: month, day, year) fag Page Worksheet 2 - Summary of data relative to hours of bedside care per patient in 2k hours and ratio of professional to non-professional nursing personnel giving this direct patient care in (Hospital A) on (fhte: month, day, year) 1*8 Worksheet 3 - Summary of data relative to hours of bedside care per patient in 21* hours and ratio of professional to non-professional nursing personnel giving this direct patient care according to size of hospitals 53 Formulae 1* Current unit of population per public health staff nurse 26 2. Number of public health staff nurses required to meet the selected standard of population unit per nurse • . • • 27 3* Number of public health nurses in supervisory positions required to meet the standard for staff nurses per supervisor. 28 k» Estimated future daily average patient census 36 5* Ratios of administrative nursing personnel to daily average patient census (including newborn) .... 1*6 6a. Equivalent number of patients cared for by other than hospital staff in a 2ii hour period • • • • • i*9 6b. Adjusted census (patients cared for by hospital staff in a 21* hour period) 1*9 7* Average hours of nursing care per patient in 2li hours 50 8. Hours of bedside care per patient by type of nursing personnel 5l 9. Ratio of Professional to Non-Professional nursing personnel giving direct patient care 52 10. Number of administrative nursing personnel required per day to meet the selected standard of daily average patient census (including newborn) per type of admin- istrative nursing personnel in general and. allied special hospitals on a State-wide basis •••••••• 55 Page 11a* Number of bedside nursing personnel required per day to meet the selected standard of average hours of bedside care per patient in 2k hours in general and allied special hospitals on a State-wide basis ... 56 11b. Number of professional or non-professional bedside nursing personnel required per day to meet the selected ratio of professional nurses or non-profes- sional nursing personnel to total nursing personnel giving bedside care in general and allied special hospitals on a State-wide basis 56 12a. Number of nursing personnel required to replace the contribution made to nursing service by basic professional student nurses 58 12b. Number of graduate professional nurses or non- professional nursing personnel required to replace the contribution made to nursing service by basic professional student nurses 58 13. Total number of nursing personnel needed in hospitals ........ 71 Tables 1. Estimated number of nurses employed by public health agencies in (State x), (date) • • • 9 2. Estimated number of nurses employed by industrial establishments (State x), (date) 10 3. Estimated number of nursing personnel employed in offices in (State x), (date) lii U. Estimated number of nursing personnel engaged in private practice, registered in and employed through licensed nurses' registries in (State x), (date) • • • . 1? 5. Estimated number of nursing personnel enployed by (registered and unregistered or registered only) hospitals (exclusive of or including Federal hospitals) in (State x), (date) • ••••••••... 22 6. Estimated number of nursing personnel currently employed in (State x), (date) 23 7. An estimated of the current and future number of nurses needed by public health agencies in (State x) . . 29 Tables Page 8* An estinate of the number of nurses needed by- industrial establishments in (State x), (date) 31 9, An estimate of the current and future number of nurses needed by industrial establishments in (State x) • • 32 10. An estimate of the current and future number of nursing personnel needed in (offices or private practice) in (State x) 3h 11. An estimate of the number of nursing personnel currently needed per day by general and allied special hospitals (exclusive of or including Federal hospitals) in (State x), (Date) . • • • 60 12. An estimate of the number of nursing personnel currently needed per day by (registered and unregistered or registered only) tuberculosis hospitals (exclusive of or including Federal Hospitals) in (State x), (Date). . • • • 63 13* An estimate of the number of nursing personnel currently needed per day by (registered and unregistered or registered only) mental hospitals (exclusive of or including Federal hospitals) in (State x), (Date) 6? lk» An estimate of the number of nursing personnel currently needed per day by (registered and unregistered or registered only) chronic hospitals (exclusive of or including Federal hospitals) in (State x), (Date) 69 An estimate of the total number of nursing personnel currently needed by (registered and unregistered or registered only) hospitals (exclusive of or including Federal hospitals) in (State x), (Date) 72 16. An estimate of the total number of nursing personnel needed in the future by hospitals (exclusive of or including Federal hospitals) in (State x), (future date). 72 17• An estimate of the number of nursing personnel required to meet current (date) and future (date) needs in (State x) 73 18. An estimate of current deficits of nursing personnel in (State x), (Date) 7A Tables. Page 19* Educational qualifications of full-time nurses employed by public health agencies in (State x), (Date) 81 20. Educational qualifications of full-time registered nurses employed by industry in (State x), (Date) ... 83 21. Educational qualifications of graduate professional nurses employed by (registered and unregistered or registered only) hospitals (exclusive of or including Federal hospitals) in (State x), (Date). ••••••• 88 22. Educational qualifications of non-professional nursing personnel employed by (registered and unregistered or registered only) hospitals (exclusive of or including Federal hospitals) in (State x), (Date) ... 89 Charts 1. Probable sources of information for obtaining an estimate of the number of nursing personnel currently employed in a State according to place of service • • • 2h 2. Suggested criteria and probable sources for obtaining essential information for estimating the number of nursing personnel required to meet current and future needs on a State-wide basis 75 3. Questions, probable sources for obtaining information, and references pertinent to an overall gross evalua- tion of the present system of nursing education in a State according to type of program 112 - vii - Introduction During "the past ten years the demands for nursing services have been unprecedented. Some of the major developments which have contributed to these increasing needs are: the rapid expansion of prepayment hospital plans; Increased emphasis on early diagnosis; greater awareness of the preventive aspects of disease; acceptance of the relationship between physi- cal and mental states; and recent discoveries in drugs and medical therapies. The additional number of hospital beds and other health facilities which will become available within the next few years (as a result of construction under the "Hospital Survey and Construction Act" as well as construction outside of this program) will further increase the need for professional and non- professional nursing personnel. The extent and urgency of the situation indicate the necessity of planning on a State and regional basis if the vital needs for nursing services are to be met effectively and economically. The scope of a State survey of nursing needs and resources as described in this Manual Includes the following factors: 1. An estimate of the number of nursing personnel currently employed. 2. An estimate of the number of nursing personnel required to meet current and future needs. 3. An evaluation of the quantitative and qualitative adequacy of the present system of nursing education. U. Recommendations which will improve the quantity and quality of nursing personnel so that current and future needs for nursing personnel can be met effectively and economically. The conclusions of the study will reveal present nursing resources; cur- rent ar>d future need for nursing personnel; current and future deficits of nursing personnel; extent to which the present educational system can quantita- tively and qualitatively meet current and future needs for professional nurses and 2 non-professional nursing personnel; annual number of students who must be enrolled in basic schools of nursing and training programs for non-professional nursing personnel for a specified period of time to meet estimated needs; and the average percent of high school graduates mho must be enrolled in nursing programs to produce the number of nursing personnel needed. These conclusions mill lead to recommendations concerning: 1. The extent to which the nursing service needs of all kinds should and can be met, 2. The kind of educational system which mill produce the type of nursing personnel needed. 3. Methods of financing this educational system. lu Horn the needed number of candidates can be attracted to the schools. £. What community. State, and regional action is necessary to initiate and advance the objectives. The approach to this type of survey (discussed in the following sections) is to be considered only as a guide. It is primarily a method of assembling available data and utilizing existing standards and techniques to emphasize the necessity of comprehensive planning to meet estimated needs for nursing personnel. The limitations apparent in this approach stress the necessity of additional research in nursing. The purpose of the following discussion is to emphasize specific considera- tions. General principles of the survey method will not be mentioned unless there is special significance for a State survey of nursing needs and resources which should be stressed. The Methodology of Educational is but one example from extensive published material which comprehensively presents the techniques of scientific research. 1/ Good, Carter; Barr, A. S.; Scates, Douglas: The Methodology of Educational Research. D. Appleton - Century Company, Inc., New York, 19i*l. The director of the study should be appointed as soon as the need for the survey has crystallized. This nurse should possess a comprehensive knowledge of professional problems and community health needs, an understanding of present trends in education and the ability to work cooperatively with others. The selection of the individual to direct the study is the responsibility of the nursing organizations of the State. Belated professional organizations (State Medical Association, State Hospital Association, etc.) should concur in the choice The participation of representative committee members in formulating a precise plan for the survey and in initiating and sustaining community interest in the project which will be capable of translating the recommendations into action will largely determine the effectiveness of the project. Committees should be organized as soon as a need for this type of survey has been recognized and expressed. The stimulus for this expression of need may come from a number of sources. It is imperative that all of the groups involved in the study be made a part of the project from the initial phase# This widely representative group will function more effectively if organized into advisory, executive, and technical committees. Advisory Committee The advisory committee should include State representatives from: Nursing organizations; related fields; and consumers of nursing service# Appropriate members in these three categories are: 1# Nursing Organizations a# Nurses* Association b# League of Nursing Education c. Organization for Public Health Nursing d. Board of Nurse Examiners e. Organization for Non-professional nursing personnel. 2. Related Fields a. Medical Association b. Hospital Association c* Agency administering Hospital Surrey and Planning Program d. Board of Health ©. Department of Education (Vocational, Secondary, and Higher Education) 3* Consumers of Nursing Service a* Federated Woman's Club b. Parent-Teacher Association c. Industry (management, labor) d. Farm groups e• Press Executive Committee The Executive Committee may be chosen from the Advisory Committee. It Is advisable to limit this group to 5 - 7 members* The members should be selected on the basis of ability, pertinent knowledge, and administrative effectiveness. The function of this committee Is to facilitate the progress of the survey and to be readily available for consultation with the director of the study. Technical Committee The Technical Committee should be composed of professional nurses with specialized interests, since a large part of the survey involves decisions relative to standards, practices, and policies in the several fields of nursing. Members should represent the following Interests: 5 1* Nursing groups a. Public Health b. Industry c. Offices d. Private Practice e. Men nurses f. Non-professional nursing personnel 2. Clinical fields a* Medical nursing b. Surgical nursing c. Tuberculosis nursing d. Psychiatric nursing e. Nursing care of chronic patients. 3. Educational programs a. Hospital operated school of nursing b. College or university controlled school of nursing c. Advanced professional nursing education program d. Approved training program for non-professional nursing personnel. This group of expert professional personnel is primarily a "working committee". In view of this, the director of the study may find it expedient to appoint sub-committees from the membership to formulate policies and develop material in specified areas (current and future needs for nursing personnel in hospitals, construction of questionnaires, etc.) for the consideration of the technical committee as a whole. 6 It is advisable to have the three committees (advisory, executive, technical) meet together at the beginning of the project to formulate the plan and method of the survey. A combined meeting is equally desirable after the necessary data have been compiled and evaluated. At this second meeting it is essential that a majority of the membership concur with the analysis, accept the implications, and make definite plans to activate the recommendations. In the interim between the two meetings, distribution of the minutes of all the individual committees1 meetings to the entire membership will keep the various committees informed of the others1 activities. There are certain practical factors which must be considered in making a detailed plan within the defined scope of the survey. Such matters as time, money, and personnel must be faced realistically in the planning stage of the project* If a deadline must be met, if funds are limited, clerical assistance is inadequate, it is essential to acknowledge the handicap and devise the most effective plan possible to fulfill the objectives of the survey. It is reemphasized that the effectiveness of the survey relies to a great extent upon the acceptance and support of the groups concerned. It is important that the report be written with consideration for varying back- grounds and diversity of Interests. The recommendations of the survey should be reviewed periodically. This appraisal at specified intervals will accomplish two purposes. First, it will reveal the progress made toward achievement of the stated objectives. Second, it will provide a means by which the objectives can be modified in terms of emerging msdical, social and economic trends. SECTION I. ESTIMATING THE NUMBER OF NURSING PERSONNEL CURRENTLY EilPLOYSD In an appraisal of nursing needs and resources, the number of nursing personnel currently employed should be estimated as accurately as possible. Esti- mates should include both professional nurses and non-professional nursing personnel. It is suggested that data on nursing personnel be limited to those individuals who give direct care to patients* It is desirable to assemble the final estimate according to "place of service**. Such a classification should includes public health , industry, private practice, offices, hospitals, and "others**. This last category includes nurses employed by professional nursing organizations, nurses* registries, county institu- tions, college infirmaries, nursery schools, etc. The preceding classification is indicated because the sources for obtaining the required data vary, and the existing standards for nursing care are applicable to specific fields of nursing* To arrive at an estimated total, existing data should be used whenever avail- able. An example is the recent count and classification of professional registered nurses made by the American Nurses' Association. This is probably the most complete enumeration of professional nurses per State available. Reports can be obtained from the State Board of Nurse Examiners or the American Nurses* Association (1790 Broadway, New York City, N.Y.). If additional data are desired, interviews, conferences, and questionnaires are methods to be considered* Held visits are generally more satisfactory in obtaining homogeneous data than information received through mailed questionnaires. Conversation is conducive to greater uniformity in the collected data because of the opportunity to clarify and interpret the information desired. Homogeneity is more difficult to achieve in a mailed questionnaire despite the most thoughtfully phrased and explicit instructions* If a mailed questionnaire is unavoidable every effort should be made to facili- tate the receipt of the necessary data. A favorable response wLlldbpend to a large extent on the following factors* a covering letter which embodies the purpose of the survey, contains an endorsement from appropriate professional organizations, and gives assurance that the data, obtained will be considered confidential; concise inquiries clearly defined and easily answered; and the enclosure of a self-addressed, stamped envelope or post card. A plan of “follow up“ for unreturned questionnaires is in>- portant. An effective method is a telephone reminder from the local group concerned with the data requested. The following discussion will present for each classification! 1. probable sources of existing information 2. sample questionnaires and tables 3* certain factors which will influence the collection, compilation, and/or interpretation of the material. Public Health A yearly census of public health nurses in each State can be obtained from the State Department of Health. This count is current as of January first. The number of public health nurses employed can be obtained for each county or as a State total. It is possible to obtain the number of nurses employed! by type of public health agency (State health department, local departments of health, boards of education, other official agencies, norv-official agencies, and schools of nursing); and by type of position (supervisory or staff). Each year, the States1 annual census of public health nurses is incorporated into a consolidated report, which provides a comparison among States. The consolidated report can be obtained either from the Division of Nursing, State Department of Health, or by writing directly to the Federal Security Agency, Public Health Service, Office of Public Health Nursing, 4th and C Streets, S.W., Washington 25> D. The following table illustrates how this information might be compiled* Table 1* Estimated number of nurses employed by public health agencies in (State x), (Date) Type of Agency Number of nurses Supervisors Staff Total Official agencies - Boards of education Non-official agencies —————— Sourcet Industry The Division of Nursing, State Department of Health or the State Department of Labor will have information on the number of registered nurses employed full time by industries as of January first of each year* This report shows the type of ser- vice in nhich the nurses are engaged (according to the one to itoich the nurse devotes the most time)* The type of service includes the following categories: in-plant; home or visiting nurse; industrial hospital nurse; personnel department; and con- sultant or advisory nurse* The nurses are further classified by type of position (supervisory and staff)* A consolidated report which provides a comparison among the States, can be obtained either from the above sources or from the Federal Security Agency, Public Health Service, Nursing Section of the Industrial Hygiene Division, 4th and C Streets, S*W*, Washington 25, D* C* Table 2 shows how this material can be assembled* Table 2* Estimated number of nurses employed by industrial establishments in (State x), (Date) Type of Service Number of nurses Supervisors Staff Total - - In-plant Home or visiting nurse Industrial hospital nurse Personnel department - Consultant or advisory nurse - Source: Offices and Private Practice The number of nurses currently employed in these tiro categories is difficult to estimate* The State Nurses1 Association and the State Board of Nurse Examiners are probably the two best sources of information* An analysis of the types of nursing activities of the members of the State Nurses* Association is one basis that can be used* It must be kept in mind, however, that membership in this organization is voluntary and available only to the registered professional nurse* The State Board of Nurse Examiners may have the desired information, if registration in the State requires the registrant to indicate the field of nursing in which currently engaged* It is important to determine whether non-professional nursing personnel are included in the registrants. Whether membership in the State Nurses* Association or regis- tration in the State is used as the basis for making the estimate, there are certain considerations which apply to Doth* These pertain to the number of nurses included in the counts who are inactive or who function outside of this State* If existing data are not sufficient, it may be necessary to secure the information through other means* The best method of obtaining additional information relative to nursing personnel currently employed in offices should be discussed with appropriate State societies (medical,dbntal, etc*)* Such conferences should result in a cooperative plan to obtain the required material* A. subsequent activity of such a meeting might be the participation in this project hy the respective county societies* If a questionnaire is contemplated, the number of licensed physicians, dentists, etc, in the State may indicate the feasibility of a representative sampling rather than a complete canvass* The following questionnaire and the accompanying covering letter is one method that can be used to obtain the desired information* Example of a covering letter to accompany a mailed Questionnaire to employers of nursing personnel in offices* (Dote) (Addressee) Dear (name of individual physician, dentist, etc*) The (State medical, dental, etc*) Association is cooperating with the (name of the group sponsoring the survey) in making a study of the number of nursing personnel currently employed in (doctors1, dentists', etc*) offices* This project is an important aspect of the survey of nursing needs and resources of (State)* In order to estimate the total number of professional and non-professional nursing personnel currently employed, it is necessary to know the number of nursing personnel in offices* Since this information cannot be obtained from any existing data, (number) of (physicians, dentists, etc*) have been selected to assist in the study by answering the questions on the enclosed post card* Information received from the participating (physicians, dentists, etc*) will be considered confidential Tour response to this request will be of inestimable value* We will appreciate it if you will mail the enclosed post card not later than (date)* Sincerely yours, (Chairman of the group sponsoring the survey) Enclosure (individually addressed, stamped post card) Questionnaire I: Self-addressed, stamped post card to be mailed to individual employers of nursing personnel in offices* Date To (Name of group sponsoring survey) The following nursing staff is now employed in my officet Type of Nursing No* of Average Personnel Persona Hrs. per Graduate Nurse (RN) Non-Professional Nurse This nursing staff is shared with: (Identifying Code number of physician, dentist, etc*} Table 3 suggests a method of summarizing the data collected by Questionnaire 1* Table 3* Estimated number of nursing personnel employed in offices in (State X), (Date)* Type of office Number of nursing personnel Professional Non-professional Total Doctors Dentists - - Others (specify) - Sources Detailed information about the number of nursing personnel engaged in private practice may be secured from professional and commercial nurses1 registries* A list of licensed nurses1 registries can be secured from the State Department of Labor or the appropriate State agency whose responsibility is to define, regulate and provide for the licensing and registration of employment agents* Material from the individual registries can be more effectively collected through personal interviews with the employers because of the variance in record keeping and the possible duplication of registrants* The amount of duplication can be revealed by selecting several letters of the alphabet and cross matching the names of the personnel appearing on the active rolls of the individual registries* If the number of nursing personnel engaged in private practice is obtained only from licensed nurses’ registries, the data will not be complete. This source •will not include those nurses -who are placed -without charge through the activity of such agents as hospitals, alumnae associations, private physicians, etc* It may not be possible to obtain information on the number of nurses in private practice who are placed in this way. If this is the case, the omission in the total count must be acknowledged* Questionnaire 2 is an example of how information in the number of nursing personnel engaged in private practice can be obtained from licensed nurse registries* Questionnaire 2* Self-addressed, stamped post card to be mailed to the registrar of individual licensed nurses1 registries* (Date). To (Name of group sponsoring survey) This registry has currently registered and placed nursing personnel as follows: graduate Nurses (RlO Total number currently registered Number on cases today: Total In hospitals In homes Other Noifc-Professional Nurses Total number currently registered Number on cases today: Total In hospitals In homes Other (Identifying Code number of licensed nurse registry) Table 4 shows how the information obtained through Questionnaire 2 can be compiled* Table 4* Estimated number of nursing personnel engaged in private practice, registered in and employed through licensed nurses* registries in (State X) (Date)* Type of registry Number of nursing personnel Professional Non-professional Total Total Total Total registered employed registered employed Total - Professional Conmercial - Source: Hoapltala It is desirable to assemble data relative to the number of nursing personnel employed by the folloning types of hospitals: 1. General and allied special 2* Tuberculosis 3. Mental 4, Chronic Utilization of the preceding classification facilitates the computations involved in estimates of present and future needs for nursing personnel in two ways. First, existing standards of nursing care can be more easily applied* Second, future needs for nursing personnel based on the anticipated construction of hospital bods as proposed by the State hospital plans correspond with the suggested categories State hospital plans in this Manual refers to the plans developed under the Hospital Survey and Construction Act. (Public Law 725, 79th Congress) Since the number of nursing personnel currently employed in hospitals will be compared with the number of nursing personnel estimated as needed by hospitals, the advantage of having similar data is obvious# An existing source of information for the' number of nursing personnel employed by hospitals is Hospital Service in the United States 1/• This annual statistical summary is pub3ished each year in the Hospital Number of the Journal of the American Medical Association, and can be obtained as a reprint from the Council on Medical Education and Hospitals, 535 North Dearborn Street, Chicago 10, Illinois. It is based on reports submitted by registered hospitals, both civilian and governmental. The latest twelve month period for which statistics are avail- able represents the reporting period* The table **Nursing Personnel and Schools of Nursing Education* contains a State total of each of the following categories of nursing personnel* 1* Student nurses 2* Administrative nursing personnel 3* Full time instructors 4* Supervisors and assistant supervisors 5. Head nurses and assistant head nurses 6. General duty nurses (part time and full time) 7* Nurses not classified 8. Private duty nurses 9* Practical nurses and attendants 10* Volunteer nurses* aides 11* Orderlies 12* Ward maids Arestad, F# H#, Leveroos, E# H#, Albus, W, R*, and Corbett, W# W,j Hospital Service in the United States. Council on Medical Education and Hospitals of the American Medical Association, Chicago, Illinois# Ihile the published material contains the preceding information as a total for each State, it has been possible to obtain the information for each category of nursing personnel in the individual hospitals in the State from unpublished material on file with the Council on Medical Education and Hospitals# If the data from the Council on Medical Education and Hospitals is utilised, the following suggestions should be considered* 1* Student Nurses This category of nurses should not be included in an estimate of the number of nursing personnel employed* However, in estimating the number of nurses needed it is necessary to know the number of student nurses so that their contribution to nursing service may be included in terms of replacement equivalents of professional nurses and non-professional nursing personnel* 2* Part Time General Duty Nurses It would seem reasonable to count the services of each part time general duty nurse as equivalent to one-half of the service of a full time general duty-nurse* 3* Nurses Not Classified These nurses might be assumed to be staff nurses in special hospital departments such as central supply room, operating room, etc* 4* Private Duty Nurses This group of nurses should be excluded from the hospital tally* As discussed previously, the professional and non-professional nursing personnel engaged in private practice in homes and hospitals should be considered as a separate group and so enumerated in the total count* 5# Volunteer Nurses* Aides and Ward Maids If the non-professdLonal personnel is to be limited to those who give direct care to patients then these two groups should be omitted# The statistical material from the Council on Medical Education and Hospitals pertains only to registered hospitals and sanatoriums, and related institutions# The number of nursing personnel in unregistered hospitals and sanatoriums, and related institutions can be obtained by means of a questionnaire# Probably the most recent data relative to the number and location of unregistered hospitals can be secured from the State agency administering the Hospital Survey and Planning Program* When the individual hospitals in the latest State survey are cross matched with the individual registered hospitals in the State listed in Hospital Service in the United States for the corresponding period of time, the number of unregistered hospitals in the State will be revealed# If the data compiled by the Council on Medical Education and Hospitals relative to the number of nursing personnel employed by hospitals are not used, similar information can he secured through a questionnaire to all hospitals, sanatoriums, and related institutions in the State# Flans for such a project should be made in cooperation with the State Hospital Association# An endorse- ment from this agency to hospital administrators will be of inestimable help in the collection of the desired facts# Whether information on the number of nursing personnel is requested from registered and unregistered or only registered hospitals in the State, the solicited data should include all nursing personnel employed by the hospitals# The following questionnaire (which is to be mailed to individual hospitals) illustrates how a total count of nursing personnel employed by a single hospital can be obtained* Questionnaire 3* Mailed questionnaire to individual hospitals to obtain a record of the number of nursing personnel currently employed. TO: (Name of group sponsoring survey) HOSPITAL ADDRESS Record of the number of nursing personnel currently employed 1/ (Date: month, day, year) Number of Nursing Personnel Full frjme Part Time " Total Total A* Graduate Nurses (R.N.) - list each nurse in the following classifications according to the one in which she devotes most time. I. Administrative Nursing Personnel a. Superintendent or assistant superinten- dent of hospital b* Superintendent and assistant superinten- dent of nurses and/or nursing school - II* Instructors - - III. Supervisors, assistant supervisors (charge of more than one nursing unit) Head nurses, assistant head nurses (charge of one nursing unit only) a. General services: medicine; surgery; obstetrics; pediatrics - b. Tuberculosis service c. Psychiatric service d. Operating room e. Central supply room f. Out-patient department - g. Other (specify) IV. Staff nurses (include those nurses giving a minor part of their time to head nurse duties or other supervisory function) a. General services: medicine; surgery* obstetrics; pediatrics -------- b« Tuberculosis service c. Psychiatric service d. Operating room — e. Central supply room f. Out-patient department - ■ g. Other (specify) B. Non-professional Nursing Personnel (those who spend the major part of their time assisting -with nursing duties) Attendants, Practical Nurses, etc. - Include nursing, personnel on afternoon-and-night duty as well as those off duty because of days off, vacation, or illness* Should the number of nursing personnel in Federal hospitals in the State be included in the total estimate of the number of nursing personnel employed by hospi- tals in the State? Recruitment for these hospitals is generally on a regional or national basis -with personnel subject to transfer in accord with different personnel policies, State may be assumed to have special responsibility to provide nursing personnel to care for its citizensin the Veterans Administration hospitals within its borders. However, there is no known standard by which to estimate the degree of this responsibility. Since the count of nursing personnel currently employed is to be used in relation to the number of nursing personnel estimated as needed, the various staffing patterns of the Federal hospitals preclude the application of existing standards by which the number of nursing personnel needed in civilian hospitals is calculated. Moreover, anticipated construction of hospital beds as proposed by the State hospital plans (which serves as the basis for estimating the number of nursing personnel needed in the future) does not include the needs of the Federal hospitals. Table 5 Is a convenient way of assembling the data on the number of nursing personnel currently employed by hospitals. Table 5. Estimated number of nursing personnel employed by (registered and un- registered or registered only) hospitals (exclusive of or including Federal hospitals) in (State X), (Date). Type of hospital Number of nursing personnel Professional Non-professional Total General and allied special Tuberculosis • Mental - - Chronic - - Source: Summary: Section I Table 6 summarizes the estimates of the number of nursing personnel currently employed in the State according to place of service (see Tables 1, 2, 3* 5)« Table 6. Estimated number of nursing personnel currently employed in (State X), (Date). Place of Service Number of nursing personnel Professional Non-professional Total — Public Health - - Industry - - - — - Offices - - Private practice - Hospitals 1/ Other 1/ Registered and unregistered or registered only$ exclusive of or including Federal hospitals# Source: The follcwing chart is a condensation of the discussion in Section I relative to the probable sources of information for obtaining an estimate of the number of nursing personnel currently employed in a State according to place of service. Chart 1# Probable sources of information for obtaining an estimate of the number of nursing personnel currently employed in a State according to place of service Place of Probable sources of information Contributory material service Existing data relative to the number of nursing personnel currently eisployed. Notes Field of employ- ment for professional registered nurses American Nurses' Association Count and Classification of professional • registered nurses !• State Board of Nurse Examiners 2* American Nurses'Association Public Health Census of Public Health Nurses !• State Department of Health, division of Nursing 2* Federal Security Agency, Public Health Service, Office of Public Health Nursing Industry Census of Industrial Nurses 1. State Department of Health, Division of Nursing or State Department of Labor 2* Federal Security Agency, Public Health Service, Nursing Section of the Industrial Hygiene division Offices 1* State Nurses' Association 2m State Board of Nurse Examiners list of individual employers of nursing personnel in office from the appropriate State associations such as the State Medical and Dental Societies* Private practice 1. State Nurses' Association 2m State Board of Nurse Examiners list of licensed nurses* registries from the State Department of Labor, or the appropriate State agency whose responsibility is to define, regulate, and provide for the licensing and registration of employment agents* Hospitals 1* Council on Medical Education and Hospitals of the American Medical Associa- tion list of unregistered hospitals from the State agency adminis- tering the Hospital Survey 1 and Planning Program* SECTION II. ESTIMATING THE NUMBER OF NURSING PERSONNEL REQUIRED TO MEET CURRENT AND FUTURE NEEDS. Having estimated the number of nursing personnel currently employed, an appraisal of the number of nursing personnel required to meet current and future needs is indicated. When this need has been estimated, it -will then be possible to see the present situation by subtracting the number of nurses currently employed from the number of nurses currently needed. What is dis- closed in the preceding computation must also be considered in conjunction with future needs for nursing personnel. Such an analysis will define the quantitative aspect of the relationship between the supply of and the need for nursing personnel. Estimates of current and future needs should include the number of professional and non-professional nurses required to give direct patient care as well as the quota of professional nurses required for administrative and supervisory positions. The question of what constitutes adequate nursing service is difficult to determine in the absence of firmly established standards in certain areas of nursing. Hhtil research provides guides for these situations, logical assumptions can be made and must be plainly identified as assumptions. The following discussion will present! 1. suggested criteria for estimating current and future needs 2. formulae for computing the number of nursing personnel required to meet the suggested criteria 3* factors influencing the estimate of needs. Public Health The need for public health nurses is computed on a ratio of public health nurses to population. Local Health Units For The Nation 1/ suggests a ratio of 1 public health nurse to 5>000 population. This ratio is based on a generalized public health program* It includes school nursing, but not bedside care of the sick. If the public health nurse is to give health guidance and bedside care to the entire family. Desirable Organization of Public Health Nursing For Family Service 2/ recommends that 1 public health nurse should be provided for approximately every 2000 people. This same article states that nadequate provision should be made for nursing supervision in the ratio of 1 qualified supervisor for every 10 nurses11. The selection of the standard to use in estimating the unit of population per public health staff nurse should be based on the current situation. Applica- tion of Formula 1 will reveal the current unit of population per staff nurse. Formula 1 - Current Unit of Population Per Public Health Staff Nurse Current population current number of public health staff nurses m current unit of population per public health staff nurse Examplel current population of State X current number of public health staff nurses 7000 current unit of population per public health staff nurse. 1/ Emerson, Havent Local Health Units For The Nation. Commonwealth Fund, “ New York, 19h$ 2/ Committee representing National and Federal agencies concerned with public "" health nursing! Desirable organization of public health nursing for family service. Public Health Nursing 38*387-389 (August 1938) In addition to the preceding computation, answers to the following questions (obtained through conferences with the directors of nursing of public health agencies in the State) will influence the decision involving a choice of the 1- £000 or 1 - 2000 ratio. Do the functions of the public health agencies indicate an overlapping of nursing activities? Is the nursing service provided geographically adequate? How much bedside care is being given? Is there a demand for care for the chronically ill patients at home? Are non- professional nursing personnel included in the public health team? How many budgeted nursing positions are unfilled? Having determined the standard to use in estimating the current need for public health staff nurses to population (based on the practical consideration of the current situation). Formulae 2 and 3 will disclose the number of staff nurses and supervisors needed. Formula 2. Number of public health staff nurses required to meet the selected standard of population unit per nurse. Population selected standard of population unit per public health staff nurse Number of public health staff * nurses required to meet the selected standard of population unit per nurse Example: 10,000,000 current population of State X £000 selected standard of population unit per public health staff nurse s 2000 public health staff nurses currently needed to meet the 1 - £000 ratio of public health staff nurses per population. Formula 3. Number of public health nurses in supervisory positions required to meet the standard for staff nurses per supervisor Required number of public health staff nurses Standard for public health staff nurses per supervisor Number of public health nurses in supervisory positions required to meet the standard for staff nurses per supervisor Example: 2000 public health staff nurses currently needed to meet the 1 - £000 ratio of public health staff nurses per population 10 standard for the number of staff nurses per supervisor 200 public health nurses in supervisory positions currently needed to meet the 1-10 ratio of supervisors per staff nurses* To use Formula 1 and 2 it is necessary to have an estimate of: 1* current population of the State 2* projected population of the State as of a future date. The most recent copy of Current Population Reports (published annually by the Bureau of the Census, United States Department of Commerce) is the most reliable source for obtaining an estimate of the current population of the State. The State Planning Committee (or its counterpart) will probably be the best source to secure an estimate of the projected population of the State as of a future date. The following table shows a convenient way to assemble the estimate current and future number of nurses needed by public health agencies. Table 7* An estimate of the current and future number of nurses needed by public health agencies in (State X). Type of Number of nurses needed Current (Date) Future (Date) Agency Supervisors Staff Supervisors Staff Total Official agencies. Boards of education. . Non-official agencies. Source: Industry The number of nurses needed by industrial establishments depends to great extent on the number of workers. Nursing Practice In Industry 1/ recommends (for the maintenance of complete health services in an industry) the following ratios of nurses per employees: 1 nurse .up to 300 employees 2 or more nurses up to 600 employees 3 or more nurses up to 1,000 employees 1 nurse per each additional 1000 employees up to £000$ and 1 nurse per additional 2000 employees. 1/ Whitlock, Olive M., Trasko, Victoria M., and Kahl, F. Ruth: Nursing “ Practices in Industry. Public Health Bulletin No. 283s U. S. Government Printing Office, Washington, 19lU*. Utilization of the preceding standard involves a tabulation of the number of industrial establishments and employees according to the size of the establishment* It will also be necessazy to make a decision relative to the minimum size of an establishment to be included in the category Mup to 300 employees *• The following factors also have an Influence on the estimate of the number of nurses needed by industrial establishments: 1. Extent of medical and health programs 2. Occupational hazards 3* Additional shifts h* Amount of nursing participation in health education activities and home nursing service 5* Utilization of part-time nursing services in establishments employing less than 100 woxkers 6* Tendency to employ non-professional nursing personnel ?♦ Provision for nursing supervision (furnished either by a member of the nursing staff at the plant or by advisory service from the State department of health, insurance companies, etc.)* Estimates of future needs will depend upon plans for industrial expansion. Discussions relative to this potential growth should also include a consideration of the social and economic trends in the State, as well as possible technological advances in the major types of industry represented* It is evident from the preceding discussion that realistic estimates of present and future needs for nurses in industry require considerable auxiliary information. The State Industrial hygiene Personnel (to be found either in the Board of Health or the Department of iabor) will probably be the best source* The State Chamber of Commerce, Manufacturers1 Association, and the State Planning Commission (or its counterpart) are other contacts which may prove helpful* The following table is suggested as a pattern for estimating either current or future needs for nurses in industrial establishments* Table b. An estimate of the number of nurses needed by industrial establishments in (State X), (Date). Size of industrial es tabli shments Number of Plants Number of Employees Number of Nurses Needed Total to 300 301 - 600 601 - 1,000 1,001 - 2,000 2,001 - 3,000 3,001 - U,000 1*,001 5,000 ♦ . . 5,001 and over Source: Table 9 summarizes the current and future needs for nurses in industrial establishments* Table 9* An estimate of the current and future number of nurses needed by industrial establishments in (State X)* Size of industrial Number of nurses needed establishment Current (Date) Future (Date) Total to 300 301 - 600 601 - 1000 1001 - 2000 2001 - 3000 3001 - 1*000 Uooi _ 5000 5001 and over Sourcei Offices and Private Practice There are no known standards for determining the number of nursing personnel needed in offices and private practice. Therefore, it is suggested that the present needs for nursing personnel in offices and private practice be held constant with the number of nursing personnel currently employed in these two categories* Estimates of future needs for nursing personnel in offices should take into consideration the following factors: 1. inclination to utilize nursing personnel in offices* 2* an appreciable increase or decrease in the number of doctors, dentists, etc** 3* trend in group practice* The utilization of nursing personnel in offices in recent years may provide a clue to the extent of future requests for this type of nursing service* Information on the number of professional nurses in offices over a period of time can probably be obtained from the State Nurses* Association* This data can be secured by coinparing the number of their members engaged in this type of nursing activity over a consecutive number of years. It may be possible to obtain similar information for non-professional nursing personnel from the State Board of Nurse Examiners (or the appropriate licensing agency). It will depend upon whether the licensure law in the State includes non-professional nursing personnel and if the registrants are requested to indicate the field of nursing in which they are engaged. The deans of medical, dental, etc. schools and the appropriate State associations (medical, dental, etc.) are the groups which will be helpful in estimating: an appreciable increase or decrease in the number of doctors, dentists, etc. (who may be potential employers of nursing personnel in offices); and the trend in group practice (which may influence / the number of nursing personnel needed in offices)* Estimates of future needs for nursing personnel in private practice should recognize the difference between demand and need* Need is distinguished from demand in that it is a response to a real necessity arising from the patient*s physical and mental condition rather than a desire for continuous individual care* The future need for the number of nursing personnel engaged in private practice in either homes or hospitals will probably be diminished as hospitals provide more adequate nursing service and are increasingly used. The preceding considerations may indicate the feasibility of maintaining the number of nursing personnel currently engaged in private practice constant for future needs. The following table can be used to record estimates of current and future needs for nursing personnel in either offices or private practice. Table 10* An estimate of the current and future number of nursing personnel needed in (offices or private practice) in (State X). Type of Number of nursing personnel needed nursing personnel Current (Date) Future (Date) Total Professional nurses Non-professional nursing personnel Source: Hospitals As stated previously (see pages 18), it is advantageous to estimate current and future needs for nursing personnel in hospitals according to the following types of hospitals: 1* General and allied special 2* Tuberculosis 3* Mental iu Chronic There are no known standards (pertinent to a study on a State-wide basis) by which to estimate needs for nursing personnel in special hospital departments such as the operating room, central supply room, outpatient department, etc* In the absence of such overall standards, the number of nursing personnel currently employed might be used as a criteria* The index of ‘‘hours of care per patient per day” is the standard recommended as a guide in estimating the number of nursing personnel needed to give bedside care to patients in general, allied special, and chronic disease hospitals. The construction and arrangement of the hospitals, avail- ability of desirable equipment, administrative skill of the executive personnel and other factors have a definite influence on the preceding standard. However, these factors cannot be included in the standard as there are no quantitative measures of their effect available. An estimate of the number of nursing personnel needed in tuberculosis and mental hospitals iwill be more practicable if based on ratios of nursing personnel (professional and non-professional) per daily average patient census. Whether hours of care per patient per 2k hours or ratios of nursing personnel per daily average patient census is used, estimates of future needs for nursing personnel will be based on an estimated future daily average patient census. To estimate the future daily average patient census it will be necessary to know: 1. Anticipated number of hospital beds 2. Expected occupancy rate. The State agency administering the Hospital Survey and Planning Program will probably be the best source for obtaining the anticipated number of hospital beds. The expected occupancy rate should be estimated in consultation with representatives of both State agency and the State Hospital Association. When the anticipated number of hospital beds and the expected occupancy rate have been obtained, the following formula can be used to arrive at an estimated future daily average patient census. Formula U* Estimated future daily average patient census Anticipated number of hospital beds X expected occupancy estimated future daily average patient census. Example: 25>000 anticipated number of hospital beds in • State X in 1955 expected occupancy rate in hospitals in State X in 1955 20,000 estimated daily- average patient census in State X in 1 955* X General and Allied Special Hospitals A recent study. Nursing Service in One Children’s and Twenty-one General Hospitals, 1/ gives detailed information which is useful in computing nursing service needs for a single hospital. This publication presents nursing service needs for specific clinical areas according to type of accommodation. It is improbable that this information will be available on a State-wide basis. Therefore, the following criteria (adapted from this study) are suggested: Administrative nursing personnel per daily average patient census (including newborn) Type of administrative nursing personnel Daily average patient census (including newborn) 1 day supervisor 1 evening supervisor .... 57 1 night supervisor 1 head nurse . Nursing personnel giving direct patient care 3*5 average number of bedside hours per patient during 2k hours; the proportion of professional nurses to non-professional nursing personnel giving this direct care to patients in the ratio - 2 professional nurses* 1 non-professional nursing personnel. Distribution of Nursing Service during War 2/ suggests 2 nurses as the central administrative staff (exclusive of day supervisors and head nurses; and night supervisors) in a general hospital with an all-graduate staff and having a daily average of 100 patients. 1/ National League of Nursing Education, Department of Studies* A Study of ” Nursing Service in One Children’s and Twenty-one General Hospitals. National League of Nursing Education, 1790 Broadway, New York City, New York, 19^8. 2/ National Nursing Council for War Servicer Distribution of Nursing Service ** during War, 1790 Broadway, New York City, New York, 19U2. A comparison of current practices with the preceding criteria may reveal a wide discrepancy between what actually exists and what is needed. If this is so, it may be considered feasible to gradually increase the average number of bedside hours per patient in 2k hours and the ratios of administrative nursing personnel per daily average patient census (including newborn) until the desired standards are met. The status of current practices in general hospitals in the State can be revealed by collecting certain data from a selected number of representative hospitals. The following section discusses pertinent factors in such a study: ****** 4 (•***** A Study of a Sample of General Hospitals *********** A sample of general hospitals in a State should include an adequate number of hospitals representing variations in: 1* size of community in which they are located 2. those with and without schools of nursing 3* ownership or control average census (including newborn) Information relative to the above items can be obtained from the mos t recent copy of Hospital Service In The United States (published annually by the Council on Medical Education and Hospitals). Utilization of information appearing in this publication for the purpose of a sample study of general hospitals in a State will involve the following steps: 1. Segregation of general ’’hospitals and sanatoriums” and ’’related institutions” from other categories listed under ’’type of service”. 2. Classification of general ’’hospitals and sanatoriums” and ’’related Institutions” according to: a* Location. The individual hospitals in the State are listed alphabetically according to location. The size of the population and the county immediately follow the location. b. Those with schools of nursing. The hospitals having schools of nursing accredited by the State Board of Nurse Examiners are designated by a symbol following the name of the individual hospital. c. Ownership or control. The various auspices under which the institutions are conducted are identified under the column ”ownership or control” ♦ d. Average census (Including newborn). The average census (excluding newborn) of the individual hospitals can be found under the column waverage census”. Since the figures in this column do not include newborn, it will be necessary to estimate the daily average newborn census. This can be approximated by multiplying the number of births (see column 11 number of births”) by the most recent ”average length of stay per patient in general hospitals” (refer to the table with this heading) and dividing by 365 (days in year). Example: 100 number of births in Hospital A, a non-profit general hospital X 9 average length of stay per patient in all nonprofit general hospitals in 19U7 2*5> estimated daily average newborn census 365” days in year INhen the daily average newborn census has been estimated, this figure added to the average census (excluding newborn) will approximate the average census (including newborn). The preceding method classifies the general hospitals in a State accord- ing to the four categories suggested as a basis for the sample study. The next consideration is the number of hospitals which will constitute a valid sample. This decision will depend upon the individual pattern of each State as revealed by the range and distribution of the hospitals within each category. It is recommended that statistical assistance be requested in making this determination. Since the purpose of the sample study is to compare current practices with the suggested criteria, it is obvious that the data collected should correspond to the classifications of the criteria# Therefore, the specific information requested from each hospital participating in the sample study will relate to the following items for a specified 2h hour period: 1. Daily average patient census (including newborn) 2. Number of administrative nursing personnel on duty classified according to a# central administrative staff b. supervisors (day, evening, night) c# head nurses 3* Number of hours of direct patient care by type of nursing personnel a# professional nurses b# non-professional nursing personnel. When the preceding data have been obtained, subsequent mathematical computations will reveal: 1. Current ratios of specific groups of administrative nursing personnel to daily average patient census (including newborn) 2. Current average number of bedside hours per patient in 2h hours, and the current ratio of professional to non-professional nursing personnel giving this direct care to patients. The effectiveness of a sample depends upon accurate and complete information from the participating hospitals. Since a relatively small number of hospitals are selected for a project of this type, it is strongly recommended that the desired data be obtained through field visits. It may be expedient to have several nurses share the field work* If this is the case, it is advantageous to hold a conference with the group prior to their visits. Uniformity in the interpretation and collection of information will facilitate subsequent compila- tion and correlation of the material obtained. If a mailed questionnaire is unavoidable, the information requested in the form should be clearly understood by the respondent. Questionnaire h (Parts 1 and 2) illustrates how the data needed for the sample study might be collected. Questionnaire U: Mailed questionnaire to individual hospitals selected to (Parts 1, 2) participate in a sample study of general hospitals to obtains Record of the number of administrative nursing personnel on duty. Record of nursing personnel giving direct patient care during 2h hours. Questionnaire U Part 1 To: (Name of group sponsoring survey) Hospital Address Daily average patient census (including newborn) Record of the number of administrative nursing personnel on duty (Date: month, day, year) Administrative nursing personnel Number of nurses !• Central administrative staff (director and assistant director of nurses and/or nursing school) II. Supervisors (Charge of more than one ward or patient unit) a. day. • • b. evening. c. night. • III. Head nurses (Charge of one ward or patient unit only) NURSING PERSONNEL GIVING DIRECT PATIENT CARE (Include full & part time) (W (5) (6) (7) Private duty Graduate Professional Non-Professional Nursing Nurses Professional Student Personnel c/ giving direct Nurses b/ Nurses care to patients No. Total ” No”. Total Nol Total Nol Total’ Hours Hours Hours Hours of of of of Care Care Care Care a/Do not include special departments, e.g.t operating room, central supply room, out-patient department, etc. B/lnclude any time given to direct patient care by head nurses and/or assistant head nurse. c/Practical nurses, attendants, nurses1 aides, orderlies, etc. "Example j B-2 Medical 20 6 1+8 2 16 2 6 3 2h Hospital Address Record of Nursing Personnel Giving Direct Patient Care During 2h Hours of (Date* month, day, year) — t+s Questionnaire li Part 2 CENSUS (3) No. of patients in unit today Tot (Name of group sponsoring survey) SERVICE (2) e.g. med., surgical, OB, T.B., psychiatry UNIT, e.g. WARD, FLOOR WT Areas in which direct nursing service is given a/ The following worksheets (to be used by the director of the survey or a designate) serve two purposes: 1. orderly method of compiling, computing, and correlating the collected data 2. systematic way of retaining essential data for reference. The explanatory material accompanying each worksheet identifies the source of the information used, and illustrates the mathematical procedures involved by means of formulae and examples. (1*) Ratios of administrative nursing personnel to daily average patient census (including newborn) 1:100 Worksheet !• Summary of Data Relative to the Ratios of Administrative Nursing Personnel to Daily Average Patient Census (including newborn) in (Hospital A), on (Date: month, day, year) (3) Daily average patient census (including newborn) 200 (2) Number of adminis trative nursing personnel UforamplA 2 (X) Specific groups of Admin is tra tive nursing personnel Central Administra- tive staff Supervisor: Day Head nurses Explanatory material. Worksheet 1. This worksheet utilizes data obtained through Questionnaire 1* (part 1). The summarization in Worksheet 1 reveals ratios of administrative nursing personnel to daily average patient census (including newborn) in a hospital, formula 5> shows the mathematical procedures employed in Worksheet 1. Formula Ratios of administrative nursing personnel to daily average patient census (including newborn). Number of administrative nursing personnel: Central administrative nursing staff or supervisors (Hay, evening, night) or head nurses. Daily average patient census (including newborn) Ratios of administrative nursing personnel to daily average patient census (including newborn). Example: 2 number of Central administrative nursing staff in Hospital A 200 daily average patient census in Hospital A (including newborn) 1:100 ratio of central administrative nursing staff to daily average patient census (including newborn) in Hospital A, Note: The data in Worksheet 1 pertains to a single hospital. To arrive at the average ratio for any one group of administrative nursing personnel for all hospitals participating in the sample study it will be necessary to: !• individually total the specific groups of administrative nursing personnel: a. central administrative staff b. supervisors - day, evening, night c. head nurses 2. total the daily average patient census (including newborn). When the preceding steps have been completed, the total number of individual groups of administrative nursing personnel divided by the total daily average patient census (including newborn) will reveal the average ratios of specific groups of administrative nursing personnel to daily average patient census (including newborn). Example: Statement of problem: To determine the average ratio of central admin- trative nursing staff to daily average patient census (including newborn) in the sample study of general hospitals in State X. Individual institutions Number of central Daily average patient participating in the sample administrative nursing census (including study of general hospitals staff newborn) Hospital A 2 200 Hospital B 8 95o Hospital C 1 50 Hospital D 3 300 Hospital E 2 100 16 1555“ Solution: 16 total number of central administrative nursing staff 1600 total daily average patient census (including newborn) r 1:100 average ratio of central administrative nursing staff to daily average patient census (including newborn). (it) Ratio of Professional to Won- professional Nursing Personnel Professional Non-Profes- (Graduate profes- sional sional nurses and nursing professional stu- personnel dent nurses) 1 1.1 Worksheet 2. Summary of Data Relative to Hours of Bedside Care per Patient in 2h Hours and Ratio of Professional to Non-Professional Nursing Personnel Giving this Direct Patient Care in (Hospital A) on (Date: month, day, year) (3) Hours of Bedside Care per Patient by Type of Nursing Personnel Graduate Professional Non-Profes- Professional student sional nurs- ing person- nel •9 .3 1*3 (2) Bedside Nursing Care in 2k Hours Sum total Average Hours of hour’s of Care care per patient h6 2.5 (i) Adjusted Census Grand total Examples 18 Explanatory material. Worksheet 2. This worksheet utilizes data obtained through Questionnaire U (Part 2)* The summarization in Worksheet 2 reveals the hours of bedside care per patient in 2k hours and the ratio of professional to non-professional nursing personnel giving this direct patient care for each unit in a hospital. The mathematical procedures in Worksheet 2 are the following j a. ADJUSTED CENSUS Source: Adjusted census (Colunn 1, Worksheet 2) is computed from census (Column 3, Part 2 of Questionnaire k) and total hours of. care of private duty nurses (Column k9 Part 2 of Questionnaire b) Formula 6a - Equivalent number of patients cared for by other than hospital staff in a 2b hour period. Total hours of service of private duty nurses 2k hours equivalent number of patients cared for by other than hospital staff in a 2k hour period. Formula 6b - Adjusted census (patients cared for by hospital staff in a 2k hour period) Census of - Equivalent number of Unit patients cared for by other than hospital staff in a 2b hour period adjusted census (patients cared for by hospital staff in a 2k hour period) ■i Example? U8 total hours of service of private duty nurses (6 nurses at 8 hours each) 2k hours 2 equivalent number of patients cared for by other than hospital staff in a 2k hour period 20 (census of unit) - 2 (equivalent number of patients cared for by other than hospital staff in a 2k hour period) 18 adjusted census (patients cared for by hospital staff In a 2k hour period) s b. AVERAGE HOURS OF BEDSIDE NURSING CARE PER PATIENT IN 2U HOURS Source: The average hours of bedside nursing care per patient in 2h hours (Column 2, Worksheet 2) is computed for each unit (Column 1, Part 2 of Questionnaire U) from the adjusted census (Column 1, Worksheet 2) and the sum total hours of bedside nursing care (Column 2, Worksheet 2). The sum total hours of bedside nursing care (Column 2, Worksheet 2) is the combined total hours of care of: graduate professional nurses (Column 5, Part 2 of Questionnaire h); professional student nurses (Column 6, Part 2 of Questionnaire 1*); and non- professional nursing personnel (Column 7, Part 2 of Questionnaire ii). Formula 7. Average hours of nursing care per patient in 2ii hours. Sum total of hours of bedside nursing care adjusted census average hours of nursing care per patient in 2li hours. Example : 16 total hours, graduate professional nurses 6 total hours, professional student nurses 2h total hours, non-professional nursing personnel U6 sum total of hours of bedside nursing care U6 l8 (adjusted census) 2.5 average hours of nursing care per patient in a 2h hour period. c. HOURS OF BEDSIDE CARE PER PATIENT IN 2k HOURS BY TYPE OF NURSING PERSONNEL. Sources Hours of bedside care per patient in 2k hours by type of nursing personnel (Column 3, Worksheet 2) is computed for each unit (Column 1, Part 2 of Questionnaire 1;) from the adjusted census (Column 1, Worksheet 2) and the total hours of bedside nursing care of each category of nursing personnels Graduate professional nurses (Column 5, Part 2 of Questionnaire U); Professional student nurses (Column 6, Part 2 of Questionnaire 1*); Non-professional nursing personnel (Column 7, Part 2 of Questionnaire U)• Formula 8. Hours of bedside care per patient by type of nursing personnel. Total hours of bedside nursing cares Graduate professional nurses Hours of Bedside or Professional student nurses care per patient by or Non-professional nursing personnel Adjusted Census = type of nursing personnel Examples 16 total hours, graduate profes- sional nurses 18 adjusted census .9 Average hours of bedside care per patient by praduate professional nurses 6 total hours, professional student nurses l8 adjusted census = .3 Average hours of bedside care per patient by professional student nurses 2k total hours, non-professional nursing personnel l6 adjusted census “ 1.3 Average hours of bedside care per patient by non- professional nursing personnel. d. RATIO OF PROFESSIONAL TO NON-PROFESSIONAL NURSING PERSONNEL GIVING DIRECT PATIENT CARE Source: The ratio of professional to non-professional nursing personnel giving direct patient care (Column U, Worksheet 2) is computed for each unit (Column 1, Part 2 of Questionnaire U) from the total hours of care of graduate professional nurses (Column 5, Part 2 of Questionnaire h) and professional student nurses (Column 6, Part 2 of Questionnaire h) and non-professional nursing personnel (Column 7, Part 2 of Questionnaire U)• Formula 9* Ratio of Professional to Non-Professional Nursing Personnel Giving Direct Patient Care. Total hours of bedside care by non-professional nursing personnel Total hours of bedside care by professional nurses (graduate professional and professional student nurses) s ratio of professional to non-professional nursing personnel giving direct patient care. Example: 2h total hours of bedside care by non-professional nursing personnel 22 total hours of bedside care by professional nurses (graduate professional nurses 16; profes- sional student nurses 6) 1 professional nurse to 1.1 non-professional nursing personnel giving direct patient care. “W Ratio of professional to Non-professional nursing personnel Professional Non-Professional (gradua te Nur sing professional Personnel nurses and professional student nurses) Summary of Data Relative to Hours of Bedside Care Per Patient in 21; Hours and Ratio of Professional to Non-Professional Nursing Personnel Giving this Direct Patient Care According to Size of Hospitals a*) Hours of Bedside Care per Patient by Type of Nursing Personnel Graduate Profes- Non- Profes- sional Profes- sional Student sional Nursing Personnel (3) Bedside Nursing Care in 2k Hours Sum total) Average Hours of Hours of Care Care per Patient (2) Number of Ho spitals Worksheet j• Grand total Below 25 26 - 50 51 - 100 101 - 200 201 - 300 3CQ. and over a) Size of Hospital Explanatory Material, Worksheet 3. This worksheet classifies certain items compiled in Worksheet 2 according to size of hospitals. The selected data utilized in Worksheet 3 are: bedside nursing care in 2h hours (Column 2, Worksheet 2); hours of bedside care per patient by type of nursing personnel (Column 3, Worksheet 2)j and ratio of professional to non-professional nursing personnel (Column Ii, Worksheet 2). The data from Worksheet 2 pertain only to a single hospital. Therefore, to utilize this data on Worksheet 3 two steps are necessarys 1. sort all Worksheets 2 according to size of hospital 2. summarize within each category of size the selected items on all Worksheets 2 to be used in Worksheet 3* When this intermediate phase has been concluded, the results can then be entered in the appropriate columns in Worksheet 3* The calculations necessary to complete this worksheet are identical to those which have been discussed previously (refer to explanatory material accompanying Worksheet 2, sections b, c, d). Notes Worksheet 3 can be used as a model for summarizing the other factors which served as a basis for selecting the general hospitals to participate in the sample study. This can be accomplished by changing the "size of hospital" (Column 1, Worksheet 3) tos 1. size of community in which the hospitals are located 2. hospitals with schools of nursing 3. hospitals without schools of nursing iu ownership or control. Summaries resulting from the preceding classification will not only permit more refined comparisons within each category, but may also disclose significant correlations between categories. When current practices (revealed by the sample study) have been compared with the suggested criteria and a decision reached relative to the standards which are to be used in estimating present and future needs for nursing personnel in general and allied special hospitals on a State-wide basis. Formulae 10 and 11 (a and b) will disclose the number of administrative and bedside nursing personnel required per day. Formula 10. Number of administrative nursing personnel required per day to meet the selected standard of daily average patient census (including newborn) per type of administrative nursing personnel in general and allied special hospitals on a State-wide frisis. Bally average patient census (including newborn) in general and allied special hospitals X selected standards for administrative nursing personnel per daily average patient census (including newborn)I Central administrative nursing staff or supervisors (day, evening, night) or head nurses number of adminis- trative nursing personnel required per day to meet the selected standard of daily average patient census (including newborn) per type of admin- istrative nursing personnel in general and allied special hospitals on a State-wide basis Example: 19*000 current daily average patient census (including newborn) of general and allied special hospitals in State X 2 central administrative nursing staff per 100 daily average patient census (including newborn) 380 central adminis- trative nursing staff currently needed per day in general and allied special hospitals in State X to meet the selected standard of 2 central adminis- trative nursing staff per 100 daily average patient census (including newborn) X Formula 11 a. Number of bedside nursing personnel required per day to meet the selected standard of average hours of bedside care per patient in 2k hours in general and allied special hospitals on a State- wide basis.!/ Daily average patient census (including new- born) in general and allied special hospitals X selected standard of average hours of bedside care per patient in 2k hours in general and allied special hospitals Number of bedside nursing personnel required per day to meet the selected standard of average hours of bedside care per patient in 2h hours in general and allied special hospitals on a State-wide basis. Average number of hours worked per day by nursing personnel giving bedside care in general and allied special hospitals. Formula 11 b. Number of professional or non-professional bedside nursing personnel required per day to meet the selected ratio of professional nurses or non-professional nursing personnel to total nursing personnex giving bedside care in general and allied special hospitals on a State-wide basis. Number of bedside nursing personnel required per day to meet the selected standard of average hours of bedside care per patient in 2k hours in general and allied special hospitals on a State-wide basis Selected ratio of professional nurses or non-professional nursing personnel to total nursing personnel giving bedside care in general and allied special hospitals on a State-wide basis Number of professional or non-professional bed- side nursing personnel required per day to meet the selected ratio of professional nurses or non-professional nursing personnel to total nurs- ing personnel giving bedside care in general and allied special hos- pitals on a State-wide basis• X 1/ This formula is adapted from an equation in the Manual of the Essentials of Good Hospital Nursing Service published by the American Hospital Association and National League of Nursing Education; 1790 Broadway, New York City, New York, 19L2, page U3 Example: Statement of problems 20,571 - daily average patient census (including newborn) in general and allied special hospitals in State X 8 - average number of hours worked per day by nursing personnel giving bedside care in general and allied special hospitals in State X Selected criteria for estimating needs for nursing personnel 3*5 average number of bedside hours per patient during 2k hours, the proportion of professional nurses to non-professional nursing personnel giving this direct care in the ratio of 2si (total nursing personnel 3 9 2/3 professional nurses and 1/3 non- professional nursing personnel) Solution: 20,571 x 3*5 8 average number of hours worked per day by nursing personnel giving bedside care 9000 number of nursing personnel required per day to meet the selected standard of 3*5 average hours of bedside care per patient in 2k hours in general and allied special hospitals in State X* 9000 x 2/3 factor for com- puting profes- sional nurses B 6000 professional nurses required per day to meet the selected ratio of professional to non-professional nursing personnel giving 3*5 average hours of bedside care per patient in 2k hours in general and allied special hospitals in State X. 9000 x 1/3 factor for compu- ting non-profes- sional nursing personnel 3000 non-professional nursing personnel required per day to Beet the selected ratio of professional to non-professional nursing personnel giving average hours of bedside care per patient in 2k hours in general and allied special hospitals in State X. Another factor which must be considered in estimates of need for nursing personnel in general hospitals is the contribution to nursing service made by student nurses in basic professional nursing education programs. It is suggested that this calculation be made in terms of replacement equivalents of professional nurses or non-professional nursing personnel* Formula 12 (a and b) illustrates a method of estimating these replacement equivalents. Formula 12 a Number of nursing personnel required to replace the contribution made to nursing service by basic professional student nurses. Total students currently enrolled X percent of students giving direct care to patients X percent of student service which is as productive as profes- sional and non-profes- sional nursing service m number of nursing personnel required to replace student nurse service. Formula 12 b Number of graduate professional nurses or non-professional nursing personnel required to replace the contribution made to nursing service by basic professional student nurses. Number of nursing personnel required to replace student nurse service percent of student service which replaces: graduate professional nursing service or non-professional nursing service. Number of graduate professional nurses or non-professional nursing personnel required to replace student nurse service. X Example: Statement of problem: 3000 student nurses currently enrolled in basic professional nursing education programs associated with general hospitals in State X* Assumptions: !• 2/3 (66 2/3$) of the total students enrolled are giving direct care to patients. 2. An hour of student service is 3A (75$) as productive as a combined hour of professional and non-professional nurse service# 3* Student nurse service replaces a* Professional nursing service 60$ b. Non-professional nursing service i*0$. Solution: 3000 students currently enrolled X 66 2/3$ (see 1 above) X 75$ (see 2 above) 1500, number of nursing personnel required to replace student nurse service 1500 number of nursing personnel required to replace student nurse service X 60$ (see 3 a above) = 900, graduate professional nurses required to replace student nurse service 1500 number of nursing personnel required to replace student nurse service 600, non-profes- sional nursing personnel required to replace nurse service• X k0% (see 3b above) If Formula 12 (a and b) is used as' the method for estimating replacement equivalents for the contribution made by basic professional student nurses on a State-wide basis, it will be necessary to obtain an estimate for the following factors: 1. percent of the students currently enrolled who are giving direct care to patients 2. percent of student service which is as productive as a combined hour of professional and non-professional nurse service 3* percent of student service which replaces professional nursing service and non-professional nursing service. Counsel in regard to the preceding items should be sought from the State Board of Nurse Examiners, State Nurses* Association, and State League of Nursing Education. The following table may be used to summarize the number of nursing personnel currently needed per day by general and allied special hospitals. Table 11. An estimate of the number of nursing personnel currently needed per day by (registered and unregistered or registered only) general and allied special hospitals (exclusive of or including Federal hospitals) in (State X), (Date). Type of Nursing personnel Number of nursing personnel currently needed per day Total Professional nurses • • • Central administra- tive staff . . . • . Supervisors . • • Head nurses Staff nurses • • Non-professional nursing personnel • • • • • Source: Tuberculosis Hospitals The following ratios of nurses per patients (based on three major classifications of patient activity) are cited in Minimal Medical and Administrative Standards for Tuberculosis Hospitals and Sanatoria 1/: infirmary patients: 1 nurse per 3 patients semi-ambulant patients* 1 nurse per 8 patients ambulant patients: 1 nurse per 30 patients The preceding source does not indicate the number of professional and non-professional nursing personnel which constitute the above ratios. For the purpose of a State-wide survey, the following ratios (or a variation) might be assumed: Type of Patient Professional Non-Profe s s ional Activity Nurses Nursing Personnel infirmary 1 2 semi-ambulant 1 3 ambulant 1 5 1/ American Trudeau Society, Committee on Sanatorium Standards: MlnimAi Medical and Administrative Standards for Tuberculosis Hospitals and Sanatoria* American Review of Tuberculosis Ll, No. 5 (May 19h£) page 1*8£. Example: Statement of problem: 3000 daily average patient census in registered tuberculosis hospital in State X, 19h9 300 estimated daily average census of infirmary patients 1200 estimated daily average census of semi-ambulant patients estimated daily average census of ambulant patients Selected criteria for estimating needs for nursing personnel Infirmary patients 1 nurse per 3 patients, ratio of professional nurses to non-professional nursing personnel 1:2 Semi-ambulant patients 1 nurse per 8 patients, ratio of professional to non-professional nursing personnel 1:3 Ambulant patients 1 nurse per 30 patients, ratio of professional nurses to non-professional nursing personnel 1:5 Solution: Infirmary patients 300 infirmary patients require 100 nurses at the ratio of 1 nurse per 3 patients; on the assumption of 1 professional nurse to 2 non-professional nursing personnel these 100 nurses will consist of: 33 professional nurses (l/3 x 100) 6? non-professional nursing personnel (2/3 x 100) Semi-ambulant patients 1200 semi-ambulant patients require 150 nurses at the ratio of 1 nurse per 8 patients; on the assumption of 1 professional nurse to 3 non-professional nursing personnel these 150 nurses will consist of: 37 professional nurse {l/k x 15>0) 113 non-professional nursing personnel (3/U x 150) • Ambulant patients 1500 ambulant patients require 50 nurses at the ratio of 1 nurse per 30 patients; on the assumption of 1 professional nurse to 5 non- professional nursing personnel these 50 nurses will consist of: 8 professional nurses (l/6 x 50) U2 non-professional nursing personnel (5/6 x 50)* Since the ratios of nurses per patients are based on three major classi- ♦ fications of patient activity, it will be necessary to estimate the number of hospitalized tuberculosis patients in the State according toi infirmary; semi- ambulant; and ambulant* A conference with the State administrative agency responsible for the supervision of State tuberculosis sanatoria should provide a logical basis for this supposition. Table 12 presents a method of compiling an estimate of the number of nursing personnel currently needed per day by tuberculosis hospitals. Table 12. An estimate of the number of nursing personnel currently needed per day by (registered and unregistered or registered only) tuberculosis hospitals (exclusive of or including Federal hospitals) in (State X), (Date)• Classification of patients in tuberculosis hospitals according to activity Number of nursing personnel currently needed per day Professional Non-professional Total Infirmary Serai-ambulant Ambulant • • Sourcet Mental Hospitals A minimum standard for nursing personnel in mental hospitals (based on Standard for Psychiatric Hospitals and Out-Patient Clinics Approved by the American Psychiatric Association 1/ is: 1 professional nurse per 25 patients 1 non-professional nursing personnel per 1; patients. If the preceding standard is considered inadequate, the need for nursing personnel might be estimated on the basis of the number of psychiatric patients who require: 1. intensive therapeutic care 2. custodial care. The number of nursing personnel needed for psychiatric patients who require intensive therapeutic care can be computed in terms of hours of bedside care* In this respect, it would seem reasonable to use the same criteria (average hours of bedside care per patient in 21; hours, and ratio of professional to non-profes- sional nursing personnel), which have been selected as standards for general and allied special hospitals on a State-wide basis. The number of nursing personnel needed for psychiatric patients requiring custodial care can be computed by using uhe minimum standard (ratios of nursing personnel to patients) suggested in the preceding paragraph. 1/ Committee on Psychiatric Standards and Policies: Standards for psychiatric hospitals and out-patient clinics approved by the American Psychiatric Association 19A5 - 19U6. American Journal of Psychiatry 102:261; - 269 (September 19h5) Example: Statement of problems 3086 daily average patient census in registered mental hospitals in State X, 19U9« 686 estimated daily average census of patients requiring intensive therapeutic care. 21*00 estimated dally average census of patients requiring custodial care. 8 average number of hours worked per day by nursing personnel giving bedside care in mental hospitals in State X. Selected criteria for estimating needs for nursing personnel Patients requiring intensive therapeutic care. 3.5 average number of bedside hours per patient during 2i* hours, the proportion of professional nurses to non- professional nursing personnel giving this direct care in the ratio of 2:1 (total nursing personnel 3* 2/3 professional nurses and l/3 non-professional nursing personnel). Patients requiring custodial care. 1 professional nurse per 25 patients. 1 non-professional nursing personnel per 1* patients. Solution Patients requiring intensive therapeutic care, 686 patients require 300 nursing personnel per day to provide 3*5 average hours of bedside care per patient in 21* hours; on the basis of 1 professional nurse to 2 non-professional nursing personnel the 300 nursing personnel will consist of: 100 professional nurses. 200 non-professional nursing personnel. 686 estimated daily average patient census 3*f> average number of bedside hours per patient In 21* hours 300 number of nursing personnel required per day to provide 3*5 average hours of bedside care per patient in 2i* hours. X 8 average number of hours worked per day by nursing personnel giving bedside care m 300 x 2/3 factor for computing professional nurses 200 professions! nurses required per day to provide 3*5 average hours of bedside care per patient in 21* hours. s 300 x 1/3 factor for computing non-profes- sional nursing personnel 100 non-professional nursing personnel required per day to provide 3*5 average hours of bedside care per patient in 21* hours* ■ Patients requiring custodial care 21*00 patients require 696 nursing personnel per day to meet * the minimum standard of 1 professional nurse per 25 patients and 1 non-professional nursing personnel per 1* patients; on the basis of the preceding ratios the 696 nursing personnel will consist of: 96 professional nurses (21*00 4. 25) 600 non-professional nursing personnel (21*00 7 1*) If the need for nursing personnel is based on the number of psychiatric patients who require intensive therapeutic or custodial care, it will be necessary to estimate the respective number of patients in the State in these two categories. The State Mental Health Authority will probably be the best source to obtain assistance in making this estimate. The following table illustrates one way by which the estimate of the number of nursing personnel currently needed per day by mental hospitals can be assembled. Table 13. An estimate of the number of nursing personnel currently needed per day by (registered and unregistered or registered only) mental hospitals (exclusive of or including Federal hospitals) in (State X), (Date)• Classification of patients in mental hospitals according to type of care required. Number of nursing personnel currently needed per day Professional Non-Professional Total Intensive therapeutic Custodial Source: Chronic Hospitals There are no firmly established standards for computing the number of nursing personnel needed tc provide adequate nursing care to patients in chronic hospitals. The following assumed criteria are suggested for consideration: 1.5 average number of bedside hours per patient during 2k hours; the proportion of professional nurses to non-professional nursing personnel giving this direct care in the ratio - 1 professional nurses 5 non-professional nursing personnel. Example: Statement of problems 500 daily average patient census in registered chronic hospitals in State X, 19i*9. 8 average number of hours worked per day by nursing personnel giving bedside care in chronic hospitals in State X. Selected criteria for estimating needs for nursing personnel. 1.5 average number of bedside hours per patient during 2k hours, the proportion of professional nurse to non-professional nursing personnel giving this direct care in the ratio of Is5 (total nursing personnel 6, 1/6 professional nurses and 5/6 non-professional nursing personnel). Solution: 500 daily average patient census X 1.5 average number of bedside hours per patient in 2k hours 9i+ number of nursing personnel required per day to provide 1*5 average hours of bedside care per patient in 2k hours 8 average number of hours worked per day by nursing personnel giving bedside care 9U x l/6 factor for computing professional nurses 16 professional nurses required per day to provide 1.5 average hours of bedside care per patient in 2k hours 9k x 5/6 factor for computing non-profes- sional nursing personnel 78 non-professional nursing personnel required per day to provide 1.5 average hours of bedside care per patient in 2k hours. Table ll* may be used to record the estimates of the number of profes- sional nurses and non-professional nursing personnel currently needed per day by chronic hospitals. Table ll*. An estimate of the number of nursing personnel currently needed per day by (registered and unregistered or registered only) chronic hospitals (exclusive of or including Federal hospitals) in (State X), (date)* Daily average patient census in chronic Number of nursing personnel currently needed per day Professional Non-professional hospitals Sourcej Total number of nursing personnel needed in hospitals Estimates of the number of professional and non-professional nursing personnel required to meet a selected standard of nursing care in hospitals have been based on the number needed per day. It is necessary to compute the total number needed to include the additional number required to supplement those away from duty for the following reasons* 1* Vacation, holidays, and illness 2* Days off each week. When the preceding factors are used in relation to current needs they should reflect average current practices. If some of these practices are not considered adequate, estimates of future needs should envisage progress in deficient personnel practices. The State Nurses* Association, State Hospital Association, and an agency representing pre-payment hospital plans should be consulted in estimating the current average days away from duty each year of every member of the nursing personnel in hospitals. Formula 13 shows how the total number of nursing personnel needed in hospitals can be computed. Formula 13, Total number of Nursing Personnel needed in hospitals. days in year average number of days worked per year by each member of the nursing personnel in hospitals X number of nursing personnel required per day to meet selected standards of nursing care in hospitals for 2k hours* total number of nursing personnel needed in hospitals. Example: Statement of problem 5300 - number of nursing personnel required to meet the selected standards of nursing care per day in hospitals in State X in 19^9• 100 - average days away from duty each year of every member of the nursing personnel for vacation, holidays, illness, and days off each week. 28 days ( h weeks) away from duty because of vacations, holidays, illness. 72 days away from duty because of days off each week 52 weeks in year - k weeks away from duty for vacation, holidays, illness 5H weeks on duty U8 x lj days off s 72 265 average number of days worked per year by each member of the nursing personnel in hospitals 365 days in year 100 average days away from duty each year for vacations, holidays, and days off each week 265 Solutioni 36g x 5300 = 7300 total number of nursing personnel needed 2&S in hospitals in State X in 19i*9* Summary: Estimated total number of nursing personnel needed by hospitals. Table 15 summarizes the estimates of the total number of nursing personnel currently needed by hospitals. Table 15• An estimate of the total number of nursing personnel currently needed by (registered and unregistered or registered only) hospitals (exclusive of or including Federal hospitals) in (State X), (Date)* Type of hospital Daily average patient Number of nursing personnel needed census Professional Non-professional Total ... General and allied special. • Tuberculosis. ..•••••• Mental. Chronic ...... Source: Table 16 summarizes the estimates of the total number of nursing personnel needed by hospitals in the future * Table 16. An estimate of the total number of nursing personnel needed in the future by hospitals (exclusive of or including Federal hospitals) in (State X), (future date)* Type of beds Anticipated daily Number of nursing personnel needed average patient census Professional Non-Professional Total General and allied special. Tuberculosis. • •••••• Mental. Chronic Source: Summary: SECTION II Table 17 summarizes the estimates of the current and future number of nursing personnel needed by the State according to place of service (see Tables 7, 9, 10, 1$, 16) Table 17. An estimate of the number of nursing personnel required to meet current (date) and future (date) needs in (State X). Place of service Number of nursing personnel needed Current need (date) Future need (date) Professional Non-Pro?. Professional Non-Pro?. Total • ••••• Public Health • Industry • • • • Offices Private practice. • • • . • Hospitals 1/ 1/ Registered and unregistered or registered only; exclusive of or including Federal hospitals Sources An estimate of the current deficits of nursing personnel in the State is revealed in Table 18 when the number of nursing personnel currently needed (Table 1?) is matched with the number of nursing personnel currently employed (Table 6)• Table 18» An estimate of the current deficits of nursing personnel in (State X), (Date) Place of Service Currently needed Number of nursing personnel Currently employed Current deficit Prof. Non-prof. Prof. Non-prof. Prof* Non-prof. Total Public Health • • 4 Industry ••••••• Offices Private practice • Hospitals 2/ •••••• 1/ Currently needed - currently employed a current deficit 2/ Registered and unregistered or registered only; exclusive of or including Federal hospitals. Sources The following chart is a condensation of the discussion in SECTION II relative to suggested criteria and probable sources for obtaining essential information for estimating the number of nursing personnel required to meet current and future needs on a State-wide basis. Chart 2. Suggested criteria and probable sources for obtaining essential information for estimating the number of nursing personnel required to meet current and future needs on a State-wide basis* Place of Service Suggested Criteria Probable sources of‘essential information Public Health 1 public health nurse per 2000 Most recent copy of '‘Current or 5000 population 1 supervisor for every 10 public Population Reports" relative to the current population of the State* health nurses State Planning Commission (or its counterpart) relative to an estimate of the projected population of the State as of a future date* Directors of nursing of the public health agencies in the State relative to: 1* overlapping of nursing activities 2# geographical coverage 3* amount of bedside care given !*• demand for care of chroni- cally ill patients 5* use of non-professional nursing personnel 6* vacancies in budgeted positions Industry 1 nurse*...up to 300 employees State Industrial hygiene Personnel*State Chamber of 2 or more nurses .. up to 600 Commerce! Manufacturers' Association; State Planning employees 3 or more nurses •• up to 1000 Commission (or its counterpart) employees relative to: 1 nurse per each additional !• minimum size of an 1000 employees up to 5000; industrial establishment and 1 nurse per additional to be included in the 2000 employees* category "up to 300 employees"• 2. present number of plants and employees according to size of industrial establishment. • 3* extent of medical and health programs U. accident frequency 5* number of additional shifts 6* amount of nursing participation in health education and home nursing service 7* utilization of part-time nursing services in industrial establishments employing less than 100 workers 8* tendency to employ non-profes- sional nursing personnel 9* extent of supervision of nurses by nurses 10. plans for industrial expansion 11. social and economic trends in the State 12. possible technological advances in the major types of industry represented. Offices current need held constant with State Nurses1 Association relative tEe number of nursing personnel to the number of -their members currently employed* future need dependent upon the engaged in office nursing over a consecutive number of years. consideration of the following State Board of Nurse Examiners factors in the Statej (or appropriate licensing agency) relative to the number of non- 1. inclination to utilize professional nursing personnel nursing personnel in offices 2. an appreciable increase or employed in offices over a consecutive number of years. decrease in the number of Deans of medical, dental, etc. doctors, dentists, etc. schools; State Medical, JJental, etc. Associations relative to an estimate 3* trend in group practice. ofT“ 1. an appreciable increase or decrease in the number of doctors, dentists, etc. (who may be potential employ- ers of nursing personnel in offices) 2. trend in group practice iwhich may influence the number of nursing personnel needed in offices). 77 Private practice current and future need held constant with the number of nursing personnel currently employed Hospitals Nursing personnel in special hospital departments (operating room, central supply, out-patient department, etc.) held constant with the number of nursing personnel currently employed. State Agency Administering the hospital Survey and Planning Program relative to the antici- pated number of hospital beds in the following categories: 1. General and allied special 2. Tuberculosis 3* Mental Chronic State Agency Administering the Hospital Survey and Planning Program; State Hospital Association relative to an estimate of the expected occupancy rate as of a future date. State Nurses* Association; State Hospital Association; Agency representing prepayment hospital plans relative to an estimate of the average days away from duty each year of every member of the nursing personnel for vacation, holidays, illness, and days off each week. General and allied special Hospitals Central Administrative nursing personnel: Most recent copy of ’’Hospital Service in The United States’* 'type of administrative Daily nursing personnel average patient census (including newborn) 2 central administrative staff 100 1 day supervisor 57 1 evening supervisor 57 1 night supervisor 80 1 head nurse 19 relative to: 1. Classification of general hospitals in the State according to a. size of the community in -which they are located b. those with and without schools c. ownership or control d. average census (includ- ing newborn) Nursing personnel giving direct State Board of Nurse Examiners; patient caret State Nurses’ Association; State 3*5 average number of bedside hours per patient during 2l| hours; the proportion of pro- fessional nurses to non-profes- sional nursing personnel giving this direct care in the ratio - 2 professional nurses 1 non- professional nursing personnel League of Nursing Education relative to an estimate of the: 1* percent of basic profes- sional student nurses currently enrolled who are giving direct care to patients. 2. percent of basic profes- sional student service which is as productive as a com- bined hour of professional and non-professional nurse service. 3. percent of basic profes- sional student service which replaces professional nursing service and non- professional nursing service* Tuberculosis Type of Number Ratio of patient of professional State Administrative Agency responsible for the supervlsion Hospitals activity patients nurses to non- of State tuberculosis sanatoria per 1 professional nurse nursing personnel infirmary — 3 1j2 semi-ambulant 8 ls3 ambulant 30 1:5 relative to an estimate of the number of hospitalized tuber- culosis patients in the State according to the classification of patient activity: 1. infirmary 2* semi-ambulant 3. ambulant Mental Hospitals 1 professional nurse per 25 patients 1 non-professional nursing personnel per k patients State Mental Health Authority relative to an estimate of the number of patients in mental hospitals in the State who requires or 1. intensive therapeutic care patients requiring intensive therapeutic care - 3*5 average number of bedside hours per patient during 2k hours; the proportion of professional nurses to non-professional nursing personnel giving this direct care in the ratio - 2• cus to dial care• 2 professional nurses: 1 non- professional nursing personnel patients requiring custodial care 1 professional nurse per 25 patients 1 non-professional nursing personnel per i* patients Chronic Hospitals average number of bedside hours per patient during 2k hours; the proportion of pro- fessional nurses to non-pro- fessional nursing personnel giving this direct patient care in the ratio 1 professional nurses £ non- professional nursing personnel V SECTION III. PLANNING TO MEET THE NEEDS FOR NURSING PERSONNEL Both quality and quantity must be considered in planning to meet the needs for nursing personnel. The present system of nursing education in the State first must be examined both quantitatively and qualitatively. For the purpose of the present study, it is suggested that this analysis should include: 1. Nursing education programs for professional nurses a* Basic professional (Diploma and/or degree programs for undergraduate student nurses) b. Advanced professional (Programs for graduate nurses leading to a degree* Supplementary- work to strengthen inadequate basic programs in nursing is not included.) 2. Training programs for non-professional nursing personnel (Approved training programs for non-professional nursing personnel. Inservice training programs are not included.) An analysis of the existing pattern of nursing education will be evaluated to determine its adequacy in meeting present needs and also to guide policies regarding adjustments to be made to meet future needs. This evaluation may indicate the advisability of reviewing the entire structural plan for higher nursing education in the State. Consideration should also be given to the coordinated hospital system envisaged in the State hospital plan. This design has implications for the distribution and location of nursing education facilities. Another factor which has an influence on the adequacy of the present system of nursing education is the number of nurses presently employed in positions for which they lack preparation. It is necessary to ascertain the extent of this deficiency so that plans can be made to improve the situation. Experience in nursing as well as educational preparation contributes to effective nursing practice. However, in the absence of standards by which to evaluate nursing experience, it is suggested that educational qualifications serve as the major basis for judgment. The following section will discuss sources and methods for obtaining data pertinent to educational qualifications of nursing personnel currently employed and suggest tables for compiling the acquired material. Educational Qualifications of Nursing Personnel Currently Employed The annual census of public health nurses contains information relative to the educational qualifications of professional nurses currently employed by public health agencies. Table 19 illustrates a method of compiling this information. Table 19 — Educational qualifications of full time nurses employed by public health agencies in (State X), (Date). Full time nurses Total Supervisors Staff dumber Percent dumber Percent dumber Percent Educational qualifications Total Less than high school graduation High school but no college degree One or more collegiate degree. •••• Total None .»•.•••• Less than one academic year One or more academic years. • • • • General education Public Health program of study Source: The yearly census of industrial nurses includes information relative to general education and post-graduate professional education for registered nurses (supervisors and staff) employed full time by industry. Utilization i this material involves a recognition of the following factors* 1. Both general education and post-graduate professional education are recorded only for those for whom data are known. 2. Post-graduate professional education of those for whom data are known states that the total nurses are included in one or more of the following subdivisions* clinical courses industrial hygiene courses public health program of study. Table 20 shows how this material might be compiled. Table 20 — Educational qualifications of full time registered nurses employed by industry in (State X), (Date) Educational qualifications Full time registered nurses "Total ~ Staffi" ~~ dumber Percent Humber Percent Dumber” yiroent General Education Total ••••••••<> Less than high school graduation • ••••••••• Higfr school graduation only .... Some college • • One or more academic degrees Total Clinical courses less than 1 month • more than 1 month but less than 3 months • 3 months or more Industrial hygiene courses without credit with credit less than 1 full-time academic year one or mors full-time academic years Public Health Program of study less than 1 full-time academic year • •••••••• one or more full-time academic years* * Post-graduate professional education Sources The State Board of Nurse Examiners will probably have information pertinent to the educational qualifications of instructional personnel in approved basic schools of nursing and training programs for non-professional nursing personnel. The arrangement of this data in a table will of course depend upon the specific categories of educational qualifications for which the information was collected. Existing data relative to the educational qualifications of graduate professional nurses (acquired from the preceding sources) may be considered inadequate. If the collection of additional information is contemplated, the following questionnaire (designed to be mailed to individual hospitals to obtain the educational qualifications of professional and non-professional nursing personnel) might be considered as a pattern. Questionnaire £s Mailed questionnaire to individual hospitals to (Parts 1, 2) obtain a record of the educational qualifications of t graduate professional nurses currently employed non-professional nursing personnel currently employed. Hospital Address Professional preparation beyond basic course (9) One or more academic years 1/ Include: a* part time and full time graduate professional nurses b. graduate professional nurses on afternoon and night duty as well as those off duty because of days off, vacation, or illness* 2/ Record only the highest level in general education (Columns 3 to 6) for each graduate professional nurse. (8) Less than one academic year Distribution by educational qualifications Record of the educational qualifications of graduate professional nurses currently employed 1/ (Date: Month, day, year) (7) None (6) One or more academic degrees Questionnaire £ Part 1 a 0 •H P 1 a> ■d o a C5 (5) Some College No Degree (U) High school only 1(3) Less than ligh school Number of graduate professional nurses (2) To: (Name of Group sponsoring survey) Total Director and assistant director of nurses and/or nursing school Instructors Supervisors and assistant super- visors (charge of more than one uard unit) ftead nursesand assistant head nurses (charge of one ward unit only Staff nurses Position (i) Questionnaire- 5> Part 2 To: (Name of group sponsoring survey) Hospital Address Record of the educational qualifications of non-professional nursing personnel currently employed l/ (Date: Month, day, year) Number of non-prof ess icnal nursing personnel (2) Distribution by Educational Qualification Position (i) Less than gighth grade (3) Complet- ed eighth grade only (h) Some high school (5) On the Job train- ing only (7) Grad- uated from high school (6) Graduated from an approved school foi practical nurses (8) Non-professional nursing personnel; practical nurses, attendants, etc. (those who spend the major part of their time assist- ing with nursing duties) 1/ Includes a* part-time and full-time non-professional nursing personnel b. non-professional nursing personnel on afternoon and night duty as well as those off duty because of days off, vacation or illness. 2/ Record only the highest level in general education (columns 3-6) for each non- professional nursing personnel. If Questionnaire 5 (or a variation) is used. Tables 21 and 22 are suggested as guides for assembling the collected information. TO ® TO I «H cd -P CO -p a ® o 0) Os Jh ® ,0 23 -P G ® * • Sh 0) S5 +3 £ ® a • h CD £5 G CD O u ® P* U a) X> -p cl ® a u ® a. u ® x» 2: +3 G ® o G ® (X, U ® ji Table 21. Educational qualifications of graduate professional nurses employed by (registered and unregistered or registered only) hospitals (exclusive of or including Federal hospitals) in (State X), (Date). TO -P ® TO TO tH H TO P TO G © TO XI T) -P © G G ® © © ® TO & O O o •H ra © rQ X) G £ ® G O •H -P © U a ® u a H § C •H m m ® «h o 5h a TO -P To O *H TO TO •H TO > gj *-t TO ® T3 -P § CO —' a o •H -P © o ■S w t ® g © o TO u 5 +3 I H © 0 ra G ® a t£ 5 m 1 a •H TO TO © O XJ OX) H G © • • • © • © • • xi ri o o m o id #•©•©• • *H © C Xl H toO ® TO H • O • ® • H O ® Jh ® cd U © G OH O® -P • G ■ • Q TO -P cd X H £ h O © G £ *-. OXlOO M H • Xl © cd IH -p TO O Ci © -P®Ci® O T3 >i O i>i rax1 © ® to TO bD £ ffi G TO ® ©•hog p ® G M XI CO O 23 H O TO G O ■g 33 G © 0 o •H *H -P «H 8 3 1 I Sources Table 22, Educational qualifications of non-professional nursing personnel employed by (registered and unregistered or registered only) hospitals (exclusive of or including Federal hospitals) in (State X), (date). Educational qualifications Non-professional nursing personnel Number Percent General education Training Total Less than eighth grade Completed eighth grade only Some high school. •••••••••• Graduated from high school. • • • • • Total On-the-job training only • Graduated from an approved school for practical nurses • • • • Sources It is highly desirable that the appraisal of the system of nursing educa- tion in the Sthte be based on an individual assessment of each program. If such a detailed review is not possible, there are certain gross measures applicable to the total nursing education system which have qualitative inferences. Con- clusions reached through this less refined method will not be sufficient as a basis for a thorough revision of the existing pattern of nursing education. If the results of an overall evaluation indicate the necessity of making drastic and extensive changes, plans should be made for a comprehensive and detailed review of the theory and practice of each program of study. The following section emphasizes considerations pertinent to an overall gross evaluation of the present system of nursing education. Reference is made, however, to published material which will be useful as a guide if a detailed review is contemplated. Basic Professional Programs (Diploma and/or Degree Programs for Undergraduate Student Nurses) The State Board of Nurse Examiners is the best source for obtaining data relative to the basic professional schools of nursing. If it is expedient to compare selected items in basic schools in the State with other States, Facts About Nursing 1/ State Accredited Schools of Nursing 2/, and Some Qualitative and Quantitative Factors in Nurse Education 3/ should be utilized. The National League of Education (1790 Broadway, New York City, N.T.) may have material (compiled in recent national studies), which is available for use by a State. As stated previously, quality is difficult to appraise without an individual assessment of each program. However, a gross evaluation based on answers to the following questions will give some indication of the effective- ness of the basic professional schools in producing the quality of professional nurses needed. 1/ American Nurses1 Association: Facts About Nursing. 1790 Broadway, ” New York 19, New York. 2/ National League of Nursing Education, Department of Studies: State Accredited Schools of Nursing. National League of Nursing Education, New York, 19U6. 3/ Vreeland, Ellwynne M.s Some Qualitative and Quantitative Factors in Nurse ~ Ed^9abi°n. Public Health Reports, Vol. 63, No. $2• U. S. Government Printing Office, Washington, D.C., 191*8, 1. Are there sufficient opportunities for able potential students from all groups to enroll in schools of nursing? nWe recommend that nurses everywhere seek to recruit students and personnel without regard to sex, marital status, economical back- ground, or ethnic, racial, and religious origins. We recommend particularly that positive steps be taken by the profession to create an atmosphere conducive to attracting carefully selected representatives of a true cross-section of the population to nursing”.!/ 2. What percent of the schools are accredited by: a* State Board of Nurse Examiners? b. National Nursing Accrediting Service? 3. How many of the schools have been accredited as graduating nurses eligible for staff positions in Public Health nursing agencies? i*. How many of the collegiate schools providing degree programs for under- graduate nurses are recognized by the Association of Collegiate Schools of Nursing as beings a. Active members? b. Associate members? ,fWe recommend that nursing make one of its first matters of important business the long overdue official examination of eveiy school; that the list of accredited schools be published and distributed as far as possible to every town and city of the United States as an avowed substitute (except legally) for the inadequate lists of schools accredited by State boards of nurse examiners; that an unequivocal statement be included in the published document to the effect that any school not named had failed to meet minimum requirements for accreditation or had refused to permit examination; that a Nation-wide educational campaign be conducted for the purpose of rallying broad public support for accredited schools and for subjecting slow moving State boards and non-accredited schools to strong social pressure. 1/ Brown, Esther L.: Nursing For The Future. Russell Sage Foundation, ” New York, 19US* page 197* wife recommend,further, that provision be made for periodic re-examination of all schools listed or others requesting it, as well as for first examina- tion of new schools, and for publication and distribution of the revised lists.” 1/ ”Its requirements (Association of Collegiate Schools of Nursing) ... are so reasonable, that any school established on a base that educators generally consider sound would have little difficulty in securing membership ”Under such circumstances the task of the future is decisive. It is to strengthen further schools that hold or are eligible for membership in the Association of Collegiate Schools of Nursing; to reconsider whether schools that are unlikely to be able to meet some such reasonable standards within the next few years should continue; and to establish new professional schools where surveys indicate they are most needed, would receive substantial financial support, and would attract sufficiently large student bodies”.2/ 5* Tlhat percent of the hospitals associated with schools of nursing are approved by* a* Council on Medical Education and Hospitals fors internships? residencies? both internships and residencies? neither internships or residencies? b. American College of Surgeons? The quality of medical care determined through approval by appropriate agencies gives some indication of the opportunities provided in the clinical facilities used by the schools which may contribute to breadth of nursing knowledge and technical competence* How many of the schools are controlled bys What proportion of the total student enrollment is ins a* Colleges or universities? b. Hospitals with a daily average patient census of l£0 or more? c. Hospitals with a daily average patient census of less than 150? 1/ Brown, Esther L.s Nursing For The Future. Bussell Sage Foundation, ” New York, 19U8, page 116. 2/ Ibid., page 177 ff* (Writer*s parenthetical insert) 7* What percent of the students have planned experience ins a. Nursery school? b. Psychiatry? c • Tuberculosi s ? d. Other communicable disease? e. Outpatient department? f. Community health? 8. How many of the students have experience in a: a. Large medical center? b* Small rural hospital? "Nursing schools should be operated as far as possible by colleges and large hospitals (with an average daily census of at least l£0 patients), which should develop affiliations with other general and special hospitals serving contiguous areas (including tuber- culosis sanatoria and hospitals for nervous and mental diseases and contagious illness) and with public health agencies in both rural and urban communities".1/ ,!In the light of current needs for graduate bedside nurses and current opportunities for their education,we recommend that those hospital schools here designated as relatively good make concerted effort through various types of experimentation to increase their vitality and social usefulness and to point the way to an ultimate solution of the 'hospital school problem1 ." 2/ "We recommend not only that there be expressed conviction that provision should be made within the university for the continuing undiminished contribution of distinguished hospital schools; but that they be given wholehearted assistance in achieving this reorganization by the entire nursing profession, medical and hospital associations concerned with nursing, university and hospital administrator, university faculties, administrators and faculties of schools of medicine and public health, foundations, and those members of the laity influential in effecting policy and influencing public opinion"^/ 1/ The Commission on Hospital Cares Hospital Care in the United States. ~ Commonwealth Fund, New York, page 87. 2/ Brown, Esther L.J Nursing For The Future, Russell Sage Foundation, New York, 19U8, page 12?. 3/ Ibid, p. 132 "To improve hospital service along its three major fronts - preventive, diagnostic, therapeutic, all States are now developing their 'coordinated hospital system'. Such a plan proposes tying all hospitals into a cooperative hook-up, in which there would be constant exchange of information, training, consultation service and personnel, and in which patients would be referred from one hospital to another." 1/ 9* How many schools are operated by the following types of specialized hospitals: a* Mental? b. Tuberculosis? c. Children's? ”The question ... should be raised of whether the future function of these particular hospitals (mental, tuberculosis, children's) does not lie entirely in providing affiliation, rather than in attempting to operate small schools.” 2/ 10. Ytoat percent of the schools have a total enrollment of less than 100 students? ”The highest percentage of poor and very poor schools are among those having an enrollment of less than 100 students”,3/ 11. What is the average ratio of nurse administrators and instructors to students? "The average ratio of nurse administrators and instructors to students was 1 to 6.£”, h/ 12. Are. there centralized teaching plans? 13. Do central schools of nursing exist? 1/ Federal Security Agency, U.S. Public Health Service, Division of Hospital Facilities* Plans of General Hospitals For The Coordinated Hospital System, Reprinted from Architectural Record, January 19U8, page 6* 2/ Brown, Esther L,i Nursing For The Future. Russell Sage Foundation, New York, 191*8, page 137 , 3/ Vreeland, Ellwynne M.s Some Qualitative and Quantitative Factors in Nurse Education* Public Health Reports, Vol. 63, No* £2. U* S* Government Printing Office, TSashington, D.C*, 19U8, p, 1689* h/ Ibid, page 1688. 111* Are the teaching resources of junior colleges utilized? ’’Especially recommended as transitional steps toward the future are the creation of central schools of nursing, and utilization of the teaching resources of junior colleges.” 1/ 15. What percent of the administrative and instructional nursing personnel have one or more academic degrees? ’’General qualifications for faculty positions in schools of nursing and related nursing service positions: A broad general education equivalent to at least two years of general college work. Advanced professional study in a college or university of good standing with academic recognition in the form of at least the bachelor's (preferably the master's) degree to include not less than one year of specialized, professional preparation in a particular field with adequate related experience in this area.” 2/ 16. What correlations are revealed when State Board examination results over a period of time are analyzed in relation to such factors as: a. Size of the hospitals in which students receive their major clinical experiences? b. Size of student enrollment? c. Number of clinical services provided each student? d. Qualifications of administrative and instructional nursing personnel? ”It is believed that the educational achievement (performance in licensure examination) of the graduates of the schools with- in a State as determined by the respective State boards of nurse examiners is an important criterion in evaluating the educational program of a State”. 17* What is the ratio of diploma to degree students? ’’Two thirds of the States had in 19kk~h5 less than 1 student in lU or no students at all (the case in 7 States) enrolled in pro- grams leading to an academic degree. To meet the need for better patient care and to provide for better prepared instructors, admin- istrators, and leaders in nursing, this ratio is far too small.”!;/ 1/ Brown, Esther L.s Nursing For The Future, Bussell Sage Foundation, New York, 19U8, p. 127. 2/ National League of Nursing Education, Committee on Revision of the Faculty Pamphlet: Faculty Positions In Schools of Nursing and How to Prepare For Them National League of Nursing Education, 1790 Broadway, N.Y. 19* 19U6, p. 13• 3/ Vreeland, Ellwynne M. j Some Qualitative and Quantitative Factors in Nurse Education, Public Health Reports, Vol. 63, No, 52. U.S. Government Printing Office, mshington, D.C,, 19R8. p, I68ii. k/ Ibid, p. 1688. Degree programs for undergraduate nurses 18. What percent of the schools controlled by colleges or universities are: a. Independent administrative units? b. Separate departments or schools? 19* Do specific written contracts exist between the college or university and the hospitals and agencies providing student experience? 20. Are qualified members of the administrative and instructional nursing personnel given academic status? 21. What is the basis for the selection of students? 22. Are degrees in nursing granted on the same basis as other degrees? 23. Do the curricula meet the requirements ofi a. College or university? b. Professional practice and State registration? 2k» Does the college or university give recognition to the curriculum of the school of nursing on the same basis as other departments or divisions? Criterion "It is a complete structural and functional unit for the conduct of a program of nursing education and is an integral part of a college or university.” WA clearly defined agreement is in effect between the college or univer- sity and the affiliating agencies regarding their responsibilities in relation to the school.H "The faculty has academic status in accordance with the statutory pro- visions for faculty rank in the college or university.” ‘•Students are selected according to admission requirements by the faculty of the school. In addition to general requirements, students are selected on the basis of characteristics essential to nursing. Students are qualified for matriculation in the college or university as candidates for a degree.” “The general requirements governing the granting of degrees as established by the college or university govern the granting of degrees in nursing." "The curriculum meets the requirements of the college or university for a baccalaureate or higher degree as well as the requirements for professional practice and State registration.” "The instruction, inclusive of class work, laboratory work, and clinical experience, which combined make up the content of the curriculum, is so related and of such quality as to command recog- nition comparable to that given for similar types of instruction in other departments or divisions in the college or university." 1/ If visits to the individual schools are possible, material contained in A Guide For Supervision of State Approved Schools of Nursing 2/ and Survey Methods Applied to Schools 6Y Nursing and Hospital Nursing Service 3/ (see Survey Methods Relating to the Basic Nursing Curriculum, in a University or Collegiate School of Nursing) will suggest pertinent trends of inquiry. Advanced Professional Programs (Programs for graduate nurses leading to a degree) For the purpose of the present study, it has been suggested that advanced professional programs should include those offered to graduate nurses, which lead to a degree and prepare them "for positions as administrators, supervisors, or teachers in schools of nursing, nursing service, or public health nursing agencies, and for public health nursing general staff positions", k/ Information pertinent to a gross evaluation of this type of program can be compiled from school catalogues and unpublished factual material ob- tainable from the colleges or universities offering such courses of study. The Association of Collegiate Schools of Nursing (2063 Adalbert Road, Cleveland, Ohio) may be able to supply additional information relative to the advanced curricula of active or associate members. An overview of the advanced professional programs should include the following questions: 1. How many colleges or universities offer advanced professional programs? 2. How many programs of each type are available? l/ Indiana University School of Education, Division of Nursing Education! “ Survey Methods Applied to Schools of Nursing and Hospital Nursing Services. Indiana University Bookstore, Bloomington, Indiana, 19U8, page U8 ff. 2/ American Nurses1 Associations A Guide For Supervision of State Approved Schools of Nursing, New York, 19ii8, 3/ Indiana University School of Education, Division of Nursing Education: Survey Methods Applied to Schools of Nursing and Hospital Nursing Services. Indiana University Bookstore, Bloomington, Indiana, 19i|8. h/ Department of Studies, National League of Nursing Education: Graduate Nurses Enrolled in Colleges and Universities. American Journal of Vol k9i page 181 (March 19U9) 3. THhat is the number of full-time and part-time students enrolled according to: a. academic level? b. type of program? c• scholarship status ? i*. What percent of the enrolled students are residents of other States? "We recommend that appropriate nursing bodies initiate planning on a State-wide basis for the distribution of the kinds of schools that are designated to meet State needs; and that planning be undertaken on a regional and Nation-wide basis for those higher forms of nursing education that require fewer units, but consequently greater selectivity of resources and location*” 1/ “Until such time as the number of students completing basic degree programs is vastly increased, attention must obviously be placed upon helping grad- uate nurses to obtain the baccalaureate* Simultaneously preparation on higher levels must be forwarded as rapidly as possible.” 2/ "Through such a study (comprehensive study of advanced curricula) univer- sities might be encouraged to cultivate those particular courses for which they were best fitted without feeling obliged to continue to offer prepara- tion for several kinds of specialization. Almost certainly this explora- tion would point to the desirability of setting aside a few centers devoted exclusively to the development of truly graduate work. Their faculties would be freed from dissipation of time and energy concomitant to helping graduate nurses prepare for the bachelor's degree. Instead they would be expected to concern -themselves through experimental teaching, research, and writing with the further development of content and method for all nursing education, and with producing teachers more fully prepared to staff university schools."3/ If a detailed study of each advanced professional program is to be made, suggestions contained in A Guide For The Organization of Collegiate Schools of Nursing h/ and Courses in Clinical Nursing For Graduate Nurses 5/ will be helpful. 1/ Brown, Esther L.s Nursing For The Future, Bussell Sage Foundation, “ New York, 19U8, page 186. 2/ Ibid; page 161 3/ Ibid; page 162 ff. (Writer's parenthetical insert) C/ National League of Nursing Educations A Guide For The Organization of Collegiate Schools of Nursing. National League of Nursing Education, New York, 19^6. 5>/ National League of Nursing Educations Courses In Clinical Nursing For Graduate Nurses. National league of Nursing Education, New lork, Approved Training Programs For Non-Professional Nursing Personnel The source of information for obtaining data relative to approved training programs for non-professional nursing personnel will depend upon the licensure laws of the State. ”In states with laws for practical nurse licensure, it is expected that practical nurses will be prepared in schools of practical nursing offering programs of training approved by the state board of education and state board of nurse examiners, or other legally authorized accrediting agency which approves schools of professional nursing in that state**• "Until a single, national accrediting body for both professional and practical nursing schools is functioning, schools in states where the licensing law does not provide for the licensing of practical nurse schools are urged to apply for approval to the Committee on Adminis- tration of the Accrediting Program of the National League of Nursing Education which cooperates with the National Association for Practical Nurse Education." 1/ The National Association For Practical Nurse Education (6£U Madison Avenue, New York City, N.Y.) may be able to supply additional information relative to approved programs in the State* Answers to the following questions will Influence the conclusions reached as a result of a gross evaluation of approved programs of training for non-professional nursing personnel* 1. How many of the programs are conducted by: a. boards of management or social agencies? b. hospitals? c. public vocational schools? "The Committee decided unanimously, after long consideration, that training should be provided by vocational or adult education units of the public school system... ".2/ 2. How many of the programs are: a. less than 12 months? b. 12 months or more? 1/ Joint Committee on Auxiliary Nursing Service:Practical Nurses and Auxiliary Workers for the Care of the Sick. American Nurses’ Association, New York. 19i*7, page 8. 2/ Brown, Esther L.: Nursing For The Future. Russell Sage Foundation, New York, 191*8, page 10U* 3» What percent of the programs include elementary nursing care for the following types of patients: a. medical? b. surgical? c. pediatric? d. obstetrical or urological? iu How many of the programs provide instruction and supervised practice ins a. home nursing? b. care of chronic and convalescent patients? MIt (Professional Advisory Committee) recommended that the period of training be one year, divided between classroom and bedside instruc- tion, and that an understanding of the patient as well as nursing techniques be emphasized.” l/ UA practical nurse is a person trained to care for subacute, conval- escent, and chronic patients requiring nursing services at homes or in institutions. • 2/ 5* What educational qualifications are required for trainees? ,!The principal educational qualifications for trainees should be their ability to profit from instruction. However, it is suggested that the completion of 2 years of high school, or the equivalent, may be expected of applicants under 25 years of age, and the completion of the eighth grade, or its equivalent, may be required for applicants over 25 years of age." 3/ 6. What are the general educational qualifications of the administrative and instructional personnel? "Director a good general education, with academic recognition of a bachelor's degree in nursing education. Instructor in nursing;- a good general education; two years or Supervisor of more of college are recommended, including Clinical Experience courses in principles of learning and teaching and related methods.” h/ 1/ Brown, Esther L.tNursing For The Future.Russell Sage Foundation, New York, 19i;8, page lOi*. (Writer's parenthetical insert) 2/ Federal Security Agency, Office of Education: Practical Nursing - An Analysis of the Practical Nurse Occupation with Suggestions for the Organization of Training Programs. U. S. Government Printing Office, Washington, D.C., page. 1 ff. 3/ Ibid; page lUl. 5/ Curriculum and Accrediting Committees, National Association For Practical Nurse Education: Practical Nurse Education. National Association For Practical Nurse Education, New York, 19h7, page 9. ?• Is there an active interest in practical nursing-? "No system of training for practical nurses is likely to succeed unless the public that creates broad general policy and provides funds, educators who design and operate instructional programs, hospitals and agencies that provide clinical facilities, and nursing associations and state boards of control that set standards and influence recruiting are prepared to manifest an active interest in practical nursing far beyond any interest yet shown." 1/ Material contained in Practical Nursing - An Analysis of the Practical Nurse Occupation vd.th Suggestions for the Organization of Training Programs 2/ will be useful as a basis for evaluating individual programs* The forthcoming publication of the committee appointed by the U* S* Office of Education to develop a practical nursing curriculum guide should also be helpful. Financial Support For Preparing Nursing Personnel It is desirable to have information on the cost of preparing profes- sional and non-professional nursing personnel under the present system of nursing education in the State. If such data are not available and a study of this type is contemplated, reference should be made to Administrative Cost Analysis For Nursing Service and Nursing Education 3/ and Cost Analysis For Schools of Nursing* k/ 1/ Brown, Esther L.s Nursing For The Future* Russell Sage Foundation, New York, 19U8, page 10f>. 2/ Federal Security Agency, Office of Education: Practical Nursing - An Analysis of the Practical Nurse Occupation with Suggestions for the Organization of Training Programs* U, S* Government Printing Office, Washington, D. C., 19^7* 3/ Pfefferkorn, Blanche and Rovetta., Charles: Administrative Cost Analysis For Nursing Service and Nursing Education. American Hospital Association and National League of Nursing Education, New York, 19h0, h/ Federal Security Agency, Public Health Service: Cost Analysis For Schools of Nursing, U* S* Government Printing Office, Washington, D*C. The economic aspect of future plans for the education of professional nurses and training of non-professional nursing personnel should take cognizance of the recommendations pertinent to finances contained in Nursing For The Future l/, A Program For The Nursing Profession 2/, and Higher Education For American Democracy 3/. Computing the Annual Number of Students who must be Enrolled in Basic Schools of Nursing and Training Programs for Non-professional Nursing Personnel to Meet Estimated Needs. It is necessary to compute the number of professional and non-profes- sional nursing personnel who should be enrolled each year for a selected period of time in order to meet the estimated needs for nursing personnel. The length of time selected for this purpose will depend upon the extent of the current deficit of nursing personnel and the conclusions reached as a result of the evaluation of the present system of nursing education. Computations relative to annual enrollments must include the number of nursing personnel required to: 1, maintain the current pool 2, make up the current deficit and provide for future needs. The future pool of nursing personnel is composed of the number ofs 1. professional and non-professional nursing personnel currently employed (minus the attrition rate). 2, students currently enrolled in approved basic schools for professional nurses and training programs for non-professional nursing personnel (minus the withdrawal rate). 1/ Brown, Esther Luc lies Nursing For The Future. Russell Sage Foundation, " New York, 19^8. 2/ Committee On The Function of Nursing* A Program For The Nursing Profession, MacMillan Company, New York, 19U8• 3/ Report of The President’s Commission on Higher Education* Higher Education For American Democracy, U, S, Government Printing Office, Washington, D.C. 19U7. The attrition rate for active registered nurses has been variously estimated from about 6 to 10 percent per annum. In the absence of a comparable rate for non-professional nursing personnel it may be necessary to assume the same loss per year as that of the professional group. The average withdrawal rate for students in approved basic schools of nursing and training programs for non-professional nursing personnel can be computed by the following steps: !• subtract the number of students graduated annually from the number of students originally admitted to those classes. 2* divide the result obtained through step 1 by the number of students originally admitted to those classes* Example: 500 number of students admitted to approved schools of nursing in State X in 19U5 350 number of students who graduated from approved schools of nursing in State X in (the required period of time for approved programs in basic schools of nursing in State X is 3 years). l50 number of students who withdrew from approved schools of nursing in State X, - 19U8. 150 ♦ 500 - 30% withdrawal rate for the students admitted to approved schools of nursing in State X in 19^5* When the •withdrawal rate has been computed, the number of students who can be expected to graduate in the future can be estimated by multiplying the number of students admitted (currently and in the future) by the complement of the withdrawal rate (the resulting percentage when the withdrawal percentage is subtracted from 100 percent)* Example: 700 number of students admitted to approved schools of nursing in State X in I9I4.7 X 70$ complement of the 'withdrawal rate (100$ - 30$ (withdrawal percentage) = 70$) 1*90 number of students who can be expected to graduate in State X in 195>0 from those admitted to approved schools of nursing in 19U7« Information relative to the number of students- admitted and graduated from approved basic schools of nursing and training programs for non-professional nursing personnel can probably be obtained from the State Board of Nurse Examiners or the appropriate licensing agency. The following example illustrates how the annual number of students who must be enrolled in basic schools of nursing in State X (1950 - 1956) was computed in order to meet the estimated need for graduate professional nurses in 1959* Example: Statement of problem: (1) 1950 - 1956 period of time selected in which to meet the estimated need for graduate professional nufses in State X in 1959. (2) 2600 number of graduate professional nurses currently employed in State X (19U9) (3) Uk00 estimated number of graduate professional nurses needed in State X (1959) (li) 8$ attrition rate per year for graduate professional nurses (5) 30$ average withdrawal rate for students admitted to approved basic schools of nursing (6) 180 number of professional student nurses who can be expected to graduate in 1950 257 number of students admitted to approved schools of nursing in 19U7 X 70$ complement of the withdrawal rate (100$ - 30$ = 70%) 180 190 number of professional student nurses who can be expected to graduate in 1951 2?1 number of students admitted to approved schools of nursing in 19i*8 X_70% complement of the withdrawal rate 190 200 number of professional student nurses who can be expected to graduate in 1952 286 number of students admitted to approved schools of nursing in 19h9 X 70$ complement of the withdrawal rate 200 Solution* Attrition Table (Based on 8$ attrition rate per year for graduate professional nurses) At end of 1 year only 92.0$ will be left (100.0 - 8.0) « « H 2 years « 81*.6$ « M " ( 92.0 x 92.0) ti it it 3 years « 77.8$ " " « ( 81*.6 x 92.0) » " " ij. years M 71.6$ « 11 » ( 77.8 x 92.0) « « « 5 years » 65.9$ « u «i ( 71.6 x 92.0) « M « 6 years « 60.6$ " 11 M ( 65-9 x 92.0) n " "7 years " 55-8$ 11 M " ( 60.6 x 92.0) " 11 n 8 years « 51.3$ « 11 " ( 55-8 x 92.0) " 11 9 years " 1*7.2$ « « « ( 51.3 x 92.0) « 11 ”10 years « 1*3.1*$ 11 H " ( 1*7-2 x 92.0) 1128 number of graduate professional nurses currently employed who will be left at the end of 10 years (1959). 2600 number of graduate professional nurses currently employed x i*3«l*$ refer to attrition table, 10th year USB— 85 number of professional nurses who will be left at the end of 9 years (1959) from the number of professional student nurses who can be expected to graduate in 1950* 180 number of professional student nurses who can be expected to graduate in 1950. x 1*7*2$ refer to attrition table, 9th year "55— 97 number of professional nurses who will be left at the end of 9 years (1959) from the number of professional student nurses who can be expected to graduate in 1951* 190 number of professional student nurses who can be expected to graduate in 1951 • x 51*3$ refer to attrition table, 8th year 97 112 number of professional nurses who will be left at the end of 9 years (1959) from the number of professional student nurses who can be expected to graduate in 1952. 200 number of professional student nurses who can be expected to graduate in 1952 x 55*8$ refer to attrition table, 7th year nr 11*22 number of graduate professional nurses available in 1959 from those currently employed (19l*9) plus the number remaining from those who can be expected to graduate in 1950, 1951* 1952. 1*1*00 estimated number of graduate professional nurses needed in 1959• -11*22 2978 number of graduate professional nurses to be supplied by 1959 from student nurses graduating in 1953 - 1959 'who must be enrolled in 1950 - 1956. n s number of professional student nurses who should be enrolled each year 1950 - 1956 •7n ■ number of professional student nurses who can be expected to graduate each year 1953 ~ 1959 (based on 30$ withdrawal rate) • ?n (60.6$) refer to attrition table, 6th year ■> number of professional nurses aho will be left in 1959 from those who can be expected to graduate in 1953 •7n (65*9$) refer to attrition table, 5th year - number of professional nurses who will be left in 1959 from those who can be expected to graduate in 195k • 7n (71*6$) refer to attrition table, kth year s number of professional nurses who will be left in 1959 from those who can be expected to graduate in 1955 •7n (77*8$) refer to attrition table, 3rd year b number of professional nurses who will be left in 1959 from those who can be expected to graduate in 1956 *7n (8k*6$) refer to attrition table, 2nd year s number of professional nurses who will be left in 1959 from those who can be expected to graduate in 1957 • 7n ( 92$) refer to attrition table, 1st year = number of professional nurses who will be left in 1959 from those who can be expected to graduate in 1958 #7n ■ number of professional nurses who can be expected to graduate in 1959* .7n (.606 / .659 / -716 / .778 / .8U6 / .92 1) = 2978. Adding the factors inside the parenthesis produces: •7n (5.525) - 2978 Multiplying »7h times 5*525 produces 3.8675 n - 2978 Solving the equation for n n = 770 number of students who must be enrolled in basic schools of nursing in State X each year 1950 — 1956 to meet the estimated need for graduate professional nurses in 1959* Computing the Average Percent of High School Graduates who must be Enrolled in Nursing Programs to Produce the dumber of Nursing Personnel Needed~ Having estimated the annual number of students who must be enrolled (for a selected period of time in the future) in basic schools of nursing and training programs for non-professional nursing personnel, it is expedient to estimate the number of students who will graduate from high school for the corresponding projected period of time, 'When this has been accomplished, it -will be possible to determine the approximate percent of high school graduates who must be enrolled in undergraduate nursing programs to meet the quota of professional and non- professional nursing personnel needed. The annual number of high school graduates in the future can be estimated by subtracting the number of children who die before they enter school from the number of live births 18 years previous to graduation, and multiplying the remainder by the average percent (for the latest five year period) of students who entered the first grade and completed high school* Since the majority of nursing personnel are women, consideration should be given to including females only in the computations entailed in the preceding suggested method. Examplei Statement of problems - number of female live births 18 years previous to graduation (1932) in State x lit, - number of deaths (1932-1937) among female preschool children bom in 1932 in State x 11,918 under 1 year (1933) 1,14.69 1 year (193U) 623 2 years (1935) 1+67 3 years (1936) 3l+8 it years (1937) hl% - average percent of female students entering first grade who completed high school during the last five years (19iUt - 191+9) in State x* Solution: 189,1458 - 114,825 1714.633 estimated number of female children born 18 years previously who entered the first grade in 1938. 178.633 X \£% 82,07bestimated number of female high school graduates in State x in 1950* Note: The example makes no corrections for migration or the number of deaths of preschool female children occurring in the fifth year of life. If information relative to these two items is available in the State, they should be incorporated into the estimate. The State registrar of vital statistics will have information pertinent to the number of live births, and deaths of preschool children. The annual statistical reports of births 1/ and deaths 2/ published (prior to I9I45) by the Bureau of the Census contains information for each State in the form used in the preceding example. The State Department of Education is the agency to be contacted to ascertain the average percent of students entering the first grade who completed high school during the latest five year period. The average percent of high school graduates who must be enrolled in nursing programs to produce the number of nursing personnel needed, is revealed when the total number of students who must be enrolled in nursing programs for a selected period of time in the future is divided by the total number of high school graduates for a corresponding period of time. 1/ Bureau of the Census, United States Department of Commerces Annual Report, Birth, Still Birth, and Infant Mortality Statistics for the Birth Regis- tration Area of the United States, U. S. Government Printing Office, Washington, D.C. 2_/ Bureau of the Census, United States Department of Commerce: Annual Report Mortality Statistics. U. S. Government Printing Office, Washington, D.C. Examples Statement of problems 12000 estimated total number of students who must be enrolled in nursing programs to meet the need for nursing personnel in State x in I960 8000 students in basic schools of nursing U000 students in training programs for non-profes- sional nursing personnel 150,000 estimated total number of high school graduates in State x 1950 - I960. Solution: 12,000 = g% average percent of high school graduates who must 150,000 be enrolled in nursing programs (basic schools of nursing and training programs for non-professional nursing personnel) to meet the need for nursing personnel in State x in I960. Summary: SECTION III Emphasis in SECTION HI has been placed on the points 1* evaluating the present system of nursing education in the State 2. computing the annual number of students who must be enrolled in basic schools of nursing and training programs for non-professional nursing personnel to meet estimated needs. 3* computing the average percent of high school graduates who must be enrolled in nursing programs to produce the number of nursing personnel needed. Having considered the preceding factors, the next step is to study the available educational and clinical resources in the State not now fully utilized* Tifhen these potentials are revealed, a plan should be formulated by which they can be woven into integrated systems of education for nursing personnel* Once having determined the need for nursing personnel who can care for general and psychiatric patients and for patients in urban and rural hospitals, then facilities for this type of preparation should be included in the educational program. Once having determined that public health nursing on a staff level is to be expected of graduates of degree programs, then facilities for the required field experience must be sought* The conclusions of this study should recommend the number, capacity, and location of professional programs (basic and advanced) and non-professional programs idiich the State should operate to meet estimated needs for nursing personnel and to prepare these professional nurses and non- professional nursing personnel to function effectively in the light of emerging standards. The following chart is a condensation of the discussion in SECTION III relative to questions, probable sources for obtaining information, and references pertinent to an overall gross evaluation of the present system of nursing education in a State according to type of program* Chart 3« Questions, probable sources for obtaining information, and references pertinent to an overall gross evaluation of the present system of nursing education in a State according to type of program* Type of Program Questions relevant to an overall gross evaluation of the programs Probable sources for obtaining information References Basic Professional 1* Are there sufficient oppor- State Board of Brown, Esther L® tunities for able potential Nurse Examiners Nursing For The (Diploma and/or students from all groups to Future, Hassell T enroll in schools of nursing? National League Sage Foundation, degree programs of Nursing New York, 1948® 2® What percent of the schools are Education for undergraduate accredited by: The Commission on Hospital student nurses) a* State Board of Nurse Publications Care: Hospital Examiners? Care in the American Nurses1 United States® b® National Nursing Association: Commonwealth Accrediting Service? Facts About Fund, New York Nursing. 1947 3- How many of the schools have 1790 Broadway, been accredited as graduating New York 19, Federal Security nurses eligible for staff New York® Agency, Public positions in Public Health Health Service, nursing agencies? National League Division of of Nursing Educa- Hospital Facil— 4* How many of the Collegiate tion. Department itiess Plans schools providing degree of Studies: State of General programs for undergraduate Accredited Schools Hospitals For nurses are recognized by the of Nursing. The Coordinated Association of Collegiate National League Hospital System® Schools of Nursing as being: of Nursing Educar- Reprinted from tion. New York, Architectural a* Active members? 1946. Record, January 1948. - b® Associate members? Vreeland, Ellwynne M.: Some Quail- Vreeland, 5* What percent of the hospitals tative and Quan- Ellwynne M.t associated with schools of titative Factors Some Qualitative nursing are approved by: in Nurse Educar- and Quantitative tion® Public Factors in Nurse a. Council on Medical Health Reports, Education® Education and Hospitals Vol. 63, No. 52 Public Health for: U. S. Government Reports, Vol® 6; internships? Printing Office No® 52. U. S. residences? Washington, D#c., Government both internships and 1948® Printing Office, residences? Washington, D®C®i b® American College of 1948. Surgeons® 6. 7. How many of the schools are controlled by: What proportion of the total student enrollment is in: a* Colleges or universities? b• Hospitals with a daily average patient census of 150 or more? c. Hospitals with a daily average patient census of less than,1507 What percent of the students have planned experience in: a* Nursery school? b« Psychiatry? c. Tuberculosis? d. Other communicable disease? e• Out-patient department? f. Community health? Arestad, F. H., £everoos, E. H., Albus, W# r#> and Corbett, W. W.: Hospital Service in the United States. Council on Medical Education and Hospi- tals of the American Medical Association, Chicago, Illinois. National League of Nursing Education, Committee on Revision of the Faculty Pamphlets Faculty Positions in Schools of Nursing and How to Prepare For Them. National League of Nursing Education, 1790 Broadway, N. T., 19, New York, 1946. Indiana Univer- sity School of Education, Divi- sion of Nursing Education: Survey Methods Applied to School of Nursing and Hospital Nursing Services. Indiana Univer- sity Bookstore, Bloomington, Indiana, 1948. 8. How many students have experience in a: a. large medical center? b. small rural hospital? 9. How many schools are operated by the following types of specialized hospitals: a* Mental? b. Tuberculosis? Cm Childrens? 10, What percent of the schools have a total enrollment of less than 100 students? 11. Miat is the average ratio of nurse administrators and in- structors to students? 12. Are there centralized teaching plans? 13. Do central schools of nursing 63d st? 14. Are the teaching resources of junior colleges utilized? 15. What percent of the adminis- trative and instructional nursing personnel have one or more academic degrees? 16. What correlations are revealed -when State Board examination results over a period of time are analyzed in relation to such factors as: 3ize of the hospital in udiich students receive their major clinical experiences? b. Size of student enroll- ment? c. Number of clinical services provided each student? d. Qualifications of adminis- trative and instructional nursing personnel? 17. What is the ratio of diploma to degree students? Degree oroerams for undergraduate nurses: 18. What percent of the schools con- trolled by colleges or universi- ties are: a. independent administrative units? b. separate departments or schools? 19# Do specific written contracts exist between the college or university and the hospitals and agencies providing student experience? 20* Are qualified members of the administrative and instructional nursing personnel given academic status? 21* What is the basis for the selection of students? 22* Are degrees in nursing granted on the same basis as other degrees? 23* Do the curricula meet the require-* oft a* college or university? b* professional practice and State registration? 24» Does the college or university give recognition to the curriculum of the school of nursing on the same basis as other departments or divisions? Note: If visits to the individual schools are possible and a detailed study of each program can be made, the following references will suggest pertinent trends of inquiry: a« American Nurses1 Association: A Guide For Supervision of State Approved Schools of Nursing, New York, 194B* b. Indiana University School of Education, revision of Nursing education: Survey Methods Applied to -Schools of Nursing and Hospital Nursing Services* Indiana University Bookstore, Bloomington, Indiana, 1948# Advanced 1. How many colleges or universities School catalogues Department of Professional offer advanced professional and unpublished Studies, National League (programs for programs? factual material graduate nurses from the colleges of Nursing leading to a 2. How many programs of each type or universities Education* degree) are available? offering advanced professional Graduate Nurses Enrolled in 3* What is the number of full-time and part-time students enrolled programs Colleges and Universities. according to: Association of Collegiate Schools American Journal of Nursing Vol.hS a. academic level? b. type of program? c. scholarship status? 4* What percent of the enrolled students are residents of other States? of Nursing Page 181 (March 1949) Brown, Esther L», Nursing For The Future, Russell Sage Foundation, New York, 1948* Note: If visits to the individual schools are possible and a detailed study of each program can be made, the following references will suggest trends of inquiry: a. National League of of Nursing Education: A Guide For the Organization of Collegiate Schools of Nursing. National League of Nursing Education, New York, 1946. • b. National League of Nursing Education: Courses In Clinical Nursing For Graduate Nurses. National League of Nursing Education, New York, 1945* Approved 1. How many of the programs are States with laws training conducted by: for uractic&l programs for non-profes^- a. boards of management nurse licensure * sional nursing or social agencies? State Board of Joint Con** personnel Education, and ndttee on b. hospitals 7 State Board of Nurse Examiners, Auxiliary Nursing c» public vocational or other legally Servi ce * Prac t icy schools? authorized accre- diting agency Nurses and Auxiliary 2. Row many of the programs are: which approves schools of Workers for the Care of a. less than 12 months? professional * nursing the Sick. American b. 12 mohths or more? in the State Nurses1 Association, New York, 1947 3. What percent of the programs States without laws Brown, Esther L.s include elementary nursing care for practical nurse Nursing For The for the following types of patientss a. medical? licensure Committee on Administration of the Accredi- Future. Russell Sage Foundation, New York, 19148. Federal Security b. surgical? ting Program of the National Agency, Office of Educations c. pediatric? d. obstetrical or League of Nursing Education Practical Nuraing- An Analysis of the Practical urological? National Association For Practical Nurse Nurse Occupation with Suggestions U- How many of the programs pro- vide instruction and super- vised practice in: a. home nursing? b. care of chronic and convalescent patients? Education for the Organiza- tion of Training Programs. U. S. Government Printing Office, Washington, D.C., 19U7. Curriculum and 5>. What educational qualifications are required for trainees? Accrediting Committees, National Associa- 6. What are the general educational qualifications of the adminis- trative and instructional personnel? tion For Practical Nurse Educations Practical Nurse Education. National Associa- 7. Is there an active interest in practical nursing? tion For Practi- cal Nurse Education, New York, 19147* Hotel If visits to the individual schools are possible and a detailed study of each program can be made, the following references will suggest pertinent trends of inquiryi a. Federal Security Agency, Office of Educationi Practical Nursing - An Analysis of the Practical Nurse Occupation with Suggestions for the Organization of Training Programs* U, S* Government Printing Office, Washington, D.C*, 19U7* b* Forthcoming publication of the Committee appointed by the Office of Education to develop a practical nursing curriculum*