R E I-1 0 R T to ASSOCIATE CO IIITTEE ON ARM MEDICAL RESEARCH National Research Council of Canada THE EFFECT OF QiJLPii/UJlAZIEE PROPHYLAXIS w RIFPIRiTORY LPH.Tj'OH _OF SERVING SOLDIERS Col. ?*?. Lloyd O.B.E., V,D.S R,C,A.ii!,0„ I. Field trials concerning the effect of Sulphadiazine, given prophylactically, on the incidence of Respiratory infection among serving soldiers were commenced in Gamp Borden Command on the 24th Oct. 1944- and terminated on the 15th A nr* 1945, (Auth, H.Q, 5 27-7-340-1 dated 21 Sep. 44). II. OBJECT The object of these trials was to determine the problems and difficulties of such e. measure, using the minimum dose of .Sulphadiamine which under service conditions would re .vice the incidence cf Respiratory Infection to a significant degree, and to determine the results that could reasonably be expected there from* The test was not to bo of the 1 hothouse1 variety but practical and workable under all conditions Ill* HAN 1, Seven units v/ere selected representing a cross section of the fury* To each of these was attached a trained HOC called the ‘Host RC, who reported to the Senior Test NGO (\7*0,II) in the office of the Senior Medical Officer* These NCOs \;ere all experienced in the Qurrtermaster•? Dept, and had considerable experience in the Medical Inspection Rooms of Units, They worked under the supervision of the Unit ideciical Officers and the Senior Hygiene Officer 1espeotimely, the latter advising the Director of the test and giving constant supervision as he visited the units on his routine inspections, 2, From the seven units were selected 5*000 healthy soldiers who were divided into equal groups in their respective unite end the huts in which they slept identified by the letter rA?3 for the first group an. I the letter nBn for the second group as the case may be. Under a carefully prepared plan of control in each unit ell the men who slept in CA:: huts were ids sued with one “A1* tablet each morning at roll call immedh tely a fir aunkering.. Similarly, every man who slept in a hut marked UE* was issued v:1th a tt3K tablet each morning. Accurate daily records were kept 0f every mn inder test who reported sick from any A man was considered clok if he was absent from duty or treining for one day or more because of illness and he was only counted as one case no matter how many days ho was a brent from duty. In this way at the commencement of the test there were 2«500 men who received an t!A” tablet each, morning and. 2,500 men living under exactly the same conditions who received a SSB-* tablet each morning> It v&f not known by those taking part in the test what those tablets contained, In each hut “A11 and “B11 groups v/ere selected so that soldiers doing similar duties or training v/ere divided equally between the groupsc PROCIDURI: IN HUT AND COMPANY OR S QUA FRO IT OH.b.CF 3, At reveille as each name was called the NGO in charge or hut handed that man one tablet which he was asked to swallow, ff he vbicoted no compulsion vras used. If he persisted the Coy, (Squad, etc) Ccnru for was asked to move him to a non-test hut. This was not always dene* t’'on a man reported sick his name was taken by the Coy. (Squad, etc) Orderly Sgt, v/ho entered the number of his hut end whether it was in an ty.1' or “BH hut on a s^eorally marked HFM 292* Since the test hut - in any Coy, were well known, the Orderly Sergeant knew at onoe the correctness of this record. U.PROCEDURE AT THE UNIT f-DICAL INSPECTION ROOM The special Test NCO issued to each Test Hut NCO i/c every throo days a bottle of tablets marked with a plain nAn (Red) or 55Bn (Black) sufficient for his particular hut, Tablets wore counted and signed for and a record kept. Each Hut NCO got only one kind of tablets. At the morning sick parade the Medical Officer examined each soldier, asked him what hut he slept in, whether he was taking tablets and if so what kind* He checked the man’s answers with the 292 when he entered his diagnosis on that form. If the man was suffering from a Respiratory Infection the Medical Officer put a plain cross before and after his diagnosis, thus (X Coryza X), 5. The Test NCO then reviewed all 292:s* If he found Respiratory Infection which had not been marked by the Medical Officer he immediately drew the fact to that Officer's attention and if a mistake had occurred it was corrected at once. Having assured himself on this point he then proceeded to the hut of every man who was in the test whom the M,0, had marked as having Respiratory Infection, and the hut orderly verified the correctness of the menrs statements. If possible he saw the man and asked him whether or not he had taken the tablets, and questioned the Hut NCO as to whether he had given the tablets. When every step had been double checked the Test NCO prepared a return known as MThe White Form1’ which consolidated the following information for the Unit: Name, Number* Hut Number, Provisional Diagnosis and Final Diagnosis of all those having a a Respiratory Infection, Those in ttAw Huts and who had taken *’A!1 tablets who had been either excused duty for one or more days or sent to hospital were entered on the upper half of the form; on the lower half of the form similarly a consolidation was made of all those who slept in nBn Huts and had taken "B” tablets. These White Forms were prepared serially through- out the experiment and sent daily to Camp HQs, Nil reports being required, the serial number of the form coincided with the day of the test; serial 99 gave the situation on the 99th day and so on0 6.HOSPITAL RETURNS The special Test NCO also examined all men in the unit who returned from hospital each day. If any man had been previously sent to hospital while under test the NCO prepared a ’’Blue Form'-’ also serially numbered in which was reported the man’s name* number, hut number and ’’A” or ,:B” with the hospital diagnosis and the number of days in hospital. The serial number of the white form on which he had originally been reported to HQs was carefully checked and entered. This Blue Form and the White Form for that day were securely stapled together and. sent to Camp Headquarters, 7.PROCEDURE AT COMMAND HEADQUARTERS A specially trained CQHS received the reports from all units daily. Under the direction of the Senior Hygiene Officer this NCO reviewed each return and compared the data thereon with the copies of the original 292!s made at the time the man reported sick. If all was correct he then compared the hospital diagnosis with the original diagnosis as made by the Unit Medical Officer, If the hospital diagnosis was not one of Respiratory Disease Infection the case was eliminated from the record. If the diagnosis was changed the fact was noted as the Final Diagnosis on the original White Form, In this manner it was possible to make certain that every case of Respiratory illness among soldiers under tost was correctly reported and correctly recorded B, All Medical Officers and M.I.R, NCOs were warned to watch for reactions, and to be especially vigilant with every case of illness no matter how slight and to see that it was investigated* with the exception of the Director of the test and the Senior Jfygiene Officer no one knew the composition of either the "A” tablets or the "S’1 tablets* 2. CONDITIONS IN UNITS In most units and in all training units there is a constant flow of men in and out. These conditions were accented because, though the segregation of men under test would have produced much more impressive results, it is also true that such results would hot have been reduplicated in a practical application of the method under service conditions. It is estimated that 1% of the men under test changed three times over or more during the five and one half months it continued. It follows that many of the men after having taken the tablets for a month or six weeks passed out of the tost to be replaced by 9 rev men* who had had no prophylaxis. The subsequent favourable record of the "lost” men was replaced by the higher rate of the •raw1 men for the 15 to 20 days necessary to immunize them. This higher rate is included in the record of the treated group, 10, With regard to the numbers of men involved, the intention was to have 5,000 at all times under test. It soon became impossible to obtain this number of men without interfering with training. As a result daily counts were made and an average of 3,994 was maintained for the five and a half months of the tost. Of these 2020 were ”A” Huts and 197A were in nD” Huts, This is compensated for by expressing the results in rates per thousand or rates per thousand per annum. 11. TIME OF TEST It was visualized when the test was authorized that there would be a relatively high incidence of Respiratory Infection because of the winter weather* Fortunately for the Army but unfortunately for our results the expected increase in R,I* did not occur. The increase of patients in hospital (CBMIi) during January, February and March 1945 was only 100 daily over the average summer count for the last throe ycars«an increase of only 25%, For this reason the results obtained must be viewed in an entirely different light to those obtained in the United States at the height of a pandemic of Respiratory Disease, In fact the significance of these results is enhanced by the lack of an epidemic * 12, ATTITUDE OF THE: MEN The Commending Officers having been interviewed by the Director of the Test and their cooperation assured, the Company Officers, under the CO's orders, explained to their own men the reasons for and plan of the test. At first a relatively high percentage of the men refused the tablets without explanation. It was then discovered that the word had got around, due possibly to the publicity given to V.D, Prevention, that the tablets contained saltpetre or some such substance to be given to soldiers surreptitiously to reduce V.D* To moot this it was found necessary to post a notice in each hut putting the case as fairly and forcibly as possible and to include a frank statement to the effect that these tablets had nothing whatever to do with V.D, Control, (Copy att*d Appendix ”B” ), This notice was signed by the Director as S.M.O, Such efforts had considerable effect and. the number of men who swallowed the tablets materially increased. IV, R:. .ULTS 1. General In spite of the faithful cooperation of all concerned there v:as still, as there always will be, a proportion of the men who did not actually take the tablets. Every effort was therefore made to arrive at a figure which would, enable a correction to bo made to allow for this important factor. However, it is felt that this correction should not bo applied to the results except for purposes of scientific analysis. It is altogether unlikely that an instrument of this kind would bo used except in the emergency of a threatened epidemic or a pandemic,. Since when this tost was made it was a healthy year with little increased incidence of Respir tory Infection present, the probable results in the face o" an epidemic might reasonably be doubled. In this case results obtained in Camp Borden under the conditions which have been noted almost exactly duplicated the results obtained in the United States during the epidemics of 194-3 and 1944* 2. EFFORTS BY UNITS The results are reported both as actual cases and as rates per thousand per annum. Since the latter alone gives the true comparative picture it will form the basis of discussion. Tables I for “A11 Huts and II for 11BM Huts give a breakdown by units of cases as they occurred, reported bi-monthly and divided into those excused duty (Fx) and admitted to hospital (Hp), Cases ’’A" Huts Fx 252 Hp 150 Total 402 Cased "B” Huts Fx 149 Hp 109 Total 2^8 A-B 102 144 3. DAILY r0UFTS AMD RATES A daily count of men under test arranged in bi-monthly groups with a consolidation of cases and rates per thousand per annum calculated therefrom is presented in Table III* The first period Nov 1-15 is discarded for the record duo to the difficulties in taking tablets referred to in Sec III, para 12 above. In Chert I these rates are graphically represented* These points should be noted, 1, The 11D11 Hut men start the test with double the illness rate of the nAns, 11, In two weeks of prophylaxis the positions are reversed, “A” has risen from 108 to 314 while "B” has fallen from 224 to 204, 111, Favourable progress continued till 31 Dec when nB,!s are 5 of "A". IV, The effect of a general laxity in taking tablets during Xnas and New Year wiped out the favourable results to Sfa by the 15 January, V, From that tine on favourable results increase until the warm weather of 15 Mar-15 Apr reduces the rate to MAM“224 and 11 Bw 154> still a significant difference* 4. MftM DAS SAVED A consideration of the tables shows that there wore 144 men saved from illness by the prophylaxis. This works out at thirty five percent of those who were ill or a reduction of Illness by 164- per thousand healthy men per annum. The average time lost while ill for each nA:t tablet man was 5.6 daysa The man days saved per year per thousand men is therefore 9J.84. man days. 5. BREAKDOWN by diseases Table IV shows the breakdown by the various types of Respiratory Disease. The only one not materially decreased by the prophylaxis was bronchitis. No explanation can be offered for this fact® 6. REACTIONS During the five and a half months that Sulphadiazine was administ- ered there were three cases of dermal reaction only of which one was doubtful. Though they were admitted to hospital none were actually ill* The first case B-A63006 Tpr Atkinson, W,H, developed an itchy rash of the ‘scarlet fever1 type on 11 Dec he is said to have been taking nB!1 tablets for throe weeks—but his urine was neg, for sulpha. He had also been taking service vitamin tablets (other cases have occurred with a similar rash definitely from these tablets). His rash cleared in 36 hours and he returned to duty. Doubtful case. The Second case on 15 Jon 45 - B~5239'7 Cpl< Morris* P, developed a generalised rash of the Erythema Multiforme type over the areas of the skin that are exposed to the sun when wearing summer clothing (shorts and shirts)* He had been taking !lBn tablets for six weeks and his urine was positive for sulpha. Rash lasted seven days with no subsequent ill effects. The third case on 19 Feb A5 - B-3.66285 Pte Truesdell, F,R, developed a rash of the Rubella type. His urine was positive and the rash latent 36 hours. Counting three cases gives a rate of 105 per thousand for 5s mens. 7. PERCENTAGE OF TEST, JEN ...TAKING.TABLETS Difficulty was experienced in getting men under test to actually take the tablets offeredc In spite of the measures adopted to persuade them a certain number did not always accept the tablets and others accepted them but did not swallow then, A careful check was made of this point in all units and from the counts made throughout it is estimated that 53% of the men actually took the tablets while did not actually swallow them* It might therefore be argued that if a reduction in Respiratory Disease amounting to 35% took place with only 53$ of the men under test actually swallowing the tablets, then if 100$ had swallowed them there would have been a reduction of 66$ in Respiratory Disease0 Calculated in rates per thousand per annum of healthy men this would moan a reduction in illness of 309 per V. SUIIXRY Purpose To obtain familiarity with the administrative problems arising out of a large scale prophylactic measure. To tost the possibility of rapidly putting such a measure into effect on the threat of an epidemic and to test its effectiveness under Canadian conditions. The test was to coincide with the 'epidemic period* of Respiratory Diseases. Conclusions 1. No epicemic of Respiratory Infection occurred during the period of the test (See Chart #3 for comparisons) therefore the results are the most conservative that can be expected* 2. Only 47$ of the men under test actually swallowed the tablets, no compulsion being used* This fact constitutes a problem in the event of the use of the measure to check an epidemic* 3. Reactions to the drug were mild and negligible in number, 1,5 per thousand over 5J- months, 4* The test showed a reduction in Respiratory Disease of 35$ (or I64. per M, per annum) due to the prophylaxis. This is likely to be doubled under epidemic conditions and moderate compulsion, 5, The measure can be carried out by the normal administrative organization of any unit (Regt, or Bn.) having a Medical Officer and staff attached. The medical supervision must be efficient and strict* 6, The plan can be put into effect in 24 hours provided the necessary tablets are available, 7* It may take 14 to 21 days before maximum effect is apparent if no epidemic exists, 8, A special directive is required to point out the salient features (attitude of men, necessity must be explained, reactions provided for ates,). Table I Units A- ■19 A-22 No, 1 TR • o TR No .3 TR TSR A- ■10 Total Total Dates Ex Hp Ex Hp Ex Hp Ex Hp Ex Hp Ex Hp Ex Hp Ex Hp ”'Both ilt Nov 1-15 1 - _ 2 2 2 1 1 6 3 9 o <1 16-30 1 1 2 3 2 4 — 3 1 3 8 2 19 11 30 Dec 1-15 1 _ 6 1 — 4 2 2 7 * 11 5 27 12 39 Dec 16-31 _ _ 7 _ 6 3 2 _ 13 — 1 5 3 34 6 40 Jan 1-15 2 — — 2 8 6 6 2 4 1 4 • 5 2 29 13 42 Jan 16-31 8 4 — 2 2 11 4 7 _ — — 8 5 40 11 51 Feb 1-15 1 1 3 2 6 6 7 6 1 X 1 9 10 28 25 53 Feb 16-28 1 — 1 1 8 10 — _ 5 7 1 7 5 23 23 46 Mar 1-15 2 _ 1 — 1 5 2 15 8 1 1 4 8 19 29 48 Mar 16-31 1 _ 3 7 14 5 3 _ _ 1 - 2 21 15 36 Apr 1-15 2 1 - - 7 2 3 2 - - - - - - 12 5 17 TOTAL 19 3 25 9 41 49 46 37 58 10 12 3 57 42 258 153 411 Record Total 252 150 402 %or purpose 53 of this record the count wi 11 beg in with Nov 16- -30, the period Nov 1- •15 being discarded. SULPHADIAZINE PROPHYLAXIS TEST Number of Cases Excused Duty and Admitted to Hospital "A" TABLETS (Placebo) Ex - Excused Duty Hp - Hospital Units A- 19 A-2 2 No.l TR No. 2 TR No .3 TR TSR A- 10 Total Total Dates Ex Hp Ex Hp Ex Hp Ex Hp Ex Hp Ex Hp Ex Hp Ex Hp Both o' < 1-15 « 1 1 1 1 — 1 1 1 4 1 5 2 12 7 19 Nov 16-30 _ 1 2 2. 4 1 1 — 2 2 1 2 1 13 6 19 Dec 1-15 1 1 3 8 _ 2 — 1 1 — 2 1 1 2 8 15 23 Dec 16-31 - - 2 1 2 1 1 1 — mam 1 2 5 1 11 6 17 Jan 1-15 4 _ _ 3 9 6 5 3 4 mm 1 1 4 1 27 14 41 Jan 16-31 5 _ 1 1 5 3 5 3 — 2 3 5 2 24 11 35 Feb 1-15 2 — 1 1 3 1 1 8 1 3 3 6 18 12 30 Feb 16-28 _ mm 1 1 2 2 5 1 6 2 3 4 17 10 27 Mar 1-15 1 mm 5 3 2 5 7 1 1 1 1 7 17 17 34 Mar 16-31 mm mm — 1 5 2 2 2 2 1 2 4 7 14 21 Apr 1-15 1 - - - 3 2 - 1 - - 3 - - 1 7 4 11 TOTAL 14 2 11 18 32 29 22 19 29 9 22 8 31 31 161 116 277 Record Total 149 109 258 /■ *For purposes of this record the count wi 11 begin with . Nov 16- -30, the period Nov 1- 15 being discarded. Table II SULPHADIAZINE PROPHYLAXIS TEST Number of Cases Excused Duty and Admitted to Hospital "B” TABLETS (.5 gms Sulphadiazine) Ex - Excused Duty Hp - Hospital Table III "A" Huts with "A” Tablets MB" Huts with "Bn Tablets Average Cases Rate 1 Average Cases Rate Period Daily Count Resp. 111. Per M. Daily Count Resp. 111. Per M. Hlo-v 1-15 2001 9 — 108 2037 i 19 224 Nov 16-30 2268 30 313 I 2231 19 204 Dec 1-15 2260 - - . . . - - . - - - - 39 - - 414 2118 23 261 Dec 16-31 2257 40 425 2069 17 197 Jan 1-15 1949 42 517 2104 41 468 Jan 16-31 2143 « 571 2075 35 405 i Feb 1-15 2131 53 597 I 1813 30 397 Feb 16-28 1876 46 1 588 1880 27 345 Mar 1-15 1776 48 649 1813 34 450 Mar 16-31 1735 36 498 1 1809 \ ... . .. 21 ! 279 Apr 1-15 1825 j.:l .. 224 1712 11 154 Total for Record 2020 402 473 i 1974 258 t 314 | for Record purposes SULPHADIAZIRE PROPHYLAXIS TEST Daily Average Count of Men in "A” and "B" Huts Gases of Respiratory Illness and Rates per Thousand per Annum. Table IV CASES OF RESPIRATORY ILLNESS MONO SOLDIERS TAKING "A" or "B" TABLETS ARRANGED BY DISEASES SHOWING DECREASE DUE TO PROPHYLAXIS DISEASE "A" .Tablets "B" Tablets Effect using as Standard Increased Decreased Cases % Cases % Measles 1 1 Chicken Pox 2 2 Mumps 32 23 9 22$ German Measles 2 2 mm Scarlet Fever 1 1 — Pneumonia 13 5 8 61$ Influenza U.R.I. 88 46 42 48$ Tonsilitis 24 26 2 CO — Pharyngitis 101 60 41 41$ Laryngitis 13 5 8 62$ Bronchitis 23 33 10 43$ Tracheitis 11 3 8 73$ Septic Sore Throat 17 8 9 53$ Otitis Media 5 3 2 Pleurisy 3 1 *, 2 — Coryza 64 42 22 34$ Sinusitis 3 6 3 - - - TOTAL 402 258 144 35.8$ Under test 5,000 Men Duration of Prophylaxis 5 Mos Duration of Record 4-ir Mos Remarks; Less than 10 cases not given in percent. PH< PFYLAaTIC STJLP A DIAZ IK E TEST, CAMP BORDEK— Races per E'POUSAND Men, M An Tabli t .on Placebo | : MB’’ en -QJ5.. j7 &r.) jSulf adiazjLne — i LEGEND Period of Xnas and "H&W- ~ r-G Br'I' /Leaver Diff. Rates per thousand or per thousand per annum* CHART 2 Resp5.ratory Infection in Test Bits,Cases, rdth Rates "B" "A" Diff. «B« Cases "A" Chart 3 Weekly admissions C.B.l.H. Respiratory Disease Appendix B THIS IS A 11B11 HUT It is most important for the health of the Army (Navy and Air Force also) for the Medical authorities to know exactly the best way of preventing disease, because prevention is always better than cure. Respiratory diseases such as sore throat, tonsillitis, bronchitis, pneumonia, etc, if unchecked often leads to such conditions as rheumatism, scarlet fever, heart trouble and kidney trouble etc. It has been found that if respiratory diseases can be prevented, a man is much more likely to remain healthy and free of such chronic conditions, 2, It is known that infected dust causes respiratory diseases. Valuable information was produced by a blanket test in Camp Borden in recent months. You are now being asked to help in making these tests more complete by taking a small tablet called a •,BM tablet each morning when you get up. The purpose of this tablet is to prevent germs that you may have breathed in either during the night or* from a theatre etc, developing in your system, causing respiratory disease. This tablet will not effect you in any other wav any more than an aspirin would, (This statement is made by the medical authorities to make it plain that this test has no connection with venereal disease prevention,) 3# Careful records will be kept by the Medical Officer of every case of illness and if you will cooperate by doing as you are requested, information of the utmost value for the prevention of diseases such as scarlet fever, rheumatism, arthritis, brain fever, kidney disease, etc. can be gained. The results for the future health of the people of Canada are so important that you are urged to do your part in making this test a complete success. Remember that YOU may be able to prevent some other person from becoming a cripple, 4. Every war has produced great advances in medicine because medical services have been able to produce new and better remedies. So true is this, that in the end, more lives may be saved by the improved treatments, than were lost during the war. Camp Borden has already done excellent work in this regard. You can be of further help in a most important way by taking part in this test. 18 Oct LA (F.P. Lloyd)■Col,, RCAMC, Senior Medical Officer, Camp Borden Command,