c c *■—s "^ * 5^- £U^< 1^ ^r>ss e C« tTc<^^ .Jg cCJ&Li •5 as?' '/>■•——~-jeroafyoz: oi-OLQu^es^-^^ Surgeon General's Office Jwli^JO, i&^ N ...J^Ml ••^ > ON THE HOMCEOPATHIC TREATMENT c: ABOETION, ITS CAUSES AND CONSEQUENCES; WITH SOME SUGGESTIONS, AND INDICATIONS FOR THE USE OF THE NEW REMEDIES. V BY EDWIN M. HALE,, M D., "" Associate Editor op the Noutii American Journal of Homceopathy, Etc, WITH A PREFATORY LETTER, V BY R. LUDLAM, \\. I)., Prof, of Physiolosy and Pathology, in the Hahnemann Med. College, Etc, (1 II T C A G O : HALSEY A KING, HOMCEOPATHIC PHARMACY, IfiS CLARK STREET 18G0. MO HI5fc \2(oO PREFACE The practicing physician of our School must have felt the need of a multiplication of monographs upon particular remedies, which shall afford in detail the especial indications for the employment of those remedies in particular diseases. This, we apprehend, is the great desideratum in the Homoeopathic medical literature of the present day ; and furthermore, it is certainly true that through this species of practical contributions mainly, may we hope to construct a permanent literature, which shall set forth the established principles, as well as the real resources of the Medical Art. The province of Therapeutics especially, would appear to have been left for us to cultivate. Physiology and Pathology, Chemistry and Toxi- cology, have each been laid under contribution, and developed in a great measure through such memoirs as have never been furnished, and could not be by any other School, for the illustration of the science of Thera- peutics. It is to this source, therefore, that the world appeals for informa- tion upon topics the most vitally important to the health and the welfare of the species. Every practical monograph which falls into the physician's hands, adds so many pages to a mutual experience, and furnishes a chapter for the great work which all of us are writing upon the Practice of Medicine, for the use of our Fellows and the future. And he, who in this manner unfolds the resources of a new and valuable remedy for the relief of human suffering, is doing a great and an incalculable service to Medicine and to mankind. As in other regards, so is it here. We have been in the habit of looking abroad for almost the entire list of our curative agents. In- digenous remedies, which have promised at the least an equal efficacy, if carefully investigated and proven, have been overlooked ; much as the low and richer prairies were passed over by the earlier pioneers of this Western world, for the higher but shallower soil beyond. The first rep- resentatives of Homoeopathy preferred a parallel course ; but as advancing civilization is settling up and making available the less desirable low-lands nearer home, so, with the specification and more intimate acquaintance with the properties and the limited value of the drugs we have long known, comes the absolute need that we familiarize us with those which have once been voted as quite beneath our notice. And happily for us, there are those in our profession, who for the mere lack of under-draining and a little tillage, will not be content with neglecting so fruitful a soil. Among the foremost in this laudable enterprise, is our friend Dr. E. M. Hai.e. Confident of the healing resources which are hidden away in what have been styled the " New Remedies," he is determined to develope them. Hence the origin of the following pages. Based upon ample ex- perience, running through years of trial and confirmation, our author's conclusions are neither hasty nor unreliable. Many of them have been verified in our own sphere of practice, and if, with others, we could have wished them a sounder and more enduring foundation in the pathogenesy 4 of particular remedies, we have not refused the former, while the latter was still wanting. To those who are disposed to style these Therapeutical deductions as " crude" and unsatisfactory, we recommend the propriety of addressing themselves to a more careful analysis of these "New Reme- dies" than is here given, in preference to a criticism of this praiseworthy attempt to map out the field for future and indefinite development. Per- fection in the matter of drug-proving, is not the work of a day, neither of a generation. As pointing to the relief of a prominent series of infirmities, we are emphatically of opinion that the accompanying memoir is destined to a useful mission among the medical brethren. Once they were obliged to combat these disorders with but a limited number of remedies in hand. Belladonna, Secale Cornutum, Sabina and Crocus, were almost the sole reliance. But here we have the practical indications which may demand a dozen other equally valuable remedies. Aletrin, Asclepin, Baptisin Caulophyllin, Gelseminum, Ilelonin, Ilydrastin, Macrotin, Podophyllin, Sanguinaria, Scnecin, Trillin and Yiburnin, are introduced to the notice of the profession in this new capacity, and as explicitly as possible, in order that their patients may reap a proportionate benefit from their prescription. In this manner, it is hoped that sufficient attention will be elicited to stimulate to the production of " provings " of each and all the foregoing remedies. By this means, if found worthy, we may soon be competent to prescribe them with that precision and efficacy with which we are accustomed to employ the more familiar polychrests of our School. Of the growing demand for professional interference in the removal of that great and crying evil, with its more serious sequelae, of which our author has treated, no one physician of our laid is supposed to be quite ignorant. Of the need of a multiplication of means for its more success- ful medical treatment, every practitioner of enlarged experience is abundantly satisfied. In so far as a knowledge of the virtues of the " New Remedies " may be drawn from clinical sources, it must be confessed that they promise to become of very essential service. For ourselves, we have no doubt but experience will ultimately determine them to be equally, if not indeed more efficacious, in the higher than in the lower potencies, and in smaller than in larger doses. In a private letter to the undersigned, Dr. Hale says: " Regarding the material doses I advise, I do not do so to bias the judg- ment of other physicians. I simply teach the results of my experience. I believe that if we had correct provings of the Macrotin, Gelseminum, and a few other of the remedies before-mentioned, we might with advan- tage use the medium, and perhaps the higher potencies. I have employed the Sanguinaria 30, and Gelseminum 6, with good effect." Once mark out the sphere and detail the proving of a remedy, how- ever, and the remainder is self-regulating. However desirable a patho- genetic chart of a remedy, we must be content with the first introduction of a majority of our curative agents into notice through their well known clinical virtues. Henceforth, this little brochure will throw a grateful side-light upon resources which are adapted to the relief of at the least one train of morbid phenomena; and we cannot but hope that it may prove initiative to kindred developments with regard to the Therapeutics of yet other and very differ- ent diseases, R. L. INTRODUCTION. Before entering upon the special consideration of the subject of Abortion, I wish to state the reasons which have impelled me to write the following monograph : 1st. Our Homceop>athic literature is exceedingly meagre of anything like a complete treatise on the subject. We find the treatment of Abortion mentioned in "Hull's Laurie's Practice;" "Jahr on Diseases of Females;" Leadam, and Peters ; which authorities, while they may be good so far as they go, do not satisfy the needs of the physician, nor fill the hiatus caused by the absence of a practical monograph. 2nd. Tyler Smith, in his "Lectures on Obstetrics" says: This (Abortion) is one of the subjects open to the greatest improvement in obstetric practice." In this emphatic remark I fully concur, for not only is there a wide field open to investigations into its nature and treatment, but never perhaps in the history of the world has Abortion been so common and so frequent as in this century. The statistics which I shall give in the following pages, as taken from " Whitehead on Abortion," will prove this assertion correct. While in most countries and in all times previous to this century, it has been deemed honorable to bear many children, the contrary seems now to obtain. Mothers once prided themselves upon their numerous and healthy offspring ; now they deem themselves lucky if they bear children few and far between. Every physician of experience will bear me out in the above assertion. From my own experience, and the observations of others with whom I have conversed, I am satisfied that it can be safely asserted that there is not one married femede in ten, who lias not had an abortion, or at least attempted one! For not only have the generally enumerated causes become more prevalent, but the intentional production of abortion is especially noticeable. Now-a-days, if a married woman happens to go a few days beyond the menstrual period, she either swallows some domestic emmenagogue at that time, or with the recurrence of the next menstrual period, procures some one of the many nostrums so shamelessly advertised as " warranted to regulate the menses," with the especial caution that it " must not be taken during the first three months of pregnancy, as it will invariably produce miscarriage." Or what is worse still, resort is had to the use of some one of the many instruments which are sold for the pur- pose of mechanically inducing abortion. Such instruments I regret to say are found in families of high standing in the community. They are all fashioned upon the principle of the bougie, and are cither sold by rascals in great cities, who advertise them through all our newspapers, or peddled about the country by creatures in the shape of women, who travel under the guise of " female doctors," lecturers on physiology, " women's rights," etc. This depraved and abominable habit is not confined to the cities and larger towns, but the extremest recesses of the quiet country are contaminated with it. Much of this is owing to the thousands of quasi physiological works, generally vulgar and obscene, which flood every State in our Union. They are advertised in all the popular and local news- papers, and are thus paraded before the curious eyes of youth, and made 6 to attract the attention of men and women of mature age. I will venture to assert that ninety per cent, of the youth of both sexes, who can read, have perused one of these " physiological" books. If a complete and healthy course of physiological study was introduced into our schools, it would do much towards destroying the prurient curiosity which leads to so many grave moral and physiological evils. Nearly every physician of any practice will testify that there is not a week during which he is not solicited by one or more persons, from all grades of society, to produce abortion, either upon themselves, or upon some person in whom they are particularly interested. Not, perhaps, openly, for at first many of them declare, " it is only a suppression, but it must be brought on at all hazards." In fact, abortion, both from unavoidable and intentional causes, is becoming so alarmingly prevalent, that it must soon attract the open attention of all philantropists and law-makers. Some great physical and moral im- provement must be opposed to the onward progress of this evil, or it will undermine the very foundations of all domestic morals, and reduce mar- riage to a false and degraded position. 3rd. The major part of the allopathic treatment of abortion, is ex- tremely unscientific and unreliable. With very little if any belief in the specific action of drugs, they grope in the misty mazes of " general indi- cations." True, there are occasional cases where some local lesion has been discovered, and the physician has acumen enough to use specific means with excellent effect. But when there is functional disorder, this routine treatment avails but little. I would not be so bigoted as to detract from the excellent labors of Smith, Whitehead, Tilt, Meigs or Gardner. Their works are invaluable to us, as results of patient and learned investi- gation, and many of their suggestions are worthy of all praise ; but I allude to the allopathic masses, than whom a more blundering class of practitioners never existed. Nor is the homoeopathic treatment, as laid down in our text books, and adopted by many of our brethren, by any means perfect. But few of the remedies enumerated have any specific value, either in preventing or treating abortion, while the total disuse of all local applications, is to be regarded as a great error. The treatment of the so-called Eclectic school is greatly superior to the Allopathic, and often equal to our own, from the fact that they use certain remedial agents, selected from our indigenous plants, which exercise a profound and specifically homoeopathic relation to the female generative organs, and consequently on the malady in question. It is the object of this paper to call the attention of my Homoeopathic brethren to these valuable and but little known remedies. If the doctrine taught by Teste is a true one—that the plants indigenous to a country arc best suited to treat the diseases of that country—then we should feel bound to test them in the crucible of experience, and see if the Pulsatilla which so often disappoints us, cannot be replaced by Senecin or some other remedy. Although I cannot present the profession with provings ©f these remedies, I feel justified in taking a course sanctioned and adopted by Hahnemann, who used and advised many unproven drugs, because he thought he could mark out their characteristic peculiarities, and under- stand their general sphere of action. At the close of this paper I shall give such pathogenetic and curative symptoms belonging to each most important drug, and delineate the pathological states to which they cor- respond. For these data I shall draw upon the experience of myself and a few colleagues, and also the writings of King, Jones and Coe, (Eclectics.) ABORTION. Statistics of Abortion.—" Two thousand married women in a state of pregnancy, admitted for treatment at the Manchester Lying-in Hospital, during parts of the years 1845-6, were interrogated in rotation respecting their existing condition and previous history. The sum of their pregnancies was 8,681; of which, rather less than one in seven had terminated abor- tively." ( Whitehead.) These women were all under thirty years of age, and as abortion occurs more frequently after that age, the real average will be much more—say one in five. Whitehead states that " more than thirty- seven out of every hundred mothers experience abortion before they attain the age of thirty years." This is probably much under the real average, for reasons above stated. In my own investigations I have met with women who have had respectively, eight, ten and thirteen children, and as many abortions ! Period op Abortion.—In my experience, the last week of the third month is the most usual period of abortion. Out of 602 cases given by Whitehead, there were 35 at two months ; 275 at three months ; 147 at four months; 30 at five months ; 32 at six months ; 55 at seven months; 28 at eight months. Fatality of Abortion, to the mother, does not seem to be very great. Out of the above cases, only three proved fatal to the mother, and those were at the seventh month. I have attended over 300 cases of abortion ; 278 were at the third month, the rest at the second and fifth. Out of these not one proved fatal to the mother. Under judicious treatment, I consider abortion to be attended with but little danger. Causes of Abortion.—These may be divided best into predisposing and exciting. " By predisposing causes are meant certain morbid condi- tions, local or constitutional, already in the system ; or a particular sus- ceptibility to morbid action during pregnancy, by the operation of which the process is liable to be prematurely arrested. They have been sub- divided into two orders; those which originate entirely in the maternal system, and those which appear to depend upon some defect in the pro- duct of gestation." ( Whitehead.) I propose to take up the causes, as enumerated by Whitehead, Tyler, Smith and others, and append to each such treatment as experience has shown to be most efficient, always adhering to the law of similia viewed rationally. treatment of predisposing causes. Debility and Exhaustion.—If from loss of blood or excessive dis- charges—China, Hydrastin, Phos. ac, Manganese, Ferrum andHelonin. Debility from Exhausting Disease,—with deficiency of muscular and nervous tone. Nux v., Ign., Syrup of Phosphates, Macrotin and Hydrastin. Genered plethora and obesity.—This has been known to produce abor- tion, and many women grow very plethoric during pregnancy. Aconite, Verat. v. and Bell, should be used palliatively; and abstinence from oily s food, with vegetable diet and copious acid drinks, aided by Kali. carb. or Kali, hyd., in appreciable doses, should be advised to lower the accumu- lation of adipose matter. General IVervous Irritation.—In extremely sensitive women, the nervous system becomes so irritable as to be acted on by the most trivial causes. This extreme irritability is often an indirect cause of abortion. The remedies best calculated to soothe and strengthen the nerves, are Macrotin Scutellaria, Ignatia, Nux v., Cypripedium, Coffea and Cham. Scrofula is considered a prominent cause. Besides our anti-psorics, I use Stillingia, Kali, hyd., Kali. brom. and Podoph. Reflex Nervous Irritation.—Tyler Smith is the especial champion of this theory, and although he may be too sanguine, there is undoubtedly much important truth in his teachings. He arranges the reflex nervous actions as follows: {a.) Trifacial.—Irritation of these nerves should be treated with Aeon. Bell., Val. of Zinc, Coccionella, Mc-c, and even extraction of a decayed tooth,—which operation is not so much to be feared as the intense irrita- tion of the pain—or plugging the tooth with a compound of Aconite tine. Chloroform and Gum Copal. (b.) Mammary.—Lactation should not be continued after conception. But if abortion threatens from mammary irritation, use Aletris, Sabina, Bell, and Morphine with local anodyne applications to the breasts. (c.) Gastric.—Several cases have come under my owTn observation, where excessive gastric irritation has caused abortion. Generally the stomach can be quieted by Macrotin, Nux v., Ipecac or Kreosote. (d.) Rectal.—Dysentery, hemorrhoids, and the use of certain purgative medicines which irritate the rectum. Aloes, Podoph., Ars., Merc, and Nux., aided by opiate injections in severe cases, also the Hammamelis, will be found most useful. (e.) Vesical or Renal.—Stone in the bladder, albuminaria, and in- flammation of the urinary organs, are best treated with Canth., Tereb., Apis., Apoc. and Eryngia aquat. (/.) Ovarian.—Irritation of ovaries, swelling, neuralgia, etc., require Zincum. val., Apis., Cauloph., Sabina and Helonin. A tendency to abort at catamenial dates is generally due to such irritation ; but if no local irri- tation or tenderness of ovaries, or other perceptible cause for the accident be apparent, and the abortion seems the result of habit, as some claim, the steady use of Cauloph. and Helonin, for weeks and even months, is the best preventive treatment that can be adopted. Six cases of " habitual abortion" which I have treated with the above two remedies, terminated in healthy pregnancies and a safe delivery at full term. Case.—Dr. Bigelow of Toledo, 0., reports the following case to me : " A delicate lady who had had several abortions at about the third month, had been sujected to the best Allopathic and Homoeopathic treatment, and had nearly despaired of ever going her full time. The usual remedies having failed, I procured some Caulophyllin of Dr. Hale, and gave the patient one grain of the 1st dec. trit., three times a day during the third and fourth month of pregnancy, with the happiest effect. She was safely confined with a healthy child at full term." I might record many similar cases. If the peculiar sphere of the two remedies were to be marked out, I should decide Cauloph. to be most appropriate when the abortion is caused by an excess of irritation of the uterus, with general nervous irritability, while Helonin would be most appropriate in those cases of real atony of the uterus, with general debility. 9 . ($> ?» > > > ^ i v > i > > j z J>>^ .s» _» » » ■ j > *>Z»^> "> > » t> i • >^> >> ?'3 ' )7»> ) >^ ^> )3 joj R- '-■■> V • ) ►,?-> >» V>^> »>"2> > >>» " ^ i36^ --*^j" !> >J >5 >•' > ~> 9 £> ~> ^S^ -^ £' ~> » 5") •>:■ ) £■>-' (» >> > »9-> -V *J SJL" »> > 0 » >• > » » » ~> )> x> % ) ^ V* ) ):> -y # > B»j- ">> "> ->■">> >.> > 2 ■» > ) \t> > ) j i. y V ')> > >» » J» *» > >> ■>■» • p »i> y > > > > • > ' » /^J> >. > ,"'"> ' i ■ ■■> )>!>!> > . v> ^> TV. T» 'V > ■> , > J > " V ?.', >"*» J -» »• • •>.> »» > J» * i '■>.» ' >-> V ""» 'i C?* * . >?D:T> J> * :«?$*J ' j ,. v > : > ..-■}*'o- "JO > >»x5> •» v^>;> > > » ■* •> - > > «»7 : . ■» ;^?^^i- K* -e,,..^^ >> > ) "> >"» ^> ' ,, > ■) - * ~> >> » > >• » ^ o > > ^> ) » 1>> > i> ^ ") > > > »> j> 3»- jem» NLM011822203