Nine Months' Work IN ABDOMINALSURGERY BY CLINTON CUSHING.. M. D. PROFESSOR OF GYNECOLOGY, COOPER ME3ICAL COLLEGE, San Francisco, Cal. REPRINT FROM Pacific Medical Journal JULY, 1890. i.No 1 Name of Medical Attendant. Date of Operation. Married or Single Number of Children Size and Nature of Tumor. One or both Ovaries Adhesions Treat- ment of Pedicle. |Drainage Complica- tions. Hospital or Private. Result. Remarks. 1 Dr. Crabbe, July 28, '89 33 M. None Intra -ligamen- One Universal Tied and Yes. Pyelitis and Private. Recovery Operation attended Millville tous papilloma- dropped cystitis, three with great diffleul- tous cyst, size of a b d o m i n al ty, ou account of adult head. hernias, and extent and number Dr. C. Cushing. San Francisco ascites. of adhesions. 2 Nov 16, '89 52 M. None Cyst of both ova- Both Right one ll Yes. Rupture of Private Death. Died on 19th day ries, size two- adherent right cyst be- Hospital from purulent peri- thirds that of to vermi- fore operation tonitis. adult head. form ap- and develop- p e n d 1 x ment of acute 3 Dr. Wm. Jones, San Francisco Dec. 9, '89 14 M. Eight Simple ovarian cyst, size of a One and bowel Slight. No. peritonitis. None. Private. Recovery water-bucket. ABDOMINAL SECTIONS FOR THE REMOVAL OF OVARIAN TUMORS. ABDOMINAL SECTIONS FOR REMOVAL OF UTERINE APPENDAGES NOT THE SEAT OF TUMOR. 3 o Name of Medical Attendant. Date of Operation. 9®V Married or | Single Number of Children Pathological Condition or Symptoms necessitating Operation. | Duration of (Disease What Removed Adhesions... Treatment of Pedicle.... Drainage Hospital or Private. Recovery or Death Complica- tions before or after Operation. Remarks. Effect of Operation upon condition requiring it. 1 Dr.R.C. Meyers, June 20, '89 32 M. None Pyo-salpynx and 5 yrs. Both Many. Tied Yes. Hospital Recov- Severe previ- Great emaciation San Francisco intra peritoneal tubes and ery. ous attacks from exhausting abscess in Doug- and drop'd. of pelvic in- discharge from pel- lass pouch. ovaries. flammation. vic abscess. Re- 2 Dr. Gross, Aug. 6, '89 33 M. None Enormous pyo- 5 mos. Lft tube Many. 44 Yes. • „ 44 None. covery perfect. Recovery perfect. San Francisco salpynx, opening & cystic Dr. J. D. Whit- into rectum. ovary. 3 Aug. 6, '89 41 M. Three Double pyo-sal- 6 mos. B >th Many. 44 Yes. 44 44 Persistent Recovery perfect. ney, pynx, discharg- ing by rectum. tubes d i a r r h ce a San Francisco and and indiges- Dr.Louis Bazet, San Francisco ovaries. tion. 4 Aug. 21, '89 38 M. None Pyo-salpynx of right Fallopian 9 yrs. Right tube Many. 44 Yes. 44 None. Symptoms much alleviated and tube. Great pain and incapacitat'd and ovary. health restored. from exercise. 5 Dr. L. C. Lane, San Francisco Aug. 22, '89 24 M. None Pyo-saipynx and 3 yrs. Lft tube Yes. 44 Yes. Private. 44 None. Gonococci found in acute peritonitis. and d i s c h a r ges from Dr. B. F.Clarke, ovary. cervical canal. 6 Aug. 26, '89 32 M. Two Retroversion and 10 yrs. Left Many. 44 No. 44 *4 Cystitis. Condition very Chico- fixation of uterus, enlargement and tube much improved. and fixation of left tube and ovary, ovary. with much pain, and chronic cys- Dr. Artiguez, titis. 7 Sept. 19, '89 29 M. One. Prolapse,enlarge- 12 yrs. Both Uni- 44 No. Hospital 44 N e p h r i t is, Health restored. San Francisco ment and fixa- tubes versal. right kidney. tion of both ova- and Dr. Hund, ries. ovaries. 8 Sept. 24,'89 34 M. Two Prolapse,enlarge- 1 yr. Left Many Ct Yes. Private 44 Pelvic a b- Uterus stitched to San Francisco ment and fixa- tube and Hospital scess 10 days anterior abdominal tion of left ovary. and firm. after opera- wall. Health ex- Dr. W. S. Taylor ovary. tion. cellent. 9 Aug. 7, '89 u M. One. Uterus retrovert- Sever'l Both Many. 44 No. 4C 44 None. Excellent recovery Livermore ed and fixed; ova- ries prolapsed, years tubes and ovaries. enlarged and fixed, with great pain. Extensive cystic 10 Dr. Henry Gib- Oct. 19, '89 34 M. Two 12 yrs. Both Yes. 44 No. 44 44 None. Excellent recovery bons, Jr. disease of ovaries tubes San Francisco some of cysts the and Dr. Hertzstein, size of hen's eggs. ovaries. 11 Nov. 18, '89 38 M. Four Prolapse,enlarge- 3 yrs. Both Slight. ft No. 44 <4 None. Local symptoms San Francisco ment and great ovaries relieved and health tenderness of and much improved. both ovaries ; re- r. reversion of uterus. tubes. 12 Dr. Perrone, San Francisco Dec. 16, '89 23 S. None Pyo-salpynx. 1 yr. Both Many. 44 Yes. 44 44 Repeated at- tubes tacks of pel- and vic peritoni- Dr. McNutt, ovaries. tis. 13 Dec. 16, '89 28 M. Two Prolapsed, en- 4 vrs. Both Many. *» No. 44 44 None. Performed Tait's San Francisco larged and adhe- tubes operation on peri- Dr. Martin, rent ovaries. and ovaries. n aeum at same time. 14 Jan. 28, '90 31 M. None Pyo-salpynx, 10 yrs. Both Uni- 44 Yes. Hospital Death. Many at- San Francisco opening into rec- tubes versal. tacks of pel- turn for eight and vic i n fl a m- years. ovaries. mation. ABDOMINAL HYSTERECTOMY. 3 p • Name of Medical Attendant. Date of Operation. Married or Single Number of Children Pathological Condition or Symptoms necessitating Operation. Duration of Disease Nature of Operation. Adhesions... Drainage Hospital or Private. Recovery or Death Complica- tions before and after. Remarks and Subsequent History. 1 Dr. Jas. Keeney San Francisco Aug. 6, '89 40 M. None Sub-mucous fi- broid, size of co- coanut ; uterine hemorrhage for thirteen years. 13 yrs. Tumor and uterus removed through a b- dominal incis- ion, bleeding vessels ligated, excavation of stump of cervix and approxi- mation with catgut sutures. No. No. Private. Recov- ery. Hysteria. Excellent recovery 2 Dr. C. N. Ellin- wood, San Francisco Nov. 15, '89 39 M. Three Sub-mucous fi- broid, size of co- co a n ut, profuse uterine h e m o r- rhages. Fibro-cystic tu- rn o r o f uterus, rapid growth. 4 yrs. Same as above case. No. Yes. Private Hospital Death. Faecal fistula on 9th day, and pelvic ab- scess. Death on 13th day from p e ri to nitis and exhaustion. 3 Dr. Pawlicki, San Francisco Jan. 21, '90 42 -J. Two 3 yrs. Removal of uterus at inter- n a 1 os, with tubes and ova- ries. Intra-ab- dominal treat- mentof pedicle. No. No. Private. Recov- ery. Before opera- tion, great ir- ritab ility of stomach. 1 Dr. C. Cushing, San Francisco Oct. 24, '89 19 M. Two. Epithelioma of cervix and round cell sarcoma of body of uterus. 1 yr. Removal of en- tire uterus per vaginam. None No. Private Hospital Recov- ery. Urine escaped from right ureter per va- ginam, on 9th day- contin- ued nve days. Excellent recovery VAGINAL HYSTERECTOMY. LAPAROTOMIES FOR OTHER DISEASES OF ABDOMINAL ORGANS. !!No Name of Medical Attendant. Date of Operation. > crc CD Married or i Single Number of Children Pathological Condition or Symptoms necessitating Operation. Duration of Disease Nature of Operation. Drainage Hospital or Private. Recovery or Death Complica- tions before or after. Remarks and Subsequent History. 1 Dr. Thos. Boy- son, San Francisco May 21, '89 28 S. None Large encysted pelvic haemato- cele, with much pain. 1 yr. Exploratory i n c i sion and subsequent punc ture of h asm at oc e le from vagina; s e 1 f- r e - taining drainage tube. Yes. Hospital Recov- ery. None. • Well marked uterus bi-cornus. S 1 ight discharge from cavity of heematocele at end of 3 mos. Health 2 Dr. J. O.Hirsch- July 16, '89 40 M. None Ventral hernia. 6 mos. Abdominal section, ex- No. Private. Recov- None. good. Cure. felder, San Francisco tirpation of loose tissue, and careful adjustment ery. 3 Dr. Trask, Aug. 12, '89 28 M. Two Fistula at lower 6 mos. of opposing surfaces with silk-worm gut. Dilatation of biliary No. Private. Recov- None. Recovery excel- Austin, Nev. angle of former abdominal incis- ion, caused by silk suture; dis- fistula and removal of gall stone from gall bladder. Abdominal section and removal of ery. lent. 4 Dr. M.A.Cachot San Francisco Aug. 28, '89 30 M. charge from bil- iary fistula Suppurating pel- vic haematocele. 6 mos. cause of fistula. Abdominal section, separation of adhe- sions, removal of clots, Yes. Hospital Death. Adhesions universal and very firm. In- Case des perate; great exhaustion and emaciation. free irrigation. jury to rec- tum in sepa- rating ad he- sions. 5 Dr. O. Perrone, San Francisco Aug. 11, '89 20 M. None Strangulated in- guinal hernia, right side. 3 days Exploratory incision in median line, for diag- nostic purposes. Divis- ion of tissues over stran- gulated gut and return of bowel. No. Private. Recov- ery. Miscarriage of 3 mos. preg- nancy after 3 days. Fee cal fistula at site of hernia on 7th day. Perfect recovery at the end of a month. 6 Dr. Z. W. Saun- ders, S'n Luis Obispo Sept. 20, '89 24 M. One Extra -uterine pregnancy of six months duration. 6 mos. Abdominal section, li- gation of broad liga- ment and adhesions, removal of sac and con- tents complete. Yes. Hospital Death. Marked sh'ck tro u blesome oozing from denuded sur- face in Doug- lass pouch. Cause of death, peritonitis. Foetus living at the time of removal. 7 Dr. Gross, San Francisco Dec. 22, '89 10 M. Eight Abdominal ab- scess extending 5 w'ks. Abdominal section, re- moval of left tube and Yes. Private. Recov- ery. None. from region of liver to Douglass ovary; free opening made into abscess cavi- 8 Dr. J. D. Whit- ney, Jan 20, '90 51 M. None pouch. Intra-1 i g a m e n- tous cyst. 1 yr. ty; insertion of four drainage tubes. Enucleation of cyst. Yes. Private. Death. Universal; small i ntes- Death from shock and exhaustion. San Francisco tines and bladder in- jured. Recovery perfect. 9 Dr. Black, Jan. 22, '90 53 M. Ten Complete pro- 5 yrs. Ventral fixation of No. Private Recov- None, San Francisco lapse of uterus and bladder. uterus. Hospital ery. NINE MONTHS' WORK IN Abdominal Surgery. By CLINTON CUSHING, M. D. Professor of Gynecology, Cooper Medical College, San Francisco. [Read before the San Francisco Obstetrical Society, May 8th, 1890.] (Reprinted from "Pacific Medical Journal," July, 1890.) Gentlemen:-The accompanying table embraces all the cases of abdominal or intra-peritoneal surgery, that I have oper- ated upon during the nine months ending January 31st, 1890. Many of the cases were desperate, and the operation was under- taken as a forlorn hope; but the rapid recovery of the larger proportion of even the worst cases, shows conclusively the wis- dom of the procedure. Certain it is that speedy death was inevitable in a considerable number of cases, except for the prompt surgical interference, and I must confess that a number of bad cases recovered where no hope whatever was held out to relatives or friends. If I was asked upon what the success of abdominal surgery depends, I would say as I did in the article published last year, " perfect cleanliness, and personal skill due to familiarity with the work." A serious mistake made constantly by professional men, is to wait, before interference, until the patient is nearly in "articulo mortis." This is an error of judgment as far as the patient is concerned, and is scarcely fair to the surgeon, to ask of him im- possibilities. The added experience of the past nine months has still farther convinced me of the truth of the statement made in former papers, " that the peritoneum, if properly treated, and not infected, could be handled, opened, and examined with very slight risk." It is very difficult for a man who was educated twenty-five years ago, and was " brought up in the fear of God, and the peritoneum," to understand how it can be possible to open the 2 Nine Months' Work in Abdominal Surgery. abdomen and introduce the hand and arm and make a thorough examination, and this, practically, without risk; and especially is it difficult of comprehension, if he has not seen frequent ex- amples of abdominal surgery. To such I would say, the new gospel of cleanliness has made many things possible that were never dreamed of when we were students of medicine. Whether we term it Listerism or antisepticism, it matters little,so long as the dirt and filth, and the germs of putrefaction and disease are not allowed to come in contact with the wound or the serous cavity; and I doubt not the name of Joseph Lister will in the future be classed among the greatest benefactors of his race, by reason of his labors in the direction of the aseptic treatment of wounds. To have the hands of the surgeon, and his instruments and appliances perfectly clean may seem a very simple matter, but in fact it is not so. To have hands and sponges, instruments and appliances, the surface to be operated on, and the water used in the operation, all free from putrefactive germs, requires a sleepless vigilance, and an amount of time and attention to detail, that is but partially appreciated by a large number of the profession, and I venture the opinion that no surgeon, how- ever skillful he may be as an operator, need ever hope for any marked success in opening the large serous cavities, whether it be the knee-joint or the peritoneum, unless antisepticism is car- ried out in its fullest details; and these can only be learned by a sad experience with fatal cases, or by observation in the large centers of population, where they have been perfected by men who have been untiring in their devotion to its principles. As far as practicable, then, strict Listerism has been practiced in the cases reported; but in operations in private houses, especially in the houses of the poor, perfectly organized methods are not always easy. Some of the cases in the tables are of sufficient interest to warrant especial mention on account of unusual symptoms or treatment. Under the head of "Abdominal section for removal of ovarian tumor," No. 1 presented the following curious history: Five years ago she had removed by a surgeon in Kansas a cystic tumor of the right ovary; she recovered easily, and shortly after a tumor began to'appear in region of the left ovary. The surgeon, one year after the first operation, re-opened the Nine}Months' Work in Abdominal Surgery. 3 abdomen but found the tumor so firmly fixed by adhesion that he feared to undertake its removal and closed the abdomen. Four years later she was referred to me by Dr. Crabb of Millville, California. Her condition was now deplorable. Her abdomen was enormously distended by ascitic fluid. She had three large ventral hernias, one above the umbilicus, one below the umbilicus in the median line, and one in the right inguinal region; a solid, or semi-solid tumor the size of the adult head, occupied the left ovarian region. She had been tapped thirteen times during the previous four years, several gallons being removed each time. She was much emaciated and had the cachectic appearance of a person suffering from malignant disease. She had much pain in the region of the bladder, and the urine was loaded with pus. A careful examination of the urine disclosed pyelitis and cystitis, believed to be due to pres- sure. Four gallons of ascitic fluid were drawn off with great relief of symptoms, and after ten days treatment the kidney and bladder symptoms were improved sufficiently to warrant the effort to remove the tumor. The adhesions were nearly univer- sal. The tumor, intra-ligamentous of left ovary, was removed with difficulty, and the hernias repaired. The patient made an excellent recovery, without interruption. My assistant, Dr. W. F. Cheney, has reported this case in full at a former meeting of this society. It is a good example of what may be done in a difficult and desperate case. Case No. 2 of the same table admirably illustrates a phase of disease that I think, as yet, is not generally appreciated or un- derstood. The woman presented herself in fair health, with a cystic tumor in each ovary, the size of a child's head. The day for operation was set six days later, and upon her return at the agreed time she seemed to be laboring under great depression. Upon opening the abdomen it was found that the cyst of the right ovary had burst, and its contents, resembling pea soup, had been disseminated throughout the abdominal cavity, set- ting up general peritonitis. The cysts were removed, and the peritoneal cavity thoroughly washed out by repeated flushing with hydro-naphthol and water, and a drainage tube left in the lower angle of the wound. As near as could be judged, from three to four quarts of peri- toneal fluid escaped from the tube during the first three days. The discharge was clear and without odor, and the tube was Nine Months' Work in Abdominal Surgery. 4 removed on the fourth day. The wound healed kindly and no untoward symptoms supervened for sixteen days after the operation, when she was allowed to sit up in a chair. She had slight pain in abdomen, slept well, had no appetite, and temper- ature at no time was more than one degree above the normal, and most of the time normal. Her pulse, however, was quick and feeble, and the expression of face was not good; the bowels were regular, and urine passed freely. The abdomen was moderately distended, and felt boggy. Manifestly there was something seriously wrong. An open- ing was made with the point of a dressing forceps at the site where the drainage tube had been, and now there escaped from three to four pints of offensive pus. The abdomen was now thoroughly washed out, but the patient never rallied and died in four hours on the nineteenth day after the original operation. The point I wish to call attention to is, that it can be possible to have in the peritoneum, for days, a large quantity of fetid pus, with only a slight rise in temperature. Had the abdomen been reopened a week sooner and the parts thoroughly cleaned, the chances for recovery would have been good. The lesson taught by this case is self-evident. The treatment of pyosalpynx, and of pelvic abscess due to dis- ease of the Fallopian tubes, by abdominal section, has been very satisfactory. As will be seen from the table, but one death has occurred, and this in a most unpromising case of many years standing. The results are so satisfactory that this operation has without doubt a brilliant future. Several cases are reported where the uterus was found bound down in the position of retroversion, by strong adhesions, the result of former attacks of pelvic peritonitis. One or both ova- ries were found prolapsed, adherent and extremely tender to touch. The health and comfort of the woman were seriously impaired, and no local treatment or force that could be safely used was of any avail. In such cases, after the efforts to relieve by local treatment, such as tamponing, efforts to replace organs by rectum and uterine sound, the abdomen has been opened, the adhesions broken up, the ovaries, if diseased, removed, and the fundus of the uterus stitched to the anterior' abdominal wall. Some of the cases have shown excellent results and all have been benefited. Time is needed to determine the ultimate good; in any event, I know of no other resource in bad cases, and the risk to life is slight if properly done. Nine Months' Work in Abdominal Surgery. 5 The treatment of larger fibroid tumors of the uterus by elec- tricity has not been satisfactory in my hands, and in bad cases when the symptoms are severe or the woman is much under forty years of age and the tumor increasing rapidly in size, the resort to the knife will probably be our best resource until our knowledge of the causes shall be made more perfect. If a uter- ine fibroid is causing no untoward symptoms, is not increasing materially in size, and especially if the woman is approaching the menopause, certainly no interference is warrantable. I believe the intraperitoneal treatment of the stump in extirpa- tion of the uterus for fibroid tumor is the most rational, as I believe it will be the method of the future. It is coming more and more into favor in Germany, and an improved technique is giving increasing good results. The intraperitoneal method was pursued in the cases re- ported in the accompanying table. The fatal case occurred in a woman who was almost entirely bloodless at the time of the operation. An intraperitoneal abscess occurred at the end of a week, and her vitality was at so low an ebb that she was unable to rally from the added drain upon her strength. The abscess was due to a small slough of the small intestine consequent upon a fold being caught in the bite of a pair of haemostatic forceps that were applied to the broad ligaments on the right side to temporarily control exces- sive venous hemorrhage. The case of vaginal hysterectomy was interesting, inasmuch as there existed a commencing epithelioma of the cervix, and a sarcoma of the posterior wall of the body of the uterus. No ligatures were used, the arteries being controlled by pressure forceps to the stumps of the broad ligaments. The forceps were left in situ for forty-eight hours. At the end of nine days urine began to escape from the right ureter, but this ceased in five days and the case went on to an excellent recovery. The injury to the ureter was probably caused by a suture introduced to approximate the opening left in the roof of the vagina caused by the removal of the uterus. Under the heading " Laparotomy for Other Diseases of the Abdominal Organs," are several cases of interest. No. 1 was a well marked elastic pelvic tumor which crowded the uterus over to the right side. An exploratory incision showed it to be an encysted hsematocele, which caused much pelvic pain on 6 Nine Months' Work in Abdominal Surgery. account of pressure on the tissues of the broad ligament in which it lay. The woman had a well marked double uterus, united at the cervix, with but one external os uteri. The abdomen was closed and the cavity containing the blood opened from below through the roof of the vagina with the dilat- ing trocar, the sac thoroughly washed out and a self-retaining drainage tube left in. The patient was out of bed in two weeks and health restored. There was a slight discharge from the sac at the end of three months. Case No. 4 of the same table was in a most desperate condition at the time of operation, and that a fatal result followed is not surprising. It was a long standing case of peritonitis with universal adhesions; large col- lections of pus and extreme weakness to begin with. The adhesions were broken up and the two pus sacs removed after much time and effort, resulting in injury to both bladder and rectum. The injuries were repaired, but the patient never fully rallied from the shock, and died in twenty-four hours. For the credit of surgery it would have been better to have left the woman to her fate, but we now see so many most unpromising cases re- cover after abdominal sections, that we are warranted in giving nearly all who apply for relief the benefit of the doubt. Certain it is that the first duty of the surgeon should be to make as gallant a struggle as possible to save the lives of those who trust and rely upon his skill and courage, rather than to shape his course to the making of a favorable " record." Case No. 5 of same table was a strangulated inguinal hernia in a woman three months pregnant. On account of the adhesions about the neck of the sac, as well as on account of some obscur- ity in the diagnosis, the abdomen was opened in the median line, and the constricting ring afterwards divided by a second incision over the protruding portion of the gut. At the end of three days an abortion occurred necessitating the cleaning out of the uterus with curette and abortion forceps. Two days later a small portion of the gut sloughed at the site of constriction and a fecal fistula was established at the wound over inguinal ring. The opening in bowels healed in two weeks and thereafter the recovery was uninterrupted. The patient was delicate and emaciated at the outset, and the complications following the operation rendered the result very doubtful for several weeks, and her recovery was a credit to the art of surgery. Nine Months' Work in Abdominal Surgery. 7 Case 6 I think ought to have recovered; it was an extrauterine pregnancy of six or seven months on the left side of and firmly attached to the uterus. The patient's health was a good deal impaired by repeated attacks of pelvic pain and local peritoni- tis. Her physicians in San Luis Obispo and in Santa Bar- bara had correctly diagnosed the case before sending her to me. The abdomen was opened in the usual manner and the sac separated from the adjacent structures to which it was attached by firm adhesions. After the application of a number of liga- tures, the whole was peeled out and removed, but not before there had been a partial escape of the contents of the sac into the peritoneal cavity. The shock was very marked and I was forced to close the abdominal cavity before the oozing of blood from the separated surfaces was fully stopped. A drainage tube was left in the lower angle of the wound and acting under instructions, the gentleman in charge threw into the drainage tube an ounce of a twenty per cent solution of Mon- sel's salt (ferri persulph.) to counteract the bleeding. This was effective in putting a stop to the hemorrhage, but it formed a sticky clot that plugged up the drainage tube. Septic fever set in on the third day; on the fourth day I re- opened the abdomen and washed out clots and pus, but this did not prevent a fatal result. The child breathed and lived for half an hour. Manifestly the peritoneal cavity became infected, else the case would probably have recovered. The only antiseptic used has been the hydronaphthol, and I am still of the opinion that it is a good agent and it has some decided advantages. Notably it is inodorous, not poisonous, does not injure instruments or the skin of the operator's hands. A saturated solution in hot water is the strength used, and the peritoneal cavity can be filled with this solution repeatedly with perfect impunity. The less opium a patient gets after an abdominal section the better, and much the larger proportion of my patients get no anodynes whatever. The pain from the operation gradually subsides; the patient is turned on either side from time to time to rest them; and no food is allowed until peristalsis has com- menced sufficiently to expel flatus from the anus. This is often much aided by a rectal injection of a teaspoonful of oil and turpentine in a quart of hot water and repeated in a few hours if needed.