MUTATIONS IN MAIZE AND CHROMOSOMAL ABERRATIONS IN NEUROSPORA Barsara McCuiintock During the past year, studies of muta- tion-controlling systems in maize were continued at Cold Spring Harbor, and ex- aminations of chromosomal aberrations in Neurospora were carried out at the Cali- fornia Institute of Technology. Mutations in Maize In previous Year Books, evidence has been presented concerning the nature of action of mutation-controlling systems in maize that are responsible for the behavior of mutable genes. Much of the detailed evidence was derived from study over a period of years of the system composed of the two chromosomal units, Ds and Ae. Extensive examination of other systems was postponed until the behavior of this system had been well explored. Knowl- edge of gene-controlling systems in maize is progressing rapidly through the efforts of investigators at other institutions who are examining some of the gene-controlling units that have appeared in their materials. One such unit, being investigated by Dr. R. A. Brink and his students at the Uni- versity of Wisconsin, behaves much like Ac. My studies of the Ds-Ac system dur- ing the past year have been limited to ob- taining some additional information about . its action at one selected locus in the chro- imosome complement. This has involved further examination of the seven cases of change in action of I induced by Ds when the latter was located just to the left of Shi in chromosome 9. The origins and general descriptions of these cases were outlined on pages 231-233 of Year Book No. 52. The newly acquired information provides a clearer understanding of the similarities and differences among them. Only a sum- mary of this information need be presented here. Among the seven cases in which the ac- tion of I (located approximately four cross- over units to the left of Ds in the parent plants) was modified, Ds has been found to be present in the chromosome in each case and apparently not changed in loca- tion by the event that altered genic action in the segment of chromatin to the left of it. Ds remains near, and to the left of, SA1. The seven cases may be separated into two main classes: four that regularly produce viable homozygotes, and three that have given no viable homozygotes even though many attempts have been made this past year to obtain them. In all seven cases, the chromosome 9g having the altered region that includes the locus of J is transmitted normally through the female gametes; but transmission through the pollen grains is considerably reduced when these compete with others carrying normal chromosomes g. The extent of this reduction is approxi- mately the same for all the members of the first class and for two of the members of the second class, but is extreme for the remaining member of the second class. The seedlings derived from the homozy- gotes produced by members of the first class have all shown the same type of al- bescence phenomenon—disappearance of chlorophyll from the seedling leaves at about the three-leaf stage. Intercrossing has produced individuals carrying all pos- sible combinations of the seven altered chromosomes 9, except combinations be- tween those of class 2, which are apparently as inviable as are the homozygotes in each member of this class. Kernels with viable combinations show no pigment in the aleurone layer, resembling in this respect DEPARTMENT OF GENETICS the phenotypes of the homozygotes of class 1. The seedlings derived from them exhibit the same type of albescence phe- nomenon that characterizes the seedlings of the class-r homozygotes. In none of the seven cases has there been any evidence of crossing over within the affected region in individuals having a normal and an altered chromosome 9. In each case, however, crossing over to the right of the affected region—between SA: and Bz and between _ Bz and Wx—is normal. The above-described relations among the seven independent cases of change in genic action within a segment of chromosome 9 located to the left of Ds are consistent with a hypothesis that they originated through removal of a similar segment of chromo- some g in each case. The common segment removed would include the region: begin- ning just to the left of the locus of SA: and ending somewhere beyond that of I. The differences between members of the two classes and among members of the second class could then be explained by differences in the extent of loss beyond the locus of I—the members of class 2 having longer deficiencies than those of class 1, ‘and one member of class 2 the longest. No direct evidence of deficiency in any one of these seven chromosomes was obtained, how- ever, when each was compared with a nor- mal chromosome g at the pachytene stage of meiosis. Also, it is known that defi- ciency need not be involved in such loss of genic action. A Ds-induced inhibition of action may be the cause, for this is known to account for some similar types of loss of genic action in the segment of chromosome g located to the right of Ds. The types and extents of such loss were described in Year Book No. 52. System controlling genic expression of ai", The occurrence of genic instability in many organisms, and its general resem- blance to cases in maize, suggest that the gene-controlling units found in maize are not peculiar to that species. Rather, they reflect a type of nuclear organization and action that is probably present in many 255 organisms. Thus it is necessary, before wider integrations can be made, to deter- mine the kinds of gene-controlling sys- tems that exist, how they differ from one another, and whether or not interactions occur among them. Attention is now be- ing focused, therefore, on a system control- ling genic expression which differs. from the Ds-Ac system in some respects but resembles it in others. Although knowl- edge of the behavior of this second system is limited, it has been possible to formulate an interpretation from present informa- tion. This system operates to control genic expression of a:”"*, one of the mutable con- ditions that has arisen at the locus of A: in chromosome 3 in the Cold Spring Har- bor cultures: (A: is associated with the appearance of anthocyanin pigmentation in plant tissues and in the aleurone layer of the kernel; a1, known recessive allele, when homozygous, results in absence of antho- cyanin pigmentation in both plant and aleurone.) The system controlling genic expression at a" is considered to be composed of two units, one inserted at the locus of i in chromosome 3 at the time of origin of ai", and one located elsewhere in the complement. The evidence suggests that this latter unit, tentatively designated as Spm for reasons that will be made evident shortly, may be altered in somatic cells and possibly may also be transposed from one location to another in the chromosome complement. In these respects, its behavior resembles that of Ac. Another apparent similarity is that Spm must be present in the nucleus if mutations are to occur at the locus of a:.%*. Spm and Ac differ in a significant way, however, and this is re- lated to the contrasts in phenotype that are expressed in their presence and ab- sence. The presence of Ac is detected by the alterations it induces at the locus of the gene whose mutations it controls (or at the locus of Ds), which lead to recog- nizable phenotypic modifications in so- matic cells; its absence is indicated by the absence of any such modifications. With 256 regard to Spm, however, its presence or absence is recognized not only by the ap- pearance or nonappearance of mutations at a: +, but also by another phenotypic differ- ence that is sharply expressed in plants having certain states of a:”*. When Spm is present in somatic nuclei, genic action at the locus of a"? is completely inhibited except in those cells that carry a mutation at this locus. Such mutations occur in some somatic cells during development. They permit the occurrence of some forms of action of the genic material at the locus of a", and this is recognized pheno- typically in the tissues produced by the descendants of such cells. Therefore, both plants and kernels that have Spm are variegated in anthocyanin pigmentation. Spots or areas, each exhibiting a particular type and intensity of pigmentation—for different types of mutations are induced at a:”* when Spm is present—appear on a colorless background. Removal of Spm, whether occurring somatically in some cells or produced as the consequence of meiotic segregations in plants heterozygous for it, results in partial release of inhibition of genic action, presumably at a:"%, for the tissues of both the plant and the aleurone layer of the kernel are uniformly pig- mented. With some of the states of a", the color is less intense than that which ap- pears when the normal A; locus is present. The difference may be qualitative as well as quantitative, for the pigment does not seem to be the same as that produced by A;. No spots or areas with altered pigmen- tation appear. In other words, no variega- tion is expressed in the absence of Spm. The symbol Spm has been used to desig- nate this unit because it acts both as a sup- pressor and as a mutator. The origin of a:”* from a modification occurring at the locus of the normal A: gene was described in Year Book No. 50 (1950-1951). Spm was first discovered in a study of a particular state of a:"*, de- rived from the original state. This derived state was selected early in the investigation of a+ because it was considered to be CARNEGIE INSTITUTION OF WASHINGTON more suitable than the original state for an analysis of factors responsible for muta- tion at ai”. It was present in an indi- vidual kernel in the progeny of the plant in which a:”" first appeared. Some aspects of the inheritance behavior of this state of ai" were outlined in Year Book No. 52. The evidence described there indicated the presence in variegated plants of a unit factor (or of several similar unit factors), not linked to the locus of a”, that in- fluenced the expression of a:"*. It was then thought that removal of this factor from nuclei by meiotic segregations re- sulted in a particular type of mutation at the locus of a:"", and that in this respect the case resembled that of a:%*, where re- moval of such a factor is known to lead to mutation at ai". Results of subsequent investigation, however, carried out during the past year, suggest that removal of the unit factor, now designated Spm, does not lead to mutation at a7, but rather re- moves an inhibitory action ascribable to Spm, as outlined above. Evidence suggesting linkage of an Spm factor with Y or its allele y (Y, yellow starch in endosperm, dominant to y, white starch), located in chromosome 6 of the complement, was presented in Year Book No. 52 in table 3 of the report of this Department. An exploratory test involv- ing only nine plants was made this year, partly in order to determine whether or not the apparent linkage could be validated. These plants were derived from the varie- gated kernels produced on the ear of plant 6046C-2, recorded in the above-mentioned table. Two or more independently lo- cated Spm units were assumed to be pres- ent in this plant, but one of them appeared to be linked to Y. It should be emphasized that, in backcross tests, segregation ratios typical of linked units would appear only on the ears of plants having a single Spm unit, and in such plants only when losses of Spm from many cells did not occur late in the development of the ear. Further- more, transpositions of Spm to new loca- tions would distort ratios or even eliminate DEPARTMENT OF GENETICS evidence of linkage if they occurred early in the development of an ear or if they were frequent during the later stages of development... An early-occurring loss of Spm from a cell whose descendants con- tribute to the formation of the ear is de- tected readily by the appearance of an area on the mature ear in which all the kernels carrying @:”* show the characteristic pale 257 cated approximately 38 crossover units from Y. The presumed location in chro- mosome 6 of one of the Spm units in the parent plant, 6046C-2, has thus been con- firmed. Further description of the behavior of this gene-controlling system will be post- poned until the evidence from tests now under way becomes available. ” TABLE 17 PHENOTYPES OF KERNELS APPEARING ON EARS OF PLANTS WHOSE CONSTITUTIONS WERE a1” Sha/as sha; Y/y WHEN THESE WERE CROSSED BY PLANTS HOMOZYGOUS FOR 4, Shs, AND y PHENOTYPES OF KERNELS Shs sha PARENTAGE Color in aleurone Color in aleurone Totals IN CROSS - Pale Variegated Colorless Pale Variegated Colorless g 3 Y y Y y Y oy Y oy Y¥ y Y¥ y 6629A-1 1041-5... 36 58 66 35 0 0 0 0 0 0 85 89 369 6629A-1 1041-4... 33 54 51 36 0 1 0 0 1 1 101 98 376 6629A-3 1040-1... 34 52 43 37 0 0 0 1 1 0 85 83 336 6629A-4 1041-5... 23 65 56 36 0 0 0 0 0 0 90 84 354 6629A-6 1040-1... 34 67 78 37 0 0 0 0 J 0 86 113 416 6629A-7 1040-1... 29 59 58 36 4 1 0 0 0 0 105 100 392 6629A-9 1040-8... 39 41 49 38 0 0 1 0 0 0 79 90 337 6629A-9 1040-5... 41 58 50 34 0 1 0 1 0 0 79 «115 379 Totals ......... 269 454 451 = -289 4 3 1 2 3 1 710 772 2959 aleurone color that develops in the absence of Spm. A few ears had such areas. Early- occurring transpositions of Spm can be de- tected by markedly altered linkage rela- tions between the given units, by absence of such linkage, or by linkage of Spm to a factor carried in another chromosome. There was evidence of such changes in location of Spm, based on observed ratios produced by some of the ears. The conditions, indicated above, that are required for the production of typical link- age ratios in backcross tests were present in eight ears obtained from six of the nine tested plants. The design of the test cross and the types of kernels that appeared on each of these eight ears are shown in table 17. From the data in this table it may be concluded that a single Spm unit was pres- ent in these six plants, linked to Y and lo- CHROMOSOME ABERRATIONS IN Neurospora During the winter of 1953-1954, exami- nation of chromosome complements in asci of Neurospora crassa was undertaken at the California Institute of Technology, for the purpose of determining the nature of chromosomal aberrations known to be present in strains 4637 and 45502. All the stocks used in this study were obtained from Mary B. Mitchell, and all crosses were made by her. Her co-operation and interest were very much appreciated. Previous investigations had shown that strain 4637 carries a reciprocal transloca- tion between two nonhomologous chromo- somes. Although the earlier studies were limited, they did indicate that chromo- somes 1 and 6 are involved in the transloca- tion. The purpose of this year’s study was 258 to determine the position of break, in each of these two chromosomes, that gave rise to the translocation. Crosses were made between the wild-type strain 2522-1a and strain 4637R-1A. Nuclei in asci produced by this cross were examined at that stage of the ‘first meiotic prophase when the chromosomes are maximally elongated. It was possible, by observing synaptic con- figurations of the chromosomes involved in this translocation and by comparing chro- momere morphologies of paired elements within it, to determine the break position in each of the chromosomes. The linear organization of chromosome 6, the next to the smallest chromosome of the complement, is unusually well defined, and this makes possible a ready identifica- tion of its component parts. That of chro- mosome 1, the longest chromosome of the complement, is less well defined; but two conspicuous chromomeres are present, which can serve as points of orientation in describing break positions. One of them is located near the middle of the chromo- some, dividing it into two segments with relative lengths of 1 and 1.6. The other conspicuous chromomere is located near the end of the shorter of these two seg- ments. The position of the break in chro- mosome 1 is in the longer of its two seg- ments, approximately three-eighths of the distance from the free end of the segment. Chromosome 6 may be divided into several well marked segments. One terminal seg- ment contains large, closely packed chro- momeres. This is followed by a longer segment with smaller, less closely aligned chromomeres. A very conspicuous, deep- staining, dumbell-shaped chromomere sep- arates the second segment from the remain- ing segment of the chromosome. This last segment, whose length is about one- quarter that of the total chromosome, con- tains a few small, rather widely separated chromomeres. The position of the break in chromosome 6 is in the second of the above-described segments, closer to the first segment than to the conspicuous dumbbell-shaped chromomere. CARNEGIE INSTITUTION OF WASHINGTON In crosses of strain 4637 to wild type, various types of synaptic configuration were produced by association of the two translocation chromosomes introduced by strain 4637 and the two corresponding nor- mal chromosomes introduced by the wild- type strain. Homologous association of all components was frequent, resulting in the formation of a cross-shaped configuration having three short arms and one long arm. Failure of association of homologous com- ponents of one or more of the shorter arms of the cross was observed, however, in a number of nuclei. The remaining five pairs of chromosomes appeared to be nor- mal, for no gross structural modifications were observed in any member of a pair. In contrast to the relative ease with which the structural modification present in strain 4637 could be analyzed, that as- sociated with strain 45502 proved to be very difficult. In crosses of this strain to wild type, a distinctive pattern of normal and abnormal spores appeared in many of the asci. Cytological examination indicated that there is no simple reciprocal transloca- tion between two nonhomologous chromo- somes in this strain to account for the distinctive patterns of spore types. The chromosome complements of four isolates of ‘strain 45502 were examined: T45502- P1315-1a, T45502-1507-1A, T45502-1508-1a, and 70007TR-2A. The examinations sug- gested that in each of them the comple- ment is composed of seven haploid chro- mosomes plus an extra chromosome whose length is approximately half that of the smallest chromosome of the complement, namely, chromosome 7. The origin of this extra chromosome could not be deter- mined readily by inferences from synaptic associations, because of the many irregu- larities in chromosome associations that oc- curred when these strains were crossed to wild type and even when two of them, T45502-P1315-1a and 70007TR-2A, were in- tercrossed. A brief description of some of the ab- normal synaptic associations that were ob- served at the first meiotic prophase in asci DEPARTMENT OF GENETICS produced by crossing any one of the four strains of 45502 with wild type will indi- cate the nature of the complexities encoun- tered in this analysis. One end of the frag- ment chromosome was often associated with an end of another chromosome. This did not necessarily reflect homology, be- cause any one of the seven chromosomes of the haploid complement could enter into such an association. It occurred most frequently, however, with chromosome 7. When one end of the fragment chromo- some was associated with an end of an- other chromosome, the homologue of this second chromosome sometimes formed a terminal association with a member of still another pair of chromosomes. Although most of the aberrant associations occurred between ends of chromosomes, a few nu- clei were observed in which longer seg- ments of two nonhomologous chromo- somes were synaptically associated. Because of these irregularities in synap- tic behavior, determination of chromosome composition and organization in the ascus nuclei was difficult. In all nuclei, pairing occurred between some of the homologues. The same pairs, however, were not present in each nucleus. Nevertheless, by noting in each nucleus which chromosomes were paired and by comparing the members of each pair with regard to their internal structure, it was possible to determine whether or not any structural rearrange- ment was present in any member of a given pair. For two of the four examined isolates of 45502, this method produced no evidence of gross structural modifications in any of the seven regular chromosomes of the complement. In the other two iso- lates, the composition of chromosome 7 was not determined with certainty, but the other six chromosomes appeared to be normal. As was stated earlier, the origin of the small extra chromosome present in each of the four isolates of 45502 was not deter- mined. The high frequency of association of this fragment with a member of the chromosome 7 pair suggests a possible deri- 259 vation from chromosome 7. Some support for this inference is given by the similar high frequencies of such associations that appeared in many of the nuclei produced by crossing 45502-P1315-1a with 7oo07TR- 2A. Each parent presumably contributed the seven haploid chromosomes plus the fragment. Thus it was to be expected that nuclei with eight homologously associated pairs of chromosomes would be numerous. Instead, they were relatively rare. More often, one or both of the fragment chromo- somes were synaptically associated with another chromosome of the complement. Sometimes there appeared very complex configurations, involving members of sev- eral different chromosomes of the comple- ment. Chromosome 7 was a component of most of these aberrant configurations. The aberrant synaptic associations ap- pearing at the first meiotic prophase in all crosses involving these four isolates of 45502 were reflected at the late diakinesis and metaphase stages. Associations be- tween nonhomologous chromosomes were noted. Also, univalents were present in a number of nuclei. No concerted effort was made, however, to analyze these stages, or still later ones in the meiotic process. Therefore it is not known whether or not many abnormal disjunctions of chromo- somes occurred at anaphase I as a conse- quence of abnormal pairing or lack of pair- ing. Neither is it known to what extent such disjunctions could contribute to ab- normal spore formation. The difficulties encountered in the anal- ysis of the chromosome constitution of 45502 were intensified in the first period of observation by the presence of another chromosomal abnormality, which was later found to have been introduced by the wild- type parent. The initial observations were made in asci produced by the cross of 45502-P1315-1a to wild-type strain 2292-2A. In addition to the fragment chromosome, a structural abnormality was noted in one of the two chromosomes 5. This chromo- some was considerably longer than its normal homologue, its length being com- 260 parable to that of chromosome 3. A seg- ment of uncertain origin, added to or in- serted into one arm of the chromosome, was responsible for the increased length. Synaptic associations were very frequent between this abnormal segment and the fragment chromosome. In addition, other complex types of synaptic configurations were formed, incorporating not only the fragment chromosome and the abnormal chromosome 5, but also one or more other chromosomes of the complement. Fre- quently, homologues of chromosome 7 or of both chromosome 7 and chromosome 2 were components of these configurations. Only after an analysis had been made of the chromosomes in asci derived from other crosses was it realized that the ab- normal chromosome 5 had been intro- duced by the wild-type parent 2292-2A. Confusion in interpreting the chromo- some constitution of 45502—arising from this initial lack of knowledge of the consti- tution of the wild-type parent, 2292-2A, used in some of the crosses—seriously ham- CARNEGIE INSTITUTION OF WASHINGTON pered progress toward a solution of the main problem, which was to determine the chromosome abnormality responsible for the distinctive spore pattern and for the accompanying false linkages of certain genetic markers. Nevertheless, the knowl- edge gained from this experience is of some general significance. It indicates the necessity for determining the chromosome constitution of wild-type and tester stocks before they are used in crosses requiring cytogenetic analysis. It also suggests that some of the discordant results derived from genetic analyses may be due to undetected structural modifications of chromosomes in strains presumed to be normal in their chromosome constitutions. Although the study of chromosome con- stitutions and behavior in strains derived from 45502 had to be terminated before the cytogenetic relations had been clarified, the increased knowledge of chromosome organization and behavior in Neurospora which it provided will serve as a guide in future studies of this type. BIBLIOGRAPHY BernsTEIn, M. H. Deoxyribonucleoproteins of cell nuclei: Sensitivity to X-rays. Nature, vol. 174, p. 463 (1954). Berriz, A.M. M. The effects of temperature on ultraviolet-induced mutability in Escherichia coli. Proc. Nat. Acad. Sci. vol. 39, pp. 1125-1133 (1953). Demerec, M. (editor). Advances in Genetics, vol. 6. 488 pp. New York, Academic Press (1954). What makes genes mutate? Proc. Amer. Philos. Soc., vol. 98, pp. 318-322 (1954). Hersnzy, A.D. Functional differentiation with- in particles of bacteriophage T2. Cold Spring Harbor Symp. Quant. Biol., vol. 18, PP. 135-139 (1953). —— Nucleic acid economy in bacteria in- fected with bacteriophage Tz. . II. Phage precursor nucleic acid. Jour. Gen. Physiol., vol. 37, pp. 1-23 (1953). Some central problems of viral growth. In The dynamics of virus and rickettsial in- fections, pp. 13-15. New York, Blakiston Co. (1954). Kaurmann, B. N. See Paicen, K. Kaurmann, B. P. Chromosome aberrations in- duced in animal cells by ionizing radiations. In Radiation biology, ed. A. Hollaender, pp. 627-711. New York, McGraw-Hill Book Co. (1954). See McDonatrp, M. R. Kunirz, M., and M. R. McDonaxp, Ribonu- clease. Zn Biochemical preparations, vol. 3, ed. E. E. Snell, pp. g-19. New York, John Wiley & Sons (1953). Lasrum, E.L. The effect of generation time on the delayed appearance of induced mutants in Escherichia coli. Proc. Nat. Acad. Sci., vol. 39, pp. 1221-1227 (1953). LevinTHAL, C., and N. Visconti. Growth and recombination in bacterial viruses. Genetics, vol. 38, pp. 500-511 (1953). McCuintock, B. Induction of instability at se- lected loci in maize. Genetics, vol. 38, pp. 579-599 (1953). McDonatp, M. R. The effects of X rays on di- lute solutions of crystalline trypsin: Contin- ued inactivation after termination of irradia- tion. Brit. Jour. Radiol., vol. 27, pp. 62-63 (1954). The inactivation of dilute solutions of crystalline trypsin by X-radiation. I. Kinet- ics and characteristics. Jour. Gen. Physiol, vol. 38, pp. 93-103 (1954). DEPARTMENT OF GENETICS and B. P. Kaurmann. The degradation by ribonuclease of substrates other than ribo- nucleic acid. Jour. Histochem. and Cyto- chem., vol. 2, pp. 387-394 (1954). See Kunitz, M. Paicen, K. The occurrence of several biochem- ically distinct types of mitochondria in rat liver. Jour. Biol. Chem., vol. 206, pp. 9457 957 (1954). 261 and B. N. Kaurmann. Effects of X-ir- radiation on amount and composition of nucleic acids in liver. Jour. Cell. and Comp. Physiol., vol. 42, pp. 163-178 (1953). Visconti, N. See LevintHat, C. von Borster, R. C. See Wuitine, A. R. Wuitine, A. R., and R. C. von Borster. Dom- inant lethal and inactivation effects of nitro- gen mustard on Habrobracon sperm. Ge- netics, vol. 39, pp. 317-325 (1954).