Editorial. 
183 
LIST OF PHYSICIANS REGISTERED IN THE CLERK’S 
OFFICE OF THE COUNTY OF ERIE 
We have taken great pains to prepare a complete list of those 
who have complied with the New Medical Law. Comment is 
unnecessary at this time. We shall take occasion to refer to 
this subject in a future number of the Journal. 
Name. 
Graduate of 
Date. 
Abbey, Emery C 
..Eclectic Med. College, Phila. Pa..... 
..April, 1863. 
Abbott, Frank A 
..Med. Dept. University of Buffalo 
..Feb. 1866. 
Armstrong, J. Stone.. 
...Jefferson Med. College, Phila 
..Mar, 12, 187-. 
Abbott, George 
...Buffalo Med. University 
Allen, Jabez 
...Castleton Med. College, Vt 
Appleby, H. T 
...Erie County Homoeopathic Med. Society... 
Allen, Daniel W 
..Med. Dept. University of Buffalo 
Brown, George L 
...Harvard Med. College, Mass 
Brecht, F. E. L 
...University of Buffalo 
..Feb. 22, 1S72. 
Briggs, Albert II 
...Med. Department University of Buffalo 
Banta, Rollin L 
..Med. Department University of Buffalo 
Brayton, Samuel N... 
...Coll, of Phys. & Surg. New York City 
...Mar,, 1861. 
Beals, Herbert J 
...N. Y. Homoeopathic Med College 
Barker, Arthur M ... 
..Med. Department University of Buffalo 
Boardman, John 
..University of Pennsylvania 
Bartow, Bernard 
...Med. Department University of Bnffalo 
Bailey, Daniel A.. ... 
...Med. Department University of Buffalo 
..July, 1865. 
Barnes, Edwin R 
...Long Island Coll. Hosp., Brooklyn, N. Y... 
Brooks, Abel D. 
..Eclectic Med. Coll, of the City of New York,May 28, 1872. 
Brooks, A. J 
Baethig, Henry 
...Albany Medical College 
...Hahneman Med. College, of Philadelphia.. 
Barrett, Willian C.... 
..University of Buffalo 
...Feb., 1880. 
Bisseli, Elias L 
...University of Michigan 
Bidaman, Weston D...University of Buffalo 
Bull, Louis A 
...University of Buffalo 
...Feb. 25, 1879. 
Bull, A. T 
...N. Y. University, Medical Department 
.. Mar., 1848. 
Berkes, Mary 
...University of Buffalo 
...Feb. 22, 1880. 
Burt, Franklin 
...Coll, of Phys. and Surg. of Ontario, Canada...May 21, 1878. 
And University of Toronto 
Bartlett, Frederick W..New York Medical College 
Bonnar, John D 
...University of Trinity College, Toronto 
...May, 1878. 
Bourne, C. W 
...Castleton Medical College, Vt 
Boies, Loren F 
...Med. Dept. University of Buffalo 
Broardt, Peter 
...Homeopathic Med. College of Erie Co..... 
..Dec. 6, 1876. 
Burwell, Geo. N 
...University of Pa., in Philadelphia 
...April, 1843. 
Blakely, Isaac C 
...Licensed by University of Buffalo 
Colton, Henry E 
...Cleveland Homeopathic College 
Crane, Lucien D 
.. Licensed by Eclectic Med. Coll, of Genesee 
Valley District 
Crittenden, S. C 
...Medical College, Pa 
1857. 
Clothier, Wm. P 
...Med. Dept. University of Buffalo 
...Feb, 23, 1875. 
Curtiss, Alexander M..Pulte Med. College, Cincinnati 
..May 24, 1877. 
Homeopathic Medical College. 
..Feb. 28, 1878. 
Cronyn, John L. C.... 
...Med. Dept. University of Buffalo 
...Feb., 1876. 
Cronyn, John 
...University of Toronto 
State Censors of N. Y 184 
Editorial. 
Name. 
Graduate of 
Date. 
Crane, Ory Philo 
..Eclectic Medical Society of the Genesee Val- 
ley District 
•June, 
1879. 
Cary, Charles 
..Med. Dept. University of Buffalo 
• Feb., 
1875. 
Colyer, Charles W.... 
..Med. Dept. University of Buffalo 
.Feb, 
1862. 
Champlin, Chas. G.... 
..Med. Dept. University of Buffalo .... 
Feb. 
24, 1880. 
Campbell, Robert E. 
..University of Michigan 
Mar. 
25, 1866. 
Clark, C. G 
..University of Michigan 
13,1864. 
Callahan, Thos. H.... 
..Eclectic Med. Coll, of Philadelphia, Pa 
•Jan. 
21, 1863. 
Daniels, Clayton M... 
..University of Buffalo.. 
.Feb. 
25, 1880. 
Dagenais, Alphonse.. 
..Victoria University, Canada 
..May 10, 1867. 
Diehl, Conrad.. ...... 
..University of Buffalo 
• Feb., 
1866. 
Davidson, A. R 
..Med, Dept. University of Buffalo 
.Feb 
1878. 
Dorland, Elias T 
..University of Michigan 
24, 1854. 
Dye, John H 
..Eclectic College of N. Y. City 
.Feb. 
29, 1873. 
Dayton, Charles L 
..Buffalo Medical University 
i853- 
Devening, Daniel.... 
..University City of N. Y. Med. Dept 
. Mar. 
6, 1846. 
Daggett, Byron H.... 
..University of Buffalo 
• Feb., 
1867. 
Danforth, W. A 
..Rush Med. College, Chicago, 111 
.Feb. 
3, 1869. 
Dayton, L. P 
..Geneva Med. College 
.Feb., 
1846. 
Dorr, Samuel G 
..Buffalo Med. University 
1875- 
Denny, Mrs. Louisa.. 
. Victoria College, Kingston, Ont 
10, 1845. 
Dambach, John 
..Buffalo Med. College 
.Feb , 
1868. 
Erb, Peter 
..University of Michigan 
..Mar. 
26, 1879. 
Ellwood, Henry S.... 
-.Med Dept University of Buffalo 
.Feb , 
1868. 
Elliott, Justiq C 
..Med. Dept. University of Buffalo 
, Feb 
1851. 
Earl, W. C 
..Bellevue College, N. Y 
.Mar. 
3, 1864. 
Eisbein, David 
..University of Buffalo 
..Feb. 
26, 1878. 
Farrington, Edwin PI..Buffalo Med. College 
.Feb, 
27, 1867. 
Bellevue Med. College 
.Feb. 
28, 1875. 
Fowler, Joseph 
..Med, Dept. University of Buffalo 
.Feb 
25, 1873. 
Foster, Hubbard A... 
..Med. Dept. Harvard Univ. Boston. Mass 
8, 1877. 
Frost, Henry C 
..Cleveland Homeopathic Med. College 
.Feb. 
11, 1874. 
Farrington, D. H 
..Buffalo Med. College 
.Feb., 
1863. 
Folwell, M. B 
..Med. Dept. University of Buffalo 
.Feb., 
1867. 
Gould, William 
..Med. Dept. University of Buffalo 
.Feb, 
27, 1850. 
Granger, William D. 
..Bellevue Hospital Medical College 
-Mar , 
1879. 
Gay, Charles C. F 
..Berkshire Medical Institution 
1846. 
Gail, Win. H 
..Medical Department University of Buffalo... 
.Feb., 
1864. 
Greene, Joseph C 
..Albany Medical College 
.June 
12, 1855. 
Greene, S. S 
..Medical College of the University of N. Y... 
Mar., 
1864. 
Gueso, Carl H.. 
..Buffalo Medical University 
.Feb. 
25, 1880. 
Grove, Benjamin H... 
...Medical University of Buffalo 
.Feb , 
1880. 
Greene, Walter D 
..University of Buffalo 
,Feb 
26, 1878. 
Gigolsky, Bernhard... 
..Konigsberg Hospital, Prussia 
.Nov. 
13, 1871. 
Gipple, F. M 
..University of Buffalo 
.Feb. 
25, l88o. 
Hancock,Alexander S ,Toronto School of Medicine 
.Apr. 
25, 1868. 
College of Phys. and Surg., Ontario, Canada.Aug. 30, 1878. 
Hubbell, Alvin A 
..University of Buffalo 
.Feb. 
23, 1876. 
Hoffmeyer, John A... 
..Medical Department University of Buffalo... 
.Feb. 
25, 1880. 
Haberstro, Joseph.... 
..Medical Department University cf Buffalo... 
.Feb , 
1880. 
Hoyer, Frederick F.. 
..Medical Department University of Buffalo... 
.April, 
, I849- 
Hauenstein, Jno 
..Geneva Medical College, State of N. Y 
•Jan., 
1844. 
Howard, Charles F... 
..Medical Department University of Buffalo... 
Feb., 
1878. 
Harrington, D. W.... 
..Medical Department University of Buffalo... 
.Feb., 
1871. 
Harvey, C. W 
..Medical Department University of Buffalo... 
1838. 
Harvey, Leon F 
..Jefferson Medical College, Pa 
..Medical Department University of Buffalo... 
.Mar., 
1859. 
Hill, John D 
.Apr., 
1849. 
Hartwig, Marcell 
..Fred. Wilhelm’s University at Berlin, Prussia 
l873- 
State Censors of the State of New York 
1879. Editorial. 
185 
Name. 
Graduate of 
Date. 
Howe, Lucien 
..Royal College of Surgeons, England 
..July 23, 1873. 
Bellevue Medical College, Long Island.... 
1872. 
Hurd, S. Wright , 
..Hahnemann Med. College of Philadelphia.. 
..Mar. 
10, 1880. 
Hoxsie, A. C 
..Cleveland Homeopathic Medical College.... 
...Feb., 
1864. 
Hopkins, H. R 
..Medical Department University of Buffalo,. 
..Feb,, 
1867. 
Hebenstreit, Robert.. 
..Medical Department University of Buffalo.. 
..Feb., 
1872. 
Halbert, John S 
..Buffalo Medical College 
..Feb., 
1872. 
Hill, Clayton L 
..Buffalo Medical College 
..Feb., 
1864. 
Heinemann, J. D 
.Cleveland Homeopathic Hosp. College 
..Feb. 
17, 1875. 
Henderson, Sallie B.. 
..College of Phys. and Surg , Buffalo, N. Y... 
26, 1880. 
Hoyt, Horace 
..Buffalo Medical College 
48. 
Johnson, Thomas M . 
. Buffalo Medical College. 
.Feb., 
1861. 
Jackson, W. H 
..South Carolina University 
4» 1873. 
Johnston, E. E 
Krug, Tulius F 
..Buffalo Medical College 
..Medical College of Indiana, 
26, 1880. 
Kilbourne, H. S 
Department of Butler University 
1, 1878. 
..University of Michigan 
1865. 
Kenyon, William B.. 
King, J. E 
..Homeopathic College of Philadelphia 
1874. 
..University of Buffalo 
1847. 
Krombein, Louis E.. 
..Buffalo Medical College 
i860. 
Kenyon, Lorenzo M. 
..Homoepathic Medical College of Missouri.. 
..Feb , 
1871;. 
Keene, Jos. W.'. 
..Med. School of Harvard University 
..June 27, 1878. 
Kamerling, Andrew. 
..Med. Dept. University of Buffalo, N. Y 
, 1864. 
Lanigan, John A 
..University of the City of New York 
..Feb., 
. 1876. 
Little, Edward 
..Med, Dept. University of Buffalo 
..Feb., 
1862. 
Long, William E....... 
..Cleveland Homeopathic Hospital College... 
..Feb. 
23, 1880. 
Lothrop, Thomas 
..University of Michigan 
...Mar. 2?, i8;8. 
Loomis, Horatio N... 
..The Faculty of the Medical College at Fair- 
field, Herk. Co., N. Y 
1828. 
Lynde, U. C 
..Buffalo University 
1859. 
And Jefferson Med. Coll 
1866. 
Lothrop, Benj. L 
..Bellevue Hospital Med. College.... 
..Feb., 
1872. 
Lewis, Geo. W 
..Med. Dept. University of New York 
1850. 
Lewis, F. Park 
..Puelte Med. College 
1876. 
Lou See On 
..Lou Com Chong, a duly designated authority 
in Canton, China, July 28, in the 34th year 
of the reign of Ton Kong, Emperor of 
China 
McGill, W. D 
..H. H. College, Cleveland, O 
25, t88o. 
McNeil, Dugald 
..Med. Dept. University of Buffalo 
20, 1871. 
Myers, Reuben S 
..Med. Dept. University of Vermont 
...July 
1, 1875. 
Mynter, Herman 
..Med. Society of the State of N. Y 
1, 1875. 
McPherson, Geo W. 
..University of Michigan .. 
28, 1866. 
McMichael, L. D 
Meisburger, Wm 
Miller, John G 
..Eclectic Med College of Philadelphia, Pa.. 
..University of Freiburg, Germany 
..Jan. 
23, 1868. 
..University of Buffalo 
, 1876. 
Moody, Mary B 
..University of Buffalo 
1876. 
Mixer, S. F 
..Med, Dept. Yale Coll, and Phys. and Surg. 
N. Y. City 
..Mar., 
1847. 
McDonald, Samuel.... 
.Buffalo Med. College 
23, 18SQ. 
Miner, Julius F 
- Albany Med. College 
26, 1847. 
Mackay, Gustavus E. 
..Med. Dept. University of Buffalo 
23,1866. 
JdcCrea, Philip A 
..Med. Dept. University of Buffalo 
1875. 
Marcley, James J 
.Coll, of Phys. and Surg., N. Y. City 
..Feb., 
1873. 
Matzinger, Charles.... 
.University of Wein, Germany 
17, 1830. 
Murray, William D... 
..National Med. College 
1859. 
Murray, Henry B 
..Bellevue Hospital Medical College 
1868. 
Moore, Samuel H 
• College of Phys. and Surg., New York 
14, 1867. 
Nichell, Henry 
• Medical Department University of Buffalo.. 
..Feb. 25, 186 
Editorial. 
Name. 
Graduate of 
Pate. 
Nott, S. E. S. H 
.Castleton Medical College........ 
1S44. 
O’Connell, Patrick M, 
..Missouri Medical College... 
. Mar. 
2, 1877. 
Osborne, Nehemiah... 
.Buffalo University 
.Feb., 
1863. 
O’Brien, Edward C.W..Buffalo Medical College 
..Feb., 
, 1867. 
Osborne, F. G 
•Buffalo Medical College 
.Feb., 
’68 or ’69. 
Pynchon, Edwin 
• Medical College of Ohio, Cincinnati, O 
.Mar. 
2, 1876. 
Pohle, John D. A 
.Cleveland Medical College . 
.Feb. 
2, 1880. 
Peterson, Frederick..., 
..Med. Department University of Buffalo 
Feb 
1880. 
Potter, Samuel 
• Academy of Medicine, Vt 
.Nov. 
12,1836. 
Pierce, Franklin D.... 
.Univ. of the City of N. Y , Med. Dep’t 
.Feb. 
19, 1878. 
„Feb. 
24, 1869. 
1876. 
Packwood, W. J 
.Buffalo Medical College 
..Feb, 
Pennell, Ezra 
.Buffalo Medical College 
.Feb. 
27, 1867, 
Parker, L. P. L 
..Buffalo Medical College 
..Feb. 
22, 1854. 
Phelps, Wm. C 
.Med. Department University of Buffalo 
.Feb. 
22, 1866. 
Pierce, Ray V 
.Eclectic Med. College of Cincinnati, O 
.Feb. 
15, 1865. 
Petsch, Charles F 
.Cleveland Homoeopathic College 
.Feb 
1870. 
Pettit, John A 
..Buffalo Medical College 
24, 1874. 
Parnenter, W. L 
.Homoeopathic College of Cleveland, 0 
, Feb 
12, 1873. 
Rowe, George G 
.University of Toronto 
10, 1879. 
Ring, Charles A 
.Med. Department University of Buffalo 
.Feb. 
26, 1878. 
Rochester, Thomas F..Med. Dep’t University of Pennsylvania 
Feb 
1848. 
Richmond, Ira 
.New York Medical College 
. June 
, 1856. 
Rogers, Henry W 
..Buffalo Medical College 
.Feb. 
25, 1880. 
Retel, Casper 
..License by College of Physicians and Sur- 
geons, Buffalo, 25 years’ practice and 
2, 1880. 
candidated for graduation 
Ring, William 
..University of Buffalo 
..June 
l6, 1847. 
Rouse, M. D 
Stumpf, Daniel B 
..Med. Dep’t University of Pennsylvania 
, 1866. 
.Cleveland Homoeopathic College 
.Feb , 
1876. 
Schade, Louis C. F.... 
.Licensed by the Medical Society of the 
State of New York 
•July 
22, 1876. 
Shaw, Merrill II 
.Medical College at Geneva, N. Y 
1839. 
Stanley, Fred. G 
,N. Y. Medical College, New York City 
I86l. 
Stockton, Chas. G 
.Med. Department University of Buffalo 
.Feb., 
1878. 
Sisson, Perry 
.American Health College, Cincinnati, O 
.Ort,, 
I876. 
Storck, Edward 
University of Michigan 
, I854. 
Searles, Macy B 
.Buffalo Medical College 
.Feb. 
23, 1869. 
Simson, J. R 
..Horn. Hosp. College, Cleveland, O 
.Feb., 
l88o. 
Stearns, George R 
.N. Y. Homcepathic Medical College 
Feb, 
28, 1878. 
Smith, Lee Herbert... 
..University of Buffalo 
1877. 
Slacer, William H 
.Medical University of Buffalo 
,.Feb. 
22, 1873. 
Storck, Eugene E 
..Medical University of Buffalo 
Feb 
1878. 
Strong, Phineas H 
..Albany Medical College 
> 1839. 
Samo, J. B 
.College of Phys. aad Surg., New York City...Mar. 
28, 1832. 
Sonnick, P. L 
..University of Wurzburg, Germany 
. 1853. 
Smith, James S 
..University of Buffalo 
25, 1862. 
Seymour, Abby Janet..Hahneman College, Chicago, 111 
. 1873. 
Sloan, James 
..Medical Department University of Buffalo... 
.Feb. 
22, 1870. 
Sweetland, Fred W.... 
..Medical Department University of Buffalo... 
.Feb,, 
1878. 
Strong, Orville C 
..Medical Department University of Buffalo... 
. 
I87I. 
Sperry, M. M 
.Licensed by S. W. Wetmore. 
1880. 
Shaw, M. B 
..Buffalo Medical College 
1866. 
Stevenson, James D.G.44 years’ practice, of which over 30 years has 
been in Buffalo, Erie Co., JN. Y 
Tyler, Clarence A 
.Western Reserve College, Hudson, O 
12, 1874. 
Turner, A. F 
.Cleveland Homeopathic Hosp. Coll., O 
. 1875. 
Thoma, L. Otto 
.Med. Department University of Buffalo, 
.Feb 
1870. 
Tobie, E 
.Geneva Medical College, N. Y 
• Feb. 
IO, 1855. Reviews. 
187 
Name. 
. Graduate of 
Date. 
Treffehn, H 
..University of Halle, Prussia 
1846. 
Thompson, Justin G.. 
..University of Michigan 
27, 1861. 
Turver, W. W 
..Bellevue Hospital Med. College, N. Y 
..Mar. 
, 1879. 
Hochschule 
..Dec., 
> 1877. 
Taylor, T. B 
..New York Central Med. Association 
, 1878. 
Volker, Louis C 
..Med. Dept. University of Buffalo 
..Feb , 
1877. 
Van Peyma, W 
..University of Toronto 
..April, 1850. 
State Curators of N. Y 
, i860. 
Van Peyma, J. W.. . 
..University of Goningen, Holland 
1841. 
Von Schulenberg, E 
..Coll, of Physicians & Surg., Buffalo, N.Y... 
..Feb. 
20, 1880. 
Vaughn, Frank O .. . 
..Buffalo Med. Univ. State of New York 
..Feb. 
25, 1880. 
Van Peyma, P. W — 
..Med. Dept. University of Buffalo 
...Feb., 
1872. 
Walsh, John J 
..Med. Dept. University of Buffalo 
..Feb. 
25, 1871. 
Weet, Elroy Sabin.... 
..Med. Dept. University of Buffalo 
..Feb. 
24, 1874. 
Wyckoff, Cornelius C..Med. Dept. University of Buffalo 
..June, 
1848. 
Wiggins, D. B 
. P. M. College of Cincinnati, O 
..Feb, 
16, 1846. 
Wetzel, Charles H.... 
..Med. Dept. University of Buffalo 
..Feb., 
1876. 
Walton,JohnTompkins,University of Pennsylvania'at Phila., Pa.... 
29, 1856. 
Willoughby, Matthew..Med. Dept. University of Buffalo 
..Feb., 
1867. 
White, Russel J...... 
..New York Eclectic Medical College 
..Feb. 
4, 1875- 
Wenz, Julius 
..University of Buffalo 
..Feb. 
21, 1865. 
Wetmore, Samuel W. ..Med. Dept. University of Buffalo 
..Feb., 
1862. 
Warren, Samuel H... 
..Buffalo Medical College 
..Feb. 
25,1880. 
Wall, Charles A 
..University of Buffalo 
..Feb., 
1879. 
White, James P 
..Jefferson Medical College of Phila 
1834. 
Wage, John F 
..Detroit Homeopathic College 
12, 1874. 
Willet, Phebe 
Wolsey, C. F 
..Col. of Phys. and Surg., Syracuse, N.Y... 
..Ten years’ Practice and Candidate for 
...June 
28, 1876. 
Graduation Col. Phys. & Surg., Buffalo,.., 
Wende, Ernest 
..Med. Dept. University of Buffalo 
..Feb. 
28, 1876. 
Waldruff, E. C 
..Buffalo Medical University 
..Feb, 
1880. 
Whitten, Clarke 
..American Medical College of St. Louis 
••Jan. 30, 1874. 
Zielinski, Jacob 
..Possen Medical Institute, Possen, Prussia..., 
1864. 
A Treatise on the Practice of Medicine. For the use of Students and Prac- 
titioners. By Robert Bartholow, M. A., M. D., LL. D., Prof, of Materia 
Medica and General Therapeutics in the Jefferson Medical College of Phila- 
delphia, etc. New York: D. Appleton & Co., i, 3 and 5 Bond street. 1880. 
This work of 850 pages octavo, is one that we can honestly 
and do most heartily recommend. The writer is well known as 
the author of a work upon Materia Medica and Therapeutics, 
one highly valued, but not more justly so than the present 
treatise. The author has had a large experience in the study 
and treatment of disease, and this is his apology for adding 
another to the already long list of text-books upon practice- Reviews. 
188 
In his preface he reviews the special privileges enjoyed by him- 
self in the study of disease. 
“ Serving as an officer of the Medical Staff of the United States 
Army in Kansas, Utah, Colorado, New Mexico, Minnesota, and 
during the war of the rebellion at Washington, Nashville, Chata- 
nooga, Baltimore, etc., followed by an extensive practice (private 
and hospital) of sixteen years, at Cincinnati, I may justly claim 
to have enjoyed large opportunities for the clinical study of the 
diseases of the North American Continent. With one or two 
unimportant exceptions, I have had personal charge of the 
maladies treated of in this work, and have made them the subject 
of clinical demonstration and post mortem investigation, either 
privately or in public lectures.” 
While being well pleased with the work in every respect,we wish 
particularly to indicate our appreciation of the author’s views 
upon treatment. He says : “ The reader will find that I have 
no sympathy with the therapeutical nihilism of the" day. * * 
Indeed there is no department of the subject in which it 
seemed to me so necessary to express positive opinions.” 
Another great advantage is found in the fact that the later dis- 
coveries in Pathology have been incorporated. 
In this respect the treatise is fully up to date and very com- 
plete. Both to student and practitioner we once more strongly 
and unreservedly recommend this work. 
The Transactions of the Medical Association of the State of Missouri. 
This is not a large volume, but contains among its papers 
one or two of special merit. The president, in his address, on 
“ Medical Ultraisms ” indulges in some hard hits at the expense 
of the gynaecologists, but in general it is marked by strong 
common sense views. From the report of the committee on 
medical education, it appears the schools in that portion of the 
country are being subjected to healthy criticisms, which in some 
instances, at least, cannot but prove beneficiaL^..-?--