THE PATH TO THE DOUBLE HELIX The Discovery of DNA ROBERT OLBY Professor of the History and Philosophy of Science The University of Pittsburgh FOREWORD BY FRANCIS CRICK DOVER PUBLICATIONS, INC. NEW YORK Contents Frontispiece Foreword by Francis Crick Preface Note on References to Source Material List of Plates Introduction Note to the Introduction (1994) Section I From Colloidal Particles to Long-Chain Molecules: Bergmann, Staudinger, Svedberg, Polanyi, Mark, Astbury Chapter I The Macromolecule Chapter 2 The Ultracentrifuge Chapter 3 The Fibre Diagram and the Long-Chain Molecule Chapter 4 The Leeds School under Astbury Chapter 5 Astbury under Attack Section II Nucleic Acids and the Nature of the Hereditary Material: Levene, Caspersson, Garrod, Muller, Darlington, Stanley Chapter 6 Kossel, Levene and the Tetranucleotide Hypothesis Chapter 7 The Nucleoprotein Theory of the Gene Chapter 8 The Physiology of the Gene Chapter 9 The Enzyme Theory of Life Chapter 10 The Chemistry of Virus-Genes Section III Bacterial Transformation, its Nature and Implications: Griffith, Avery, Boivin, Vendrely, Chargaff, Wyatt Chapter 11 Bacterial Transformation Chapter 12 The Identity of the Transforming Substance Chapter 13 Support for Avery Chapter 14 Base Ratios Section IV Intellectual Migrations: Delbrick, Schrédinger, Bernal, Perutz, Pauling, Watson and Crick Chapter 15 Physicists in Biology: The Informational School Chapter 16 Physicists and Chemists in Biology: The Structural School XV xiii xvii xix XXV 11 23 41 59 71 73 97 123 143 153 167 169 181 195 207 223 225 249 CONTENTS Chapter 17 Pauling, Caltech and the a-Helix 267 Chapter 18 Watson and Crick 297 Section V Hunting for the Helix: Wilkins, Gosling, Furberg, Franklin, Pauling, Watson and Crick 321 Chapter 19 DNA as a Single- or Multiple-Strand Helix 323 Chapter 20 DNA as a Triple Helix 353 Chapter 21 DNA as a Double Helix 385 Chapter 22 Conclusion 425 Postscript (1994) 445 Bibliography 457 Index 507 xvi