[Extracted from the American Journal of the Medical Sciences for April 1864.] REPORT OP CASES OF HOSPITAL GANGRENE TREATED IN DOUGLAS HOSPITAL, WASHINGTON, D.C. By WILLIAM THOMSON, M. D., ASSISTANT SUKGEON U. S. A. The following histories of cases of hospital gangrene treated in Doug- las Hospital, Washington, serve to illustrate several points of great inte- rest in the etiology, pathology, and treatment of a disease hitherto rare in our military hospitals, and most worthy of careful study. The victims of this disease were wounded at Fredericksburg, Va., Dec. 13th, 1862. For several weeks previous to this battle, the army had been resting on the Rappahannock, and had been exposed to no great hardships. It had been amply supplied with good and varied food, and the men were free from any scorbutic or other cachectic taint. It is well known that the fullest preparations had been made by Surgeon Letterman for that engagement. The operations were performed promptly, and the wounded probably received better care than ever before in the history of the war. On the 26th of December, 1862, about two hundred wounded from the battle of Fredericksburg, were received into the Douglas Hospital. I cannot speak of their treatment, medical, surgical, or hygienic, as at that time I was not connected with the hospital. I am, however, aware that the building in which the gangrene appeared contained fifty badly wounded, and recent cases; that there was a deficiency of medical officers and dressers to insure the necessary cleanliness, and that the sanitary con- dition of the ward was far from perfect. This hospital consists of the three brick houses known as " Minnesota Row;" and two large wooden pavilions, each divided into two wards. The ward in which this disease originated is one hundred and forty- three feet in length, twenty-three feet in breadth, and sixteen feet in height (eighteen feet at the cone, and fourteen at the eaves of the roof), and con- tains beds for fifty patients, thus giving 1050 cubic feet of space for each bed. There are two raws of windows, the lower of which contains two, SL$6 2 the upper one sash each ; the upper windows so constructed as to be opened by means of a cord, but when opened directing a current of cold air imme- diately downwards upon the beds beneath. On the 16th of Feb. 1863, I took charge of the hospital, and found the ward mentioned in the following condition : There was no ridge ventila- tion, nor was there any egress for foul air, except through two large wooden shafts connected with two of the stoves, which had been placed there only a few days previously. The ward was heated by ordinary sheet-iron radi- ating coal stoves ; and no provision had been made, until a few days before, to introduce any supply of fresh air. It contained from forty to fifty patients, all wounded—many of them very severely. The police was not unexceptionable, too little attention having been paid to the removal of offensive discharges. The medical officer in charge preferred to water, as a dressing, either simple cerate or mutton tallow, which had been issued to the hospital, and which had become rancid. The attendants were, from a want of strict discipline, careless and inattentive. There was a perceptible and offensive odour in the ward, which felt close and badly ventilated; and this condition of the atmosphere seemed to have a marked effect on the spirits of the men ; they were all gloomy, despondent, and homesick. On Feb. 17th, when making my first visit with the officer in charge of the ward, I discovered Case I. Sergt. Otto Kosack, Co. K, 2d Md. Vols., who had been struck by a shell, Dec. 13th, 1862, which made it necessary to amputate his left leg at the middle. The operation was done ten minutes after the injury. He was received here on the 26th Dec. The stump closed by granulation, a small portion of the tibia having been removed by exfoliation. The cica- trization had been almost complete, when, a few days previous to the 17th, the still open wound commenced to slough. He was aneemic, very pallid,' haggard, and with an expression of great depression in his features; his pulse was very feeble and rapid. He had been " feeling very badly" for several days, and complained of a burning pain in the stump. On the outer side of the tibia there was an ulcer, one inch in diameter covered with a yellowish-gray, pultaceous slough, and a serous and very fetid discharge; the edges were thickened and everted, and an areola of purple, livid congestion, extended for half an inch from the margin which was undermined. This sore was at once treated with pure nitric acid, applied both to the ulcer and to the areola ; the ulcer was dressed with an antiseptic solution of creasote; and citrate of iron and quinine, with stimulants and nutrients were freely given. On the 18th the sloughing had extended to the border of yesterday's livid areola, but was now more superficial; and the areola, which had likewise invaded the surrounding skin, was more florid. The ulcer was now two inches in diameter. As there was some doubt as to its specific cha- racter, the patient was not removed from the ward until the 23d when he was transferred, with several others, to a small ward prepared in the brick building, and completely isolated from the other wounded men The iron and quinine was found to disturb his stomach and destroy his 3 >m aquas, 3iij. The patient was anaesthetized, and the caustic solution applied most liberally to the entire diseased surface, which was immediately deodorized, and covered with a tough yellow deposit. The sore was then covered with a piece of dry lint, a second piece of lint, wet with the bromine solution, was placed over it, upon this a piece of muslin spread with cerate, and over all a piece of oiled silk, confined closely with a roller, was bound; and the local effect of bromine was thus continued in the form of vapour. The burning pain disappeared; the antiseptic effect of bromine seemed to restore the appetite by destroying the virus that had been poisoning the whole system, and, for the first time for many days, he took some food. May 4. The exposure of the surface of the body to the air at this application of the bromine was followed by a severe attack of bronchitis, with viscid and bloody expectoration, and severe dyspnoea, which was treated by warm cataplasms to the chest, and by expectorants. 1th. The ulceration has ceased, the odour disappeared, and the surface is now clean and rosy. The vapour has been used twice daily. An imme- diate improvement followed the use of bromine, both locally and constitu- tionally. The pain, diarrhoea, and profuse perspiration ceased, the appetite returned, and the nervous prostration soon yielded to the extra diet and stimulants. The bromine was used twice in solution, and continued in the form of vapour until the granulations became normal. 23d. He is convalescent, and the ulcer entirely cicatrized. The bromine produced this gratifying change, after the entire failure of nitric acid ; nor do I hesitate to affirm that, but for its employment, the case would have terminated fatally. Case IX. George Zilch, Sergeant Co. K, 7th N. Y. Vols., aged 25, had his left leg amputated at its upper third, for a bullet wound received at Fredericksburg, Va,, Dec. 13th, 1862. He was admitted to Douglas Hospital December 26th, and placed in Ward No. 5. The stump had closed slowly by granulation, until there remained an ulcer as large as a half dime on its face. April 14, 1863. This ulcer was inflamed around its edges, and covered with a white pultaceous slough; there was no constitutional disturbance, and the patient was allowed to remain on his crutches. The ulcer was cauterized with nitric acid, and dressed with solution sodae chlorinatae. lath. The ulceration and areola are both enlarged, and the slough, yet very tough, is thicker. Acid was again used locally. 21s/. He is feverish, and inclined to nausea; his pulse 120, skin hot, and tongue thickly coated. The ulcer is extending in depth, and he was removed to the gangrene ward. 22d. The solution of bromine was applied to the sore after cleansing the surface as much as possible of the tenacious slough, nis general con- dition was unfavourable, and there was a tendency to diarrhoea and perspi- ration. Internally he took muriatic acid, with extra diet and stimulants. 24/ft. Bromine was again applied to the surface, and used in the form of vapour. The ulcer was now three inches in diameter, irregularly circular in form, with ragged, everted, and thickened edges, and surrounded by a purple areola. The slough was one inch in thickness, and resisted the action of the bromine. 26//). The sore is looking better; it has been disinfected since the first application of bromine, and the constitutional symptoms are better. 27//). A painting in oil was made to-day by Surgeon Brinton's direction, which would be pronounced a good representation of hospital gangrene. 28//). The slough is much thinner to-day, and the granulations are showing through the thin gray covering. 29//). The sore is much better, is becoming covered with granulations, and has lost almost entirely its specific appearance. There is no constitu- tional disturbance, no fever, no headache ; the tongue is cleaning off, and there is a return of the appetite. The bromine vapour was discontinued, and a sol. sod. chlorinat. substituted. BOth. The livid areola has been changing daily in hue under the bromine treatment, has now entirely disappeared, aud the sore is perfectly healthy. May 6. He is still improving, and is taking tonics and nutrients. 20//). The sore is reduced to half its original size, and is now cicatrizing rapidly. 24th. There is now a surface as large as a penny unhealed. The patient's health is very good; he is about the ward on crutches, and is no longer considered an interesting case. We have in this case another instance in which the acid, locally used, proved useless, and in which the solution of bromine caused an immediate improvement. It was found necessary to apply the caustic solution to the ulcer three times, owing to the thickness of the slough, which was too closely attached to be removed by spatula or forceps. Its action here seemed to be to correct the fetor at once, to check the molecular death, and to change the hue of the areola, by causing a more healthy action in the capillaries. The gnawing, burning pain was relieved, and the patient was able to sleep in comfort. The absorption of the virus produced in the ulcer was prevented by its destruction, and the nervous system quickly regained its tone. This man steadily improved, recovered with a good stump, and was finally sent to New York to be mustered out of the service. I will conclude this brief clinical history by a short summary. Etiology.—This disease made its appearance in a wooden pavilion, con- taining fifty beds, most of them occupied by very seriously wounded men unable to leave the building, with a cubic capacity of 1050 feet to each bed, heated by ordinary radiating coal stoves, devoid of any system of ventila- tion, and having no ingress for pure air, nor egress for foul, except through the windows and doors. This want of pnre air was combined with a want of strict police, and a careless and unscientific method of dressing the 13 • &t*7 wounds, rancid ointments being largely used instead of the ordinary water dressing. No case of gangrene was received as such into the hospital, nor is it probable that it was otherwise introduced. Although a majority of the cases in this ward escaped gangrene, yet there was evidently some depressing agent at work, since but few wounds healed rapidly. The patients seemed also dispirited, homesick, and moody. Those who were attacked were removed to a ward in the brick house, where they were isolated, and at the same time placed under better hygienic influences. Two shafts for foul air, connected with the stoves, which withdrew the foul air from near the floor, had recently been placed in the ward by order of the Surgeon-General. This was not considered sufficient, and the long doors of these foul air shafts were kept constantly open. Strict attention to cleanliness and careful dressing was enforced, and, what might have been a very severe epidemic, was confined to few cases. The upper row of win- dows were rehung in such a manner as to direct the currents of cold air admitted in a line with the roof, and, to crown all, the ridge ventilation was applied to the pavilion. These precautions, and an improvement in the diet of the house, giving more vegetables and antiscorbutics, enabled me to prevent any further seri- ous manifestations. No. Names. Ward. Side. West Date of attack. Grade of disease. Result. Treatment. 1 Otto Kossacke 5 Feb. 15, 1S63 Ulceration Cured Nitric acid. 2 L D. Thurston 5 " 15, " Spliacelus Death •« 3 Sam'l Fos«ett 5 " 18, " Ulceration Cured " 4 C. Underwood 3 East 20, " " mild " " 5 J. Wick 5 West 28, " Sphacelus 1 Death " 6 Pat Murrissey 5 " March 6, " Ulceration Cured " 7 J. Jordan 5 East Feb. 27, " " " " 8 R. W. Plummer 1 Building March 9, " " " Bromine. 9 Geo. Zilch 5 East April 14, " " 1 There were three other wards of like construction, with Ward No. 5, but two of them were unoccupied, and the third one contained fewer, and less serious cases. The foregoing table indicates that of the nine unmistakable cases re- ported, eight appeared in Ward No. 5 ; and that of these eight five occur red on the west, and three on the east side of the ward. Although these facts would suggest the probability of inoculation, yet I cannot but remem- ber that there were at least thirty-five other wounded men in this ward who escaped, although the disease had been in existence several days before Feb. 17th, when I took charge, and no precautious against contagion had been employed. I shall not attempt to argue here the long-disputed point of contagion or non-contagion, but simply state it as the result of my observation, that I saw no well-marked instance of inoculation, whilst I did see many wounds t &+48 14 escape this influence where inoculatiou was not only possible, but probable. Nor was it necessary to invoke the aid of any specific virus, since the unfavourable hygienic influences which had surrounded these men from the date of injury, Dec. 13th, and the date of admission into hospital, Dec. 26th, 1862, to Feb. 15th, 1863, were sufficient to produce, in all the cases treated in Ward 5, a well-marked cachexia—neither scorbutus nor anaemia, but more unmanageable than either, and due, most probably, to the absence, simply, of fresh, pure air in sufficient quantities. With no further improvements than those mentioned, a marked change for the better took place in the other inmates of this ward. Their wounds became healthy, and healed rapidly, and their spirits became cheerful. It will be observed from the table that I have described two grades of hospital gangrene, the one mild, generally manageable, and characterized by ulceration or molecular death of the tissues, spending itself generally in the subcutaneous and intermuscular connective tissue ; the other, more rapid in its course, more fatal, less amenable to treatment, and distinguished by sphacelus or mortification, en masse, of the invaded tissues. It will be seen that of the nine cases, seven are described as ulceration, and two sphacelus, and the latter both fatal. These two cases last mentioned were entirely uninfluenced by the treatment employed. The rapid invasion and advance of the mortification, and the impossibility of reaching it with nitric acid, to influence it locally, left but little to do, but to observe its profoundly depressing effect on the vital forces. Bromine may prove the antidote in such cases, but its virtues were then unknown to me. Treatment.—Recognizing the depressed condition of the first few cases, I endeavoured to remedy it by giving at short intervals nutrients and sti- mulants, with such tonics as seemed proper; and milk punch, alternating with beef essence, porter or ale, and egg-nog, was at first given, regardless of the desires of the patient. The ferri et quin. cit. with sherry wine was given in doses of gr. vj to x three times daily. This system was found injudicious, since it overpowered the feeble digestive organs, and caused nausea, vomiting, and diarrhoea; it was suspended, and acid, hydrochloric. gtt. iv, in combination with tr. opii gtt. xvj, were given every three hours. Under this treatment the tongue became moist and clean, and the appetite returned sufficiently to cause the patient to ask for and enjoy a reasonable quantity of food. The opium was given to allay the gnawing pain and to give rest and sleep, as well as to obtain any specific influence over the dis- ease which it might possess, as claimed for it by the older writers. The local treatment consisted at first in the use of undiluted nitric acid, freely applied to the entire surface of the ulcer. The table indicates the success of that treatment. Of the nine cases, all were treated with the acid in the earlj stages. Of these, two were fatal, and two resisted the acid ; or, in other words, in four cases it was useless. Of these four, the two 15 "&*p fatal cases were not treated otherwise, whilst the other two were treated with success, with bromine. The five cases treated successfully with acid are marked ulceration, and were milder than those that proved fatal, or than those that were treated with bromine successfully. The dressing, after the use of the acid, was an antiseptic wash, either creasote or liq. sod. chlor. in a dilute solution. In some instances a yeast poultice, or a stimulating one of cinchona, ginger, and porter, seemed to assist in cleaning the surface. Where the sore lost its sloughing character, after the use of nitric acid, the mild antiseptic washes were sufficient to encourage rapid granulation. Of more value than the acid is the solution of bromine%in water and bromide of potassium, proposed by Surgeon Goldsmith, U. S. Vols. Two cases were treated with this agent, in both of which nitric acid had failed. One of these would, doubtless, have proved fatal, whilst the other was progressing rapidly, although the acid had been used several times without benefit. The action of the bromine is that of a caustic; all the necrosed tissues are converted into tough yellow shreds, and are perfectly deodorized. The ulceration seems to be checked at once, whilst the nervous system, no longer depressed by the absorption of the fetid products of the mortification, soon recovers from its depression. The areola loses its livid hue, becomes more crimson, and finally disappears; the sloughs are rapidly thrown off, and a rosy, florid surface appears beneath. The bromine was also used in the form of vapour, confined to the surface by oiled silk. Its antiseptic influence is very powerful, since not the least odour could be perceived on dressing these gangrenous sores, even when they had been covered closely with oiled silk for twelve hours. From its antidotal efficacy in these two cases, I have formed a high opinion of its value in the local treatment of this disease. Microscopy.—The discharges from several of these cases were examined, to ascertain whether some of the speculative views in regard to the presence of fungi and their influence in producing the disease could be sustained, but no fungi were found. The discharge consisted of fluid, granular matter, and debris. The connective tissue seemed to have been broken down into unrecognizable granular material. The fibrous tissue was softened and easily teazed out, and in the muscular tissue the striated appearance was lost before the fibrous. No evidence of textural growth was found in the discharges, although the "piled-up" and thickened margins of the ulcers would probably reveal, on examination, a multiplication of the connective tissue-corpuscles, as re- ported in a similar group of cases at Annapolis, Md.,by Assistant Surgeon Woodward, U. S. A. Since the preceding report was drawn up, four other cases of hospital $.60 u gangrene have been observed, occurring sporadically, and treated with success with bromine. Their clinical histories are very briefly offered for consideration, in addition to those already submitted. No other cases have occurred in this hospital. It will be observed that three of these four cases were fully treated with pure nitric acid without benefit, and that the four did yield eventually to the local application of bromine. Where that remedy has required heretofore several repetitions, it would now be used more energetically. The diseased surface would be thoroughly cleansed of all sloughs, by removing those portions dead, yet tenaciously adherent, with the forceps and scissors, and pure bromine would be freely used by means of a glass pipette or a syringe. A number of the cases reported I am now satisfied would have proved fatal but for this local treatment; and it will be a proud satisfaction to Surgeon Goldsmith to know that he has not only already been instrumental in preserving so many valuable lives, but that he has provided the military surgeon with a defence against one. of the most deadly and obdurate of his antagonists. In conclusion, the writer regrets that circumstances do not permit him to render these clinical histories more acceptable to the critical reader. The report was made to the Surgeon General for the future use of the surgical historian of the war, and now meets the public eye in this crude form because it has been represented that further evidence as to the virtues of bromine might be of service in the exigencies of the coming campaign. Case X. Michael Flood, age 24, priv. Co. D, 33d NY. Vols., was struck by a minie ball at the battle of Chancellorsville, May 3d, 1863, which en- tered the right thigh anteriorly, comminuted the femur for four inches at the junction of the middle and upper third, and escaped posteriorly. He was admitted on the 8th of May. This man had been suffering from diar- rhoea, and was in a feeble condition. The usual profuse suppuration fol- lowed the injury, thus reducing his strength still further. The Teg was lightly dressed, was supported by sand-bags, and extended by means of a brick attached to the limb by a band of adhesive plaster. On July 23d, the inner surface of the thigh, at its middle, was found red and inflamed oppo- site the seat of fracture, and in the centre of this diffused redness there was a spot very tender on pressure, slightly softened, and indicating an ap- proaching abscess. This was treated with a poultice. On the 24th, a small black spot of sphacelus was observed in the centre of this inflamed region, which was easily detached, and then revealed a sloughing condition of the connective tissue. No previous abrasion of the skin existed, nor any wound which would have permitted of inoculation ; nor was there any other case of gangrene then under treatment. The diarrhoea simultaneously increased, and the patient's condition became rapidly worse. The ulcer was treated with the solution of bromine and bromide of potassium. This was followed on the following day by pure nitric acid, with the apparent effect of adding to the rapid de- struction of tissue. On the 27th, the ulcer was in dimensions five by four inches, with irregular ragged edges, everted, thickened, and extensively un- dermined at the margins ; and, in a word, presented the characteristics of severe hospital gangrene. It was now thoroughly treated with pure bro- mine. The improvement was marked ; the ulcer became deodorized ; lost rapidly its sloughing, ragged look ; became clean, then florid, from rapid granulation, and in a few days was converted into a perfectly healthy, rosy surface. The man's broken condition gave no hope of his recovery. There was still a free discharge from his fractured femur, his diarrhoea continued unchecked, and from these he sank exhausted, and died on the 6th of Au- gust. The gangrene here did not attack the gunshot wound through which the discharge from the seat of fracture escaped, but invaded a new unwounded surface, and one upon which no abrasion was known to exist. The gangrene was perfectly removed previous to his death. Case XI. P. C. Barton, Co. D, 26th New York, age 25, was struck at Chancellorsville, May 23d, 1863, by a piece of shell, which comminuted with extensive laceration the right tibia and fibula, at the middle, and fractured the right femur at the junction of the lower and middle third. This was a most severe wound, since the soft parts were so greatly injured. He was admitted on the 8th, his leg placed in a bran-box, and slight ex- tension attempted by fastening the foot to the foot-board and elevating the lower end of the bedstead. Profuse discharge and occasional attacks of diarrhoea reduced his strength, whilst his wounds were undergoing rapid repair. On July 1st, he was removed to a ward filled with other wounded men, and in a few days the granulating wound on his leg became grayish, and the discharge thin and offensive. The wound of the thigh had almost closed. This was recognized as mild hospital gangrene, and was treated with strong nitric acid, followed by yeast poultices. No improvement fol- lowed. The cicatrized tissue, the offspring of the previous repair, was rapidly removed, the ulceration spread under the sound integument, and the sore assumed the characteristic appearance of gangrene. Stimulants and mineral acids were given internally, but rapid emaciation and general prostration ensued from the continuance of the diarrhoea. The sore was then treated with the solution of bromine, but required several applications to check the ulceration. Pure bromine would now be employed in such a case. This man was moved to a better ward on July 30th, and the ulcer was then seven inches in length by four in width, occupying the outer side of the right leg. Soon after his removal an abscess formed in the outer portion of the . right thigh, the pus was evacuated, and gangrene immediately attacked the walls of the cavity; this extended with great rapidity, became four by three in extent in two days, and was immediately arrested by the bromine. No hope whatever was entertained of this man's recovery. A severe commi- nuted fracture of both bones of the leg, a compound fracture of the same femur, and two severe attacks of gangrene, combined with an obstinate diarrhoea, had brought him to the last stages of exhaustion. By the 12th of August his ulcers were normal in appearance, and were granulating rapidly; the bones had united, and his diarrhoea had been checked by ni- trate of silver and opium. The improvement was gradual, but constant; his stomach recovered its tone, the quantity of food was increased ; his whole condition became more favourable, and he was finally sent home on the 20th of September, his term of service having expired. He was able to travel safely, and his wounds were almost closed. Case XII. Wm. Hutchinson, age 32, Co. F, 107th New York, was struck by a bullet at Chancellorsville, May 3d, 1863, in the middle of the 2 161 18 right tibia, which comminuted the bone, without, however, fracturing it through. He was admitted June 17th; the wound was discharging freely, and, shortly after his admission, several fragments of bone were removed. He was kept quiet in bed and his leg dressed with water. On the 10th of August the open wound lost its healthy look, and the discharge became thin and offensive. On the 18th the case was beyond doubt a mild one of hos- pital gangrene. There were the burning pain, the livid areola, the thick- ened everted edges, and the deep, tenacious, gray slough occupying the former seat of the opening. No effort was made to remove this necrosed tissue, and hence the application of the pure bromine produced less than the usual effect. For six days after the 18th the bromine was applied daily, and followed by yeast poultices. No ulceration occurred after the first application ; but at the expiration of the time stated, a florid, healthy surface replaced the gangrenous one; the excavation was deep and exten- sive enough to contain a large egg. After this complication the wound filled up rapidly, the man received a furlough, but was enfeebled by the long- continued discharge resulting from local necrosis. Case XIII. James Hogan, age 47, private, Co. A, 127th Pa. Vols., was struck at Fredericksburg, Va., December 13th, 1862, by a minie ball which comminuted his right tibia. A resection of six inches of the shaft was performed at a field hospital. The fibula was uninjured. A tedious and almost hopeless convalescence, and the removal of sequestra from both upper and lower extremities of the tibia, found him, after the closure of the extensive incision, in good health, and with only a very small granulating surface near the tubercle of the tibia unhealed. This was attacked by hos- pital gangrene, was treated ineffectually with nitric acid, and penetrated so deeply as to make the involvement of the knee-joint probable. _ Two or three applications of pure bromine at once checked the destruc- tive action, but not until an opening large enough to receive a hen's egg had been produced. The granulation was rapid; the constitutional symp- toms of gangrene soon disappeared, and the man recovered with a per- fectly useless leg, since a hiatus of eight inches remained between the two extremities of the tibia. He was sent home on Oct. 12th, 1863, in good health, his term of service having expired. Douglas Hospital, Washington, D. C. £63 CfZ. 7X.IV 2 6*+